Transgenders are female spirits trapped in a male body and they cannot be punished for cross-dressing as it is a fundamental part of their nature, the Court of Appeal here heard today.
Lawyer Aston Paiva submitted that transgenders, also known as "mak nyah", suffer from a chronic medical condition call gender identity disorder (GID) whose inner psychology was not congruent with the physical body.
He is representing three Muslim bridal make-up artists who are challenging a Negeri Sembilan Syariah criminal law which prosecutes Muslim transgenders who dress like women.
Paiva said persons with the disorder would cross-dress as they feel the essence of their identity to be that of a woman and wear women's clothing to express themselves as women.
"Medical evidence show GID is not a question of choice. Nobody decides to have GID. It afflicts you," he said, adding that they could not be changed with pharmalogical medicine or pyschological therapy.
He said to penalise a transgender for an attribute they did not choose nor could change, it would mean to accept apartheid and racial genocide.
Paiva said Section 66 (of the syariah enactment involved) did not apply to persons who suffer from GID, adding that the section infringed Article 10 (1)(a), Article 5(1) and Article 8(2) of the Federal Constitution which respectively guarantees freedom of expression, right to personal liberty and prohibit discrimination on grounds of religion, race or gender.
Muhamad Juzaili Mohamad Khamis, 26, Syukor Jani, 28, and Wan Fairol Wan Ismail, 30, are appealing to the Court of Appeal against a High Court's dismissal of their judicial review application to challenge the constitutionality of Section 66 of the Syariah Criminal (Negeri Sembilan) Enactment 1992 which criminalises any man who dresses or posed as a woman.
They sought to declare that Section 66 was unconstitutional or that Section did not apply to people like them, who suffer from GID.
On Nov 4, 2011, they obtained leave from the High Court to bring the judicial review proceedings.
The High Court in Seremban, after hearing the trio's judicial review, rejected their request to declare unconstitutional the Enactment, ruling that because they were Muslims and were born male, they must adhere to the law as part of Islamic teaching.
Section 66 allows the Syariah Court to punish any man who dresses or poses as a woman with up to a fine not exceeding RM1,000 or imprisonment not exceeding six months or both, upon conviction.
The trio who claimed to have been arrested and harassed by the authorities repeatedly, are also seeking a court order to prohibit their arrest and prosecution under the section.
Lawyer Syahredzan Johan acting for the Bar Council as amicus curiae (friend of the court) argued that state enacted laws must be consistent with the fundamental liberties as guaranteed in the Federal Constitution.
"The Bar is very concerned with the findings of the High Court with respect to its approach, which was a wrong approach," he said.
He said the Enactment was passed by the Negeri Sembilan state assembly and must be measured by the yardstick of the Constitution.
The Court of Appeal panel comprising Justices Datuk Mohd Hishamudin Mohd Yunus, Datuk Aziah Ali and Datuk Lim Yee Lan fixed July 17 for continued hearing of the appeal.
Earlier, the court had allowed the Bar Council and Human Rights Watch to appear as amicus curiae in the appeal.
Bernama
Thu May 22 2014
!['Transgenders cannot be punished for cross-dressing' 'Transgenders cannot be punished for cross-dressing'](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2014-05/51400764919_295x200.jpg)
Also known as "mak nyah", transgenders suffer from a chronic medical condition call Gender Identity Disorder whose inner psychology was not congruent with the physical body. - Filepic
![Amaran gempa bumi di Jepun selama seminggu berakhir selepas tiada perkembangan baharu Amaran gempa bumi di Jepun selama seminggu berakhir selepas tiada perkembangan baharu](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/71723718198_tokyo.jpg)
Amaran gempa bumi di Jepun selama seminggu berakhir selepas tiada perkembangan baharu
Nasihat gempa bumi Palung Nankai mendorong kerajaan pusat dan komuniti tempatan untuk memperhebatkan persiapan bencana sejak minggu lepas.
![Jenazah ibu Menteri Besar Kedah selamat dikebumikan Jenazah ibu Menteri Besar Kedah selamat dikebumikan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/51723717957_IbuMBKedahmenigg.jpg)
Jenazah ibu Menteri Besar Kedah selamat dikebumikan
Jenazah Allahyarham Meriam Ahmad, 74, ibu Menteri Besar Kedah, selamat dikebumikan di Tanah Perkuburan Islam Sungai Pau jam 5.45 petang Khamis.
![Pengarah SRC adalah profesional, bukan boneka yang diupah oleh Najib - Ismee Pengarah SRC adalah profesional, bukan boneka yang diupah oleh Najib - Ismee](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/81723717419_tbIsmeeIsmail.jpg)
Pengarah SRC adalah profesional, bukan boneka yang diupah oleh Najib - Ismee
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Ahli Lembaga Pengarah SRC International adalah sekumpulan profesional dan bukannya 'boneka' Najib.
![Mesir tekankan keperluan gencatan senjata segera di Gaza Mesir tekankan keperluan gencatan senjata segera di Gaza](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/71723717873_BadrAbdelatty.jpg)
Mesir tekankan keperluan gencatan senjata segera di Gaza
Pendekatan itu adalah satu-satunya cara menghentikan peningkatan ketegangan serantau dan membendung percubaan untuk meluaskan konflik.
Berita Terkini Kita: Hero Kita: Kisah wira negara yang tidak didendang
Irfan Faruqi menjelajah Johor membawakan kisah-kisah wira tidak didendang yang memainkan peranan penting dalam pembangunan negara bersempena bukan kemerdekaan.
Niaga AWANI: Potongan 50 peratus bagi pendaftaran domain .my dan .com.my
MYNIC Berhad, agensi di bawah Kementerian Digital menyemarakkan sambutan Bulan Kebangsaan dengan memberi potongan harga hingga 50 peratus bagi pendaftaran domain .MY dan .COM.MY yang baharu.
Niaga AWANI: K'jaan Persekutuan, Negeri perlu tingkat kepantasan beri kelulusan untuk tarik pelabur – PM
Kerajaan Persekutuan, negeri dan pihak berkuasa tempatan perlu meningkatkan kepantasan dalam memberi kelulusan tanpa berkompromi dengan peraturan yang dikuat kuasa bagi menjadikan Malaysia tumpuan pelabur di rantau ini, kata Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Niaga AWANI: KDNK Jepun meningkat 3.1 peratus tahun ke tahun pada suku kedua
Keluaran Dalam Negara Kasar (KDNK) Jepun mencatatkan pertumbuhan 3.1 peratus tahun ke tahun pada suku tahun kedua tahun ini, menurut data awal yang dikeluarkan kerajaan Jepun, lapor Sputnik.
Niaga AWANI: Zus Coffee lancar ciri derma baharu dalam aplikasi
ZUS Coffee menjadi syarikat terbaharu yang menyuarakan sokongannya terhadap Palestin.
![KPDN pelawa Lotus’s, pasar raya besar buka cawangan di Sabah, Labuan KPDN pelawa Lotus’s, pasar raya besar buka cawangan di Sabah, Labuan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/71719502719_DatukArmizanMohdA.jpg)
KPDN pelawa Lotus’s, pasar raya besar buka cawangan di Sabah, Labuan
KPDN mempelawa pasar raya besar seperti Lotus's untuk membuka cawangan mereka di Sabah dan Labuan.