KUALA LUMPUR: Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor's defence team told the High Court today there is a risk of bias on the part of Judge Mohamed Zaini Mazlan if he continues to hear Rosmah's case due to the existence of a 'purported draft judgment'.
Rosmah's counsel Datuk Jagjit Singh said even though they have full confidence that the judge would not be influenced by the purported leaked judgment, the risk of bias still exists.
He submitted that trial judges must be able to discharge their duties impartially, free from outside influence.
He said the purported draft judgment was prepared by an individual, or more than one person, who had no authority.
"Hence, how can the prosecution say that this allegation (purported draft judgment) is hearsay?" he said.
Jagjit submitted that the prosecution claimed the purported draft judgment is a piece of research and challenged the recusal application by claiming it was made on evidence that was based on hearsay.
"A trial judge must be able to deliver decisions without improper influence direct or indirect from any other source. The leaked document was prepared by more than one person.
"The leaked document is disturbing when it appeared on social media. But it has come out; we cannot hide it under a coconut shell. The leaked documents were not the actual written judgment against Rosmah, but copies of a write-up by the research unit of the Kuala Lumpur High Court," he said.
Jagjit said two posts on Malaysia Today were widely shared on social media and have found their way onto the length and breadth of the country.
Jagjit claimed that dark clouds have descended on the judiciary since Aug 23, 2022, when a judgment in Datuk Seri Najib Razak's SRC International Sdn Bhd case was alllegedly leaked before the Federal Court pronounced its verdict.
He said this was similar to what happened in 1988, referring to the removal of the then Chief Justice Tun Mohamed Salleh Abas, historically known as the judicial crisis.
Jagjit then referred to the two documents (judgment) which he claimed were prepared by somebody else.
Mohamed Zaini: Since you want to call a spade a (piece of) garden equipment, let's just get to the point. What do you call these documents?
Jagjit: To put it bluntly and simply, it has been prepared at the request and behest of someone of authority.
Mohamed Zaini: Answer my question. What do you call these two documents?
Jagjit: I cannot label them but they are incriminating.
Mohamed Zaini: What do you call your submission? What is the aim of your written submission?
Jagjit: To persuade your lordship. But this (the document) cannot persuade your lordship because you have to make an independent mind.
The judge then asked again what the documents were, and Jagjit said he could not answer.
Mohamed Zaini: It is in your affidavit; you say it (the document) is my judgment. Having heard you now, I'm confused. Are you saying this is a draft judgment prepared for me?
Jagjit: Yes
Mohamed Zaini: I'm glad we can clarify that. Do you see these two documents as opinion or a draft judgment?
Jagjit: To me it doesn't seem like an opinion but it is a draft judgment written by a third party.
Mohamed Zaini: Are you insinuating that I would therefore use the draft judgment (in my decision)?
Jagjit: That's where the real danger of bias comes in ... the perception.
Mohamed Zaini: I think I understand where your angle is.
Bernama
Thu Sep 01 2022
Rosmah's counsel Datuk Jagjit Singh said even though they have full confidence that the judge would not be influenced by the purported leaked judgment, the risk of bias still exists. - BERNAMA
#AWANIRingkas 19 Ogos 2024 | 9 PM
Berikut merupakan rangkuman berita setakat 9 malam, 19 Ogos 2024
1️⃣ Memperkasa agenda Bumiputera
2️⃣ Perdagangan Malaysia-India
3️⃣ Kes keropok beracun
#awaniringkas
1️⃣ Memperkasa agenda Bumiputera
2️⃣ Perdagangan Malaysia-India
3️⃣ Kes keropok beracun
#awaniringkas
Malaysia Airports raih paras tertinggi bulanan baharu pergerakan penumpang pada Julai 2024
Malaysia Airports Group mencatatkan 12.4 juta pergerakan penumpang pada Julai 2024, peningkatan 7.3 peratus berbanding bulan sebelumnya sekali gus sebagai paras tertinggi bulanan baharu pascapandemik.
Imigresen jalankan siasatan telus dakwaan petugas di kaunter biadab
JIM menjalankan siasatan secara telus dan menyeluruh berhubung dakwaan petugas di bahagian kaunter jabatan itu bersikap biadab terhadap dua wanita.
Inovasi mampan jadi tumpuan utama ACAAF 2024, julung kali di Malaysia
Malaysia sekali lagi melakar detik bersejarah selepas menjadi tuan rumah kepada penganjuran Asia Convention Alliance Association Forum (ACAAF) 2024.
Beijing kutuk tindakan keras Manila
Kementerian Luar China mengkritik tindakan pengawal pantai Filipina dan kekal menyalahkan mereka atas perlanggaran dengan kapal pengawal pantai China di kawasan yang dipertikaikan di Laut China Selatan.
Danish hilang selepas keluar rumah menaiki motosikal
Seorang pemuda dilaporkan hilang selepas keluar dari rumah ibunya di Bukit Jambul, George Town sejak Sabtu lalu.
Suami isteri proses dadah dalam rumah inap
Suami isteri antara tujuh ahli sindiket pengedaran dadah ditahan dalam tiga serbuan berasingan di rumah inap di Bandar Seri Alam dan Johor Bahru, minggu lalu.
Belanjawan 2025: Pelan Pembangunan Pendidikan, perkasa reformasi pendidikan tumpuan KPM
Pelan Pembangunan Pendidikan 2013-2025 yang bakal berakhir serta pelaksanaan agenda reformasi pendidikan dalam negara antara fokus Kementerian Pendidikan (KPM) dalam Belanjawan 2025.
Muhyiddin yakin tidak hina institusi raja
Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin menegaskan ucapannya ketika kempen PRK DUN Nenggiri tidak berniat menghina institusi raja.
Thaksin Shinawatra tidak risau tentang pertuduhan kes jenayah terhadapnya
Thaksin dan penyokongnya berpegang teguh kepada pendapat mereka bahawa kesemua pertuduhan terhadapnya adalah bermotifkan politik.
Mahkamah tolak permohonan Rosmah tangguh prosiding saman syarikat barang kemas
Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan Rosmah untuk menangguhkan prosiding saman yang difailkan terhadapnya oleh syarikat barang kemas yang berpangkalan di Lubnan.
Rosmah nafi barang kemas, beg tangan, aksesori mewah dibeli hasil aktiviti haram
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor menegaskan bahawa barang kemas, beg tangan dan barangan mewah lain yang berada dalam milikannya bukan dibeli dengan wang hasil aktiviti haram.
Rosmah kemuka permohonan hakim tarik diri dengar kes saman 1MDB
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor memfailkan permohonan supaya hakim Mahkamah Tinggi menarik diri daripada mendengar kes saman sivil US$346 juta difailkan 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) terhadapnya.
Rosmah mohon tangguh prosiding kes saman syarikat barang kemas Lubnan
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor memfailkan permohonan untuk menangguhkan prosiding kes saman difailkan syarikat barang kemas Global Royalty Trading SAL terhadapnya.
Kes 1MDB: Rosmah beri aku janji tidak lupuskan barangan mewah RM1.6 bilion
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor memberikan aku janji untuk tidak melupuskan barangan kmewah yang kini berada dalam milikan atau kawalannya yang dituntut oleh 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB).
Mahkamah tolak permohonan Rosmah masukkan kerajaan, polis sebagai pihak ketiga
Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan Rosmah untuk memasukkan kerajaan dan polis sebagai pihak ketiga dalam kes saman syarikat barangan kemas.
Saman fitnah: Rosmah peroleh penghakiman ingkar terhadap pemilik akaun TikTok
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor memperoleh penghakiman ingkar terhadap seorang pemilik akaun TikTok dalam kes saman fitnah yang dikemukakannnya.
Saman AS$346 juta 1MDB: Rosmah perlu fail pernyataan pembelaan sebelum 4 Julai
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor perlu memfailkan pernyataan pembelaan terhadap saman US$346 juta yang difailkan oleh 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) dan 10 syarikat lain berhubung pembelian barangan mewa
Ucapan Azmin bersifat jahat dan memfitnah beliau dan abangnya - Saksi
Ahli perniagaan, Deepak Jaikishan, berkata kenyataan Mohamed Azmin dalam ceramah politiknya pada 11 Mac 2023, adalah bersifat jahat yang memfitnahnya dan nama abangnya.
Projek solar: Mahkamah dengar rayuan Rosmah pada 23 dan 24 Okt
Dalam pengurusan hari ini, Rosmah diwakili Akberdin dan Datuk Jagjit Singh manakala Timbalan Pendakwa Raya K. Mangai hadir mewakili pihak pendakwaan.