As reports this week from Scotland and Israel where much or most of the population have gotten Covid jabs confirm that vaccines largely prevent people from getting sick, another question is emerging: do they also block infection?
A lot depends on the answer, experts say.
If vaccines being rolled out worldwide ward off not only symptoms but the virus itself, it could sharply slow the pathogen's spread and hasten the return to normalcy.
"If the true impact on infections was very high, it would be great news because that is what we need for herd immunity," Marc Lipsitch, director of the Center for Communicable Disease Dynamics at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, told AFP.
Herd immunity is achieved when most of a population estimates vary between 60 to 80 percent have acquired defences against a virus, whether through vaccination or because they caught the bug and survived.
But if the Pfizer, Moderna and AstraZeneca vaccines and perhaps others made in China, Russia and India shield poorly against infection, then even people who have rolled up their sleeves to be injected remain potential, unwitting carriers.
"The big concern is that the vaccines prevent illness, hospitalisation and death, but won't sufficiently prevent transmission," Peter English, a UK-based consultant in communicable disease control and former chair of the British Medical Association's Public Health Medicine Committee, told AFP.
Escape variants
In that scenario, communities and economies already reeling from the pandemic face prolonged mask wearing, social distancing and more-or-less hard lockdowns until vaccine campaigns can be completed.
"There is also a greater risk that vaccine 'escape variants' might be thrown up as the virus continues to circulate," English said.
Several such variants more contagious, more deadly or both have already proliferated in England, South Africa and Brazil as the SARS-CoV-2 virus finds it harder to find new hosts, a predictable phase in the evolution of a pandemic.
But recent studies along with others in the pipeline give reason for optimism.
Research covering the entire Scottish population of 5.4 million a fifth innoculated with the Pfizer or Oxford/AstraZeneca jabs provides real-world validation that the vaccines prevent Covid symptoms and illness more than 90 percent of the time.
A study published Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine comparing two groups in Israel of nearly 600,000 persons each, one vaccinated and the other not also reported reduced illness in line with clinical trials.
But unlike the research from Scotland, the Israeli findings also showed infections had sharply declined in the vaccinated cohort by 92 percent among those at least one week past the second of two doses.
Encouraging results
The true level of protection may not be that high because Israel does not systematically test for Covid among people with no symptoms, the authors acknowledge.
"They are likely to have failed to detect some asymptomatic cases, and we know that people without symptoms can still transmit the infection," said English.
But the results are still encouraging, he added.
"These findings give us hope that vaccination alone may get the R number below 1," English said, referring to the threshold above which a virus continues to spread.
"If it can and this is the big question we would eventually no longer need to take behavioural measures such as lockdowns or masks to interrupt spread."
But how is it that despite hundreds of studies, as well as rigorous clinical trials involving tens of thousands of people and resulting in more than half-a-dozen successful vaccines, we still do not know yet how well they block infection?
One reason, said Lipsitch, is that when the pandemic began its devastating march across the globe last Spring this was not a priority.
"What the global community cared about most, the question they wanted answered quickly, was how well vaccines prevent disease," he said, noting that clinical trials were designed with that in mind.
"We got answers quickly," he added. "But we wouldn't have if we had tried to do too many things at once especially things like measuring impacts on infection."
Asymptomatic to deadly
Another reason is the challenge of tracking a disease affecting millions that ranges in impact from zero symptoms to death.
"Trying to work out how many people are asymptomatic but potentially infectious is difficult," said English.
"How do you identify them unless you are routinely testing everybody?"
On top of that, even the best measures of infection -- so-called PCR tests -- are only about 70 percent sensitive outside laboratory conditions, he added.
But to what extent vaccines impact infection is likely to come into focus soon.
"The limited data available suggests that vaccines will at least partly reduce transmission, and the studies to determine this with more clarity are underway," Angela Rasmussen, a virologist at the Center for Global Health Science and Security at Georgetown University Medical Center, wrote Wednesday in the New York Times.
One of the most promising signals so far has come from the clinical trials for the Moderna vaccine developed in the United States.
"When people came in for their second shot, they were tested for virus in the nose," commented Lipsitch, who is writing a study interpreting the data.
"There was a more than 60 percent reduction in the proportion who had virus on Day 28 if they got the vaccine, rather than a placebo, on Day Zero."
If anything, the effect was even larger, he added.
ETX Studio
Fri Feb 26 2021
If vaccines being rolled out worldwide ward off not only symptoms but the virus itself, it could sharply slow the pathogen's spread and hasten the return to normalcy. ETXStudiopic
Tindak balas antarabangsa bantu mangsa Taufan Yagi di Myanmar diperlukan
Taufan Yagi melanda utara Myanmar pada 10 September, menyebabkan banjir teruk, tanah runtuh dan kemusnahan meluas di seluruh negara.
Populasi warga emas berusia 100 tahun di Jepun melebihi 95,000
Bilangan penduduk berusia sekurang-kurangnya 100 tahun di Jepun dianggarkan mencecah 95,119 orang pada September.
Pantai Port Dickson tumpuan pengunjung musim cuti sekolah
Pantai peranginan di Port Dickson menjadi tumpuan pengunjung dari seluruh pelosok negeri untuk berkelah bersama keluarga sempena musim cuti persekolahan ini.
Malaysia melihat kemampanan industri nadir bumi dengan potensi semakan perundangan
Ia untuk menilai keperluan pelarasan bagi pengawasan cekap sektor unsur nadir bumi bukan radioaktif (NR-REE).
23 projek rumah mampu milik akan dibina menerusi RMK-12
Kesemua projek berkenaan akan menyediakan lebih 7,000 unit RMM, yang dibina khusus untuk membantu golongan berpendapatan rendah (B40).
Rusia, Malaysia jalin kerjasama dalam pelancongan mesra Muslim
Rusia dan Malaysia sedia utingkatkan pelancongan mesra Muslim menerusi kerjasama baharu antara badan pensijilan halal Rusia, Roskachestvo dan Pusat Pelancongan Islam Malaysia.
IShowSpeed tiba di KL, terima baju batik daripada peminat
Speed menerima hadiah daripada beberapa orang peminat Malaysia ketika kenderaannya berhenti di lampu isyarat di ibu negara pada Selasa,
Penyanyi Sean Diddy ditangakp di New York
Penerbit muzik terkenal, Puff Daddy atau lebih dikenali sebagai Sean Diddy Combs yang berdepan dengan beberapa tuduhan serangan seksual telah diberkas di Manhatann, New York oleh ejen persekutuan pada Isnin waktu tempatan.
10 maut, puluhan cedera bas Iran terbalik
Menurut angka awal, kemalangan itu mengakibatkan 10 maut dan 41 cedera.
Malaysia perlu melabur dalam infrastruktur
Pengarah Eksekutif Ukrainian Prism, Hennadiy Maksak berpandangan, Malaysia juga tidak boleh bergantung kepada satu laluan, selain menjalin hubungan yang baik dengan negara-negara jiran.
Amazon arahkan pekerja kembali bekerja di pejabat lima hari seminggu
Pekerja Amazon diarah kembali bekerja sepenuh masa di pejabat, dengan menekankan kepentingan bekerja secara bersemuka.
Makanan tradisional Bajau Seri Semporna ubati kerinduan perantau
Meskipun nasib tidak menyebelahi Azreena apabila terpaksa menutup restoran ketika musim pandemik, setahun kemudian mereka mampu bangkit kembali.
Pesta Air Kuala Perlis medium rapatkan hubungan masyarakat
Pesta Air Kuala Perlis antara acara tradisi di Perlis sejak tahun 50-an, kini kembali selepas kali terakhir dianjurkan pada 2019.
MyPELINDUNG 2024: Jamin kehidupan selamat bersama COVID-19
Kempen MyPELINDUNG 2024 terus membantu rakyat Malaysia untuk menyesuaikan diri dengan norma baharu.
Konsulat Malaysia di Pontianak anjur majlis resepsi Hari Kebangsaan ke-67
Konsulat Malaysia di Pontianak, Kalimantan Barat mengadakan majlis resepsi Hari Kebangsaan ke-67 pada malam Sabtu yang dihadiri 300 tetamu termasuk Pemangku Gabenor Kalimantan Barat, Harisson dan iste
Semua PLC perlu adakan mesyuarat agung secara hibrid atau fizikal mulai 1 Mac 2025
Semua syarikat awam tersenarai (PLC) di Bursa Malaysia perlu mengadakan mesyuarat agung secara hibrid atau fizikal mulai 1 Mac, 2025, menurut Suruhanjaya Sekuriti Malaysia (SC) dan Bursa Malaysia Bhd.
Ini lapangan terbang miliki sambungan penerbangan terbaik di dunia
Lapangan Terbang iGA Istanbul, yang dibuka pada 2018, muncul lapangan terbang yang mempunyai sambungan terbaik di dunia.
COVID-19: Lonjakan kes memungkinkan wad kecemasan ditutup di Korea Selatan
Persatuan Perubatan Korea Selatan memberi amaran bahawa lonjakan kes COVID-19 dan mogok berterusan oleh doktor pelatih memungkinkan banyak wad kecemasan di Korea Selatan ditutup bulan hadapan.
Wabak mpox: Lindungi golongan rentan, individu imuniti rendah - Pakar kesihatan
Kumpulan yang memiliki imuniti rendah antaranya adalah pesakit kanser, wanita hamil, warga tua serta kanak-kanak.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.