KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's highest court on Friday found news portal Malaysiakini in contempt of court over comments posted by readers deemed offensive to the judiciary, in a case widely seen as a test of media freedom in the Southeast Asian nation.
Last year, Malaysia's attorney general filed an application to cite Malaysiakini and editor-in-chief Steven Gan for contempt over five comments posted by readers on its website that it said undermined public confidence in the judiciary.In a six to one decision on Friday, a Federal Court panel found Malaysiakini was fully responsible for publishing the readers' comments that "undermined the system of justice in the country" and fined the news portal 500,000 ringgit.
"The impugned statements had gone far and wide... the content was spurious and reprehensible in nature and the content involved allegations of corruption which were unproven and untrue," said judge Rohana Yusuf, who chaired the panel.
The fine was more than double the 200,000 ringgit prosecutors had sought, though the court cleared Gan of any offence. Malaysiakini and Gan had maintained that they could not be held responsible and that the offending comments had been immediately removed after they were contacted by police.
In a country with a highly regulated media often dominated by state-controlled groups, Malaysiakini has been a platform for the opposition and a critic of the establishment.
After the hearing, Gan said he was "very disappointed" with the court's decision, which he said put a burden on news and technology companies to control comments posted by external parties.
"It will have a chilling effect on discussion of public issues in the country and delivers a body blow on our campaign to fight corruption in the country," Gan told a news conference.
It is unlikely Malaysiakini can appeal the verdict because the case was heard before Malaysia's highest court.
The ruling may also have broader implications for how social media companies like Facebook and Twitter manage their sites, especially as the case involved comments by third parties, said Malaysiakini's lawyer, Malik Imtiaz Sarwar.
"I would think it is safe to say that you could similarly take issue with postings or comments on Facebook or Twitter. But it's still premature and I think we should wait for the judgments," he said.
In a brief joint statement, the British and Canadian high commissions raised concerns over the court's decision, saying that media freedom is a "fundamental importance to the security, prosperity and wellbeing of all societies".
Rights groups also spoke out on the ruling.
In a tweet, the Asian Forum for Human Rights and Development said the fact that the fine was double what prosecutors had sought was a sign of judicial harassment against dissenting voices and a failure to protect press freedom.
In January, Gan said reporters should not "give up" in the face of what he described as "harassment" by Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin’s government.
He said in the two decades since he founded Malaysiakini, its journalists had been declared traitors, faced debilitating cyber-attacks, kicked out of press conferences, arrested, and raided by the police.
Malaysia has moved up the World Press Freedom index compiled by Reporters Without Borders in recent years. But rights groups have said freedom of speech and freedom of the press face renewed pressure after an unexpected change to a Muhyiddin government in March last year.
The government had denied that it was clamping down on media freedom.
Reuters
Fri Feb 19 2021
Malaysiakini's editor-in-chief Steven Gan speaks to members of the media at the Federal Court in Putrajaya, Malaysia, February 19, 2021. REUTERSpic
PDRM gerak unit skuba forensik, K9 cari bukti hari ini
Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM) akan menggerakkan unit skuba (Unit Forensik) serta Unit Anjing Pengesan (K9) ke lokasi penemuan mayat Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah, 25, di Kampung Sri Kledang, Hulu Selangor, pagi esok.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Dewan Rakyat: Langkah meknoktahkan kemisikan tegar di Sabah antara tumpuan hari ini
Langkah-langkah untuk meknoktahkan kemiskinan tegar di Sabah terutamanya di lapan daerah yang dikategorikan termiskin di Malaysia antara tumpuan persidangan Dewan Rakyat hari ini.
Kagame, menang 99.5 peratus pilihan raya Rwanda
Paul Kagame meneruskan khidmatnya buat penggal keempat berturut-turut sebagai Presiden Rwanda, selepas memenangi 99.15 peratus undi dalam pilihan raya negara itu.
Polis kerah lebih 300 anggota kawal perlawanan Piala FA
Seramai 351 anggota polis ditugaskan bagi mengawal perlawanan separuh akhir Piala FA antara Terengganu FC (TFC) dengan Selangor FC di Stadium Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin (SSMZA) Jumaat ini.
Perisik Korea Utara berpaling tadah
Seorang diplomat Korea Utara berprofil tinggi yang ditempatkan di Cuba dikenali sebagai Ri II Kyu, 52 tahun, berpaling tadah ke Korea Selatan.
Dua warga AS antara yang ditemui maut di bilik hotel di Thailand
Jabatan Negara Amerika Syarikat ambil maklum mengenai laporan mengenai dua warganegaranya yang ditemui mati di sebuah hotel di Thailand.
EU tolak label UNRWA sebagai organisasi pengganas
Ketua Dasar Luar Kesatuan Eropah (EU), Josep Borrell mengulangi penolakan blok itu melabel Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) sebagai organisasi pengganas.
Mengimbau sedekad tragedi MH17
Pesawat MH17 Malaysia Airlines ditembak jatuh di timur Ukraine sejurus berlepas dari Lapangan Terbang Schiphol di Amsterdam, mengorbankan kesemua 283 penumpang dan 15 anak kapal di dalamnya.
Tragedi yang berlaku pada 17 Julai 2014 itu, kini memasuki tahun ke-10 kejadiannya.
Tragedi yang berlaku pada 17 Julai 2014 itu, kini memasuki tahun ke-10 kejadiannya.
Kerajaan teliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap, pastikan kewangan negara lebih mampan
Kerajaan sedang meneliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap bagi memastikan pengurusan kewangan negara yang lebih mampan.
PDRM gerak unit skuba forensik, K9 cari telefon, rantai Nur Farah Kartini hari ini
Proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Asyraf Wajdi saman Malaysiakini, Astro AWANI masing-masing RM25 juta
Kata Asyraf, sudah tiba masanya UMNO untuk bersikap lantang dan lebih agresif kerana parti itu sudah lama bersikap gentleman.
Panel 7 hakim tolak permohonan semakan Malaysiakini batal sabitan menghina, denda
Hujahan yang dibangkitkan oleh peguam gagal untuk meyakinkan mahkamah berhubung isu berkaitan dakwaan pelanggaran keadilan asasi.
Pandora Papers: Semua jawatan dalam Kumpulan Kenanga telah dilepaskan pada Jun 2010 - Tengku Zafrul
Tengku Zafrul telah merujuk perkara berkenaan kepada peguamnya untuk mendapatkan nasihat lanjut dan tindakan susulan yang sewajarnya.
Malaysia jatuh 18 anak tangga dalam Indeks Kebebasan Media 2021 - RSF
Malaysia jatuh 18 tangga dari tempat ke-101 pada 2020 ke tempat ke-119 tahun ini.
Saya tidak pernah buat laporan polis terhadap Apandi Ali mengenai 1MDB - Kit Siang
Ketika dicadangkan Lim tidak membuat laporan polis kerana beliau tahu Mohamed Apandi tidak membantu dan bersubahat dalam skandal 1MDB, Lim berkata beliau tidak bersetuju.
Kemaluan dipotong, dicampak selepas dipaksa ketuk ketampi
Mengerikan! Seorang lelaki warganegara Pakistan berusia 32 tahun berdepan detik ngeri dalam hidupnya apabila kemaluannya dipotong sekumpulan lelaki yang tidak dikenali di Klang, Selangor baru-baru ini
Indonesia bukan negara Islam walaupun penduduk majoriti Muslim - Ma'ruf
Ma'ruf memaklumkan bahawa kerukunan antara agama di republik itu harus dijaga, antaranya dengan menghormati kepelbagaian rakyat.
Komen berbaur hasutan, polis buka kertas siasatan terhadap Steven Gan dan Charles Santiago
Ia dipercayai berhubung reaksi mereka terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Persekutuan yang mendapati Mkini Dot Com Sdn Bhd bersalah Jumaat lepas.
Malaysiakini bersalah siar komen pembaca
Keputusan dibuat panel tujuh Hakim Mahkamah Persekutuan, yang dipengerusikan Presiden Mahkamah Rayuan, Tan Sri Datuk Rohana Yusuf.
Sesi PdPR terganggu, murid 'tayang' video lucah ketika guru mengajar
Cikgu N berkata tindakan yang di luar jangkaan itu memaksa beliau terus menghentikan sesi PdPR serta-merta.