A specter is haunting Europe - the specter of nationalism.
For now, though, it's mostly just that: a specter. It hasn't been able to move beyond its phantasmological form and actually take power outside of Hungary and Poland. Everywhere else on the continent, mainstream parties have managed to keep the new, old breed of rabidly right-wing nationalists from taking the reins of government the past decade. How have they done this, even in the aftermath of the worst financial crisis in 80 years?
Well, it turns out, the center actually can hold - so long as the center-right helps out.
That, at least, is the lesson of the relentlessly technocratic Emmanuel Macron's bigger-than-expected blowout of the anti-immigrant and anti-European Union Marine Le Pen in France's presidential election. Even double-digit unemployment and semi-regular terror attacks weren't enough for Le Pen's far-right National Front to get anywhere close to 51 percent of the vote, especially as every other party treated them like political pariahs. Which is worth thinking about. Why did they?
After all, Republican elites in the United States ended up embracing then-Candidate Trump's equally extreme brand of populism that, like its French counterpart, called for banning Muslims, ripping up trade deals that were supposedly ripping the country off, and cozying up to Russia. So why didn't France's Republican elites - that's what they call their center-right party as well - do the same?
A few reasons. First off, Le Pen didn't take over her country's chief conservative party like Trump did. Instead, she took over her father's radical right party that's been trying to replace its Holocaust denial with a more socially acceptable hatred of Muslim immigrants. So there wasn't any partisan pressure on run-of-the-mill conservatives to support her. Second, in France, the ideological stakes between the center-right and center-left weren't so big that one felt like it couldn't vote for the other. The straitjacket that is the euro means that there's a lot of truth to the idea that they're just competing to see who gets to implement Germany's policy preferences. But third, and most important, is France's historical memory of itself. Not of 1789's "liberté, égalité, fraternité," but of 1940's "travail, famille, patrie" - the slogan of the collaborationist Vichy regime. That was the last time the far-right got control of the state, and it's the last time the rest of the country wants that to happen. The result has been a long-lasting taboo against being a stooge for a party that started out defending Nazi stooges.
The far-right, then, can only do as well as the center-right will let it. And that's not just true today. It always has been.
See, on the one hand, economists have found that it's the radical right that does the best after financial crises. When people aren't getting what they think they deserve, they look around to see who's getting more than they supposedly should - and then blame them. Sometimes that's the bankers who might have caused the crash, but more often it's people they come across in their everyday lives who they suspect of freeloading. Like the neighbor they don't think should be on disability, or the immigrant they're sure isn't paying taxes.
On the other hand, though, even this hasn't been enough for the far-right to ever get an outright majority - at least not on their own. That's the case whether you're talking about the National Front right now or the National Socialists (Nazis) in the 1930s. Remember, Hitler actually lost his bid for the German presidency in 1932, and the Nazis never won more than 37 percent of the vote in free and fair Reichstag elections. It was only when the conservative Paul von Hindenburg acquiesced to pressure to appoint Hitler to the Chancellorship that the Nazis were able to take over. So if right-wing extremists want to win power - assuming they're using ballots and not bullets - then they need right-wing non-extremists to go along with them.
They haven't in the French elections, or in the Dutch ones, and won't in the German ones later this year. But as Harvard's Daniel Ziblatt explains in "Conservative Parties and the Birth of Democracy," sometimes they're so weak that they can't help it, or feel like they can't afford not to. In other words, a center-right party that doesn't have the institutional wherewithal to control its base or the Machiavellian flair for reaching out to new constituencies might get hijacked by far-right activists or despair that using them is the only way it can win elections anymore. But, like most Faustian bargains, this doesn't tend to work out like they expected. Whatever tax cuts or tariff increases these vested interests thought they'd get are usually forgotten once the radical right actually gets its hands on the levers of power. And before you can say "Weimar," so are things like a free press and an independent judiciary.
The good news is that Europe doesn't have to worry about this spreading for now. But the bad news is that Europe knows it doesn't have to worry about this spreading for now. German Chancellor Angela Merkel has already said that they won't let French President Macron ease up on austerity, except maybe, possibly after he makes it easier for companies to fire workers (and she wins re-election herself). But even then, it's hard to imagine that she'd offer anything macroeconomically significant enough to make much of a difference. Europe seems to be betting that mainstream parties will just continue to quarantine the far-right, and be content to take turns crucifying themselves on a cross of euros, all to keep the 60-year dream of an ever closer union alive, and their people's savings from being devalued.
While you should never underestimate the power of the status quo, this is one of those things that works until it doesn't. Every year, there are more young people who, if they're lucky, might be able to find a job but not a career. And every year, there are fewer old people who grew up in the shadow of Vichy. Indeed, it wasn't idealistic twentysomethings who gave Macron and his doggedly upbeat message his biggest margins, but rather retirees who recoiled at the prospect of the far-right regaining power even 70 years later. That's why Le Pen père was only able to garner 18 percent of the vote when he made the second round of presidential voting back in 2002, but Le Pen fille was almost able to double that to 34 percent. Pressure is building. It won't burst today or tomorrow or even the day after that, but what about after the next recession? The far-right might not need much help by that point.
Which brings us to the real problem: everything seems impossible in Europe. It doesn't seem conceivable that a country could actually leave the euro, since just talking about that scares people into wanting to stay. Nor does it seem conceivable that they could build the United States of Europe it would take for the euro to work, since just talking about that scares people about losing their sovereignty. So they just muddle on. All the while, though, the far-right is slowly rising, and the center-right is slowly forgetting.
The nationalists of the world won't unite, but they might lose their metaphorical chains.
The Washington Post
Thu May 11 2017
Le Pen didn't take over her country's chief conservative party like Trump did.
PM mahu persediaan mantap dilakukan menjelang kepengerusian ASEAN 2025
Perdana Menteri berkata Malaysia perlu menjadi peneraju hebat dengan menyusun pelbagai program yang benar-benar memberi kesan mendalam kepada komuniti ASEAN secara keseluruhannya.
PM Anwar ulangi komitmen Malaysia jayakan Agenda 2030 untuk pembangunan mampan
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini mengulangi komitmen Malaysia dalam menjayakan Agenda 2030 untuk pembangunan mampan seperti yang dimeterai bersama 192 negara lain pada 2015.
HUMS dijangka siap Dis 2025, beroperasi pada Jan 2026 - Zambry
HUSM dibina dengan kapasiti 400 katil, 25 bilik pembedahan, 40 katil rawatan intensif atau rapi serta 145 buah klinik pakar.
Seorang ahli GISB akan dituduh di Mahkamah Majistret Putrajaya esok
Individu terbabit akan didakwa di bawah Seksyen 506 Kanun Keseksaan.
Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional mudahkan operasi perdagangan - Tengku Zafrul
Inisiatif Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional (National Single Window) yang bakal diharmonikan bersama sistem kastam China akan memudahkan operasi perniagaan dan perdagangan antara Malaysia-China.
'Abang Bas' bebas selepas bayar ikat jamin RM40,000
'Abang Bas' yang ditahan di Pusat Koreksional, Muar, sejak Selasa lalu kerana gagal membayar ikat jamin keseluruhan berjumlah RM40,000 dibebaskan, selepas membayar semua bayaran.
10 Berita Pilihan - (17 September 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
AWANI Ringkas: PN tolak draf MoU kerana ada niat tersirat - Muhyiddin
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Ahmad Zahid gesa pemain industri TVET sokong ekosistem industri halal
Ahmad Zahid berkata kewujudan lebih ramai bakat dan pakar dalam sektor halal akan mengukuhkan lagi peranan Malaysia sebagai peneraju global dalam industri.
#AWANIRingkas 17 September 2024 | 9 PM
Berikut merupakan rangkuman berita setakat 9 malam, 17 September 2024
1️⃣ PN tolak draf MoU kerana ada niat tersirat - Muhyiddin
2️⃣ Banjir: cuti anggota, pegawai bomba Kedah dibekukan
3️⃣ 'Abang bas' bebas selepas bayar ikat jamin RM40,000
#awaniringkas
1️⃣ PN tolak draf MoU kerana ada niat tersirat - Muhyiddin
2️⃣ Banjir: cuti anggota, pegawai bomba Kedah dibekukan
3️⃣ 'Abang bas' bebas selepas bayar ikat jamin RM40,000
#awaniringkas
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Cubaan bunuh: Trump ucap terima kasih kepada perkhidmatan rahsia pastikannya "selamat"
Trump mengucapkan terima kasih kepada semua pihak atas keprihatinan mereka terhadap cubaan bunuh yang menimpanya pada Ahad di Florida.
FBI siasat "cubaan bunuh" selepas insiden tembakan berhampiran Trump
Insiden tembakan berhampiran bekas Presiden Amerika Syarikat Donald Trump pada Ahad disiasat sebagai "yang kelihatan seperti cubaan bunuh".
Biden lega Trump tidak cedera selepas cubaan bunuh
Presiden Amerika Joe Biden lahirkan rasa lega kerana bekas presiden Donald Trump tidak cedera berikutan cubaan membunuh.
Trump selamat cubaan bunuh di Florida
Pegawai penguat kuasa undang-undang menyatakan, penembak bersembunyi di kawasan semak berhampiran sempadan padang golf.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Trump tidak akan sertai satu lagi debat presiden bersama Harris
Trump mendakwa beliau memenangi debat yang dihoskan oleh ABC News di Philadelphia pada malam Selasa.
Debat Presiden AS tarik 57.5 juta penonton TV - Data Nielsen
Debat malam Selasa itu merupakan kali pertama calon-calon dalam Pilihan Raya Presiden 5 November bertemu secara bersemuka.
Debat calon presiden: Jika Harris menang, Israel tidak akan wujud dua tahun lagi - Trump
Bekas presiden AS itu berkata, Harris "membenci Israel" dan tidak menyokong Perdana Menteri Israel Benjamin Netanyahu.
Pilihan Raya Presiden AS: Debat pertama dengan Trump, Harris sukar diduga
Perdebatan itu adalah yang pertama antara Trump dan Harris, walaupun Trump pada Jun lalu pernah berdebat dengan Presiden AS, Joe Biden.