I don't believe in corporal punishment when it comes to disciplining children and neither do my parents. So I have never laid a finger on my daughter.
I would much prefer to have a heated and honest argument which eventually ends in a better understanding for both parties than a quick smack on the buttocks. But when it comes to Azizul Raheem Awaluddin and Shalwati Nurshal, the Malaysian couple detained in Sweden for 'abusing' their son for not praying, I think I would sway in their defence.
Its quite easy why my rational logic tells me that corporal punishment isn't the way to go with children, because it is just the Islamic way. Islam's main principles are compassion, mercy and sincerity. And that is how I base almost all of my dealings in life with.
What is one of the most common phrase in Islam? Of course it is, bismillahirahmanirahim, which means, in the name of Allah, the most compassionate and most merciful. And there is ikhlas,or sincerity, which is the foundation of any and every single deed in Islam if it were to have any meaning at all.
The prophet Muhammad himself had never hit a woman, child or even animal. So that must say something about the negativities of corporal punishment. But now back to the issue with the Malaysian couple who has been detained while their four children have been separated from them and are in the Swedish foster care system.
Although I don't know the exact details of what actually happened that constituted the abuse, I strongly believe that it wasn't abuse.
Like any Muslim or even Malaysian family, I can imagine that the 'abuse' for not praying would have been a smack on the wrist or even leg. And if we look at it from an Islamic point of view, although it isn't a preferable method of discipline, it could still be an accepted one if: - the parent is not excessive in the physical punishment - the parent is sincere in wanting to teach and correct the child from bad behaviour - the parent does not do it out of anger or frustration - the parents makes sure the child understands why he or she is being punished It would be fine in our Asian culture but not so in Scandinavian culture.
So there is obviously a clash of cultures in this case.
Okay, fine. There may be a law in Sweden that prohibits parents from using any form of physical punishment to discipline their children because it traumatises them.
But in this case, it seems that detaining the parents and putting the children in foster care is causing more trauma to the children than the actual punishment by the parent. And after speaking to Swedish lawyers and reading official reports, it is even more worrying to know that there is a history of exploitation in the Swedish welfare system.
No matter how liberal or how entreched a country is in a full welfare state, they have to see things in context and not just black and white.
Yes, the law may be the law and it is difficult for one country to meddle in another's judicial affair (as many quarters are calling for the Malaysian government to interject).
But throughout the years, I have often been told by many human rights lawyers, activists and even lawmakers in Malaysia of one thing. The law is the law and it needs to be upheld.
But if it is an unjust law, then by all means, we need to fight to abolish it and not to uphold it.
Sweden may be a welfare state from cradle to grave, but they definitely do not own your children.
Sometimes, parents really do know best.
Zan Azlee
Thu Jan 23 2014
AWANI Borneo [18/10/2024] – Perahu karam | Belanjawan 2025 | Pan Borneo dan SSLR
Tumpuan Awani Borneo 18 Oktober 2024 bersama Syaff Shukri
1. Lima peserta latihan regata dikhuatiri lemas di Sungai Sarawak.
2. Pemberian khas Sabah, Sarawak dicadang dinaikan RM600 juta.
3. Pembangunan jalan raya di Sabah, Sarawak terus diperkukuh
1. Lima peserta latihan regata dikhuatiri lemas di Sungai Sarawak.
2. Pemberian khas Sabah, Sarawak dicadang dinaikan RM600 juta.
3. Pembangunan jalan raya di Sabah, Sarawak terus diperkukuh
Tanda retak politik Filipina? Naib Presiden Sara Duterte dakwa Marcos tidak cekap
Sara Duterte mendakwa, Ferdinand Marcos Jr menjalankan pentadbirannya tanpa perancangan jelas.
AWANI Ringkas: Pembentangan Belanjawan 2025
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
#AWANIRingkas 18 Oktober 2024 | 9 PM
Berikut merupakan rangkuman berita setakat 9 malam, 18 Oktober 2024
1️⃣ Pembentangan Belanjawan 2025
2️⃣ Sektor pendidikan
3️⃣ Sektor kesihatan
#awaniringkas
1️⃣ Pembentangan Belanjawan 2025
2️⃣ Sektor pendidikan
3️⃣ Sektor kesihatan
#awaniringkas
Belanjawan 2025: Peruntukan AI dinaikkan sebanyak RM50 juta
Kerajaan komited memperluaskan pendidikan berkaitan Kecerdasan Buatan (AI) ke semua universiti penyelidikan dengan peruntukan RM50 juta, berbanding RM20 juta tahun ini.
UAE hantar tiga lagi pesawat bersama 120 tan bantuan untuk Lubnan
UAE setakat ini telah menghantar 12 pesawat yang membawa 515 tan bekalan bantuan.
Latihan regata bertukar tragedi, lima peserta dikhuatiri lemas
Insiden melibatkan 15 peserta menggunakan satu bot untuk latihan regata. 10 individu berjaya selamatkan diri manakala lima yang lain masih hilang.
Belanjawan 2025: Nak masuk Universiti? Ini cara kerajaan bantu anda
Belanjawan MADANI memperlihatkan komitmen Kerajaan dalam meningkatkan sektor pendidikan tinggi negara.
Belanjawan 2025 sedia platform menyeluruh hadapi cabaran tahun depan - Mohamad Hasan
Langkah-langkah dalam Belanjawan 2025 juga dilihat cuba mengimbangi keperluan rakyat terutama dalam mendepani isu kos sara hidup.
Jumlah kematian di Lubnan terus meningkat
Jumlah kematian akibat serangan udara Israel di Lubnan sejak tercetusnya konflik Israel-Hizbullah pada 8 Oktober 2023 meningkat kepada 2,412.
Anak pasangan M'sia ditahan di Sweden ikuti kelas intensif Bahasa Melayu
Jabatan Kebajikan Masyarakat (JKM) telah menghantar dua lagi laporan berkala kepada Wisma Putra mengenai keadaan empat beradik itu, Jumaat lepas.
Kerajaan usaha dapatkan imuniti pegawai pelancongan di Sweden
Timbalan Menteri Luar Datuk Hamzah Zainuddin bagaimanapun berkata kerajaan akan sentiasa memastikan langkah dibuat mengikut perundangan negara berkenaan.
Azizul dan Shalwati tidak bersalah sehingga dibuktikan sebaliknya - Nazri
Kementerian Pelancongan dan Kebudayaan akan menunggu keputusan perbicaraan sebelum membuat sebarang keputusan untuk mengarahkannya kembali ke Malaysia atau sebaliknya.
Kes pukul anak di Sweden: Anak kenalpasti 'kayu yang berikat' sebagai objek memukulnya
Pendakwa raya telah menayangkan video temubual bersama anak bongsu pasangan tersebut yang berumur tujuh tahun, Arif.
Tourism Malaysia lantik peguam pemerhati perbicaraan kes Azizul dan Shalwati
Ketua Pengarah Tourism Malaysia Datuk Mirza Mohammad Taiyab kini berada di Stockholm untuk memerhati perbicaraan kes Azizul dan Shalwati.
Tuduhan dera: Peguam Shalwati mahu buktikan wujud keraguan munasabah
Peguam Shalwati bersedia membuktikan bahawa wujudnya keraguan munasabah di atas kes yang dibentangkan pendakwaraya.
Empat anak pasangan Malaysia ditahan di Sweden terima berita dengan hati terbuka
Anak ketiga Azizul Raheem Awaluddin dan Norshalwati Norshal akui sedih menerima berita bahawa ibu bapa beliau akan didakwa di Mahkamah Deaerah Stolkholm.
Keluarga rakyat Malaysia yang ditahan di Sweden redha dengan pendakwaan
Perbicaraan kes pasangan itu ditetapkan bermula pada 18 Februari ini dan dijangka mengambil masa 10 hari.
Empat anak pasangan Malaysia ditahan di Sweden mohon tidak diganggu
Kempat-empat anak pasangan tersebut dikatakan sedih dengan berita berkenaan dan tidak ke sekolah pada Selasa.
Pasangan Malaysia di Sweden didakwa pukul anak sejak 2010
Azizul Raheem Awaluddin dan Shalwati Norshal didakwa memukul dan mendera keempat-empat anak mereka dalam beberapa insiden sejak September 2010 sehingga Disember tahun lalu.