MANY people have said many things about the newly formed cabinet. As the former Environment Minister, I am writing specifically to congratulate the Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim for getting the environment ministerial structure right by combining Energy and Natural Resources (KeTSA) and Environment and Water Ministry (KASA), so the Environment Ministry finally has the right structure to ensure holistic environmental governance in Malaysia. I shall elaborate further.
Historically in Malaysia, a minister is called Environment Minister when he/she is responsible for the environment sector with punca kuasa from the Environmental Quality Act 1974 (EQA 1974) and its enforcement agency, Department of Environment (DOE). EQA 1974 only deals with pollution control, hence the “Environment Ministry” in Malaysia essentially only had direct power over pollution control. Other areas of jurisdiction depend on the sectors which are combined with the environment sector of the ministry.
Before May 2018, the Environment Minister was responsible for the Natural Resources and Environment Ministry (NRE); under Pakatan Harapan, the Environment Minister was responsible for the Ministry of Energy, Science, Technology, Environment and Climate Change (MESTECC); while after the Sheraton Move, the Environment Minister is responsible for the Ministry of Environment and Water (KASA). All of NRE, MESTECC and KASA ministry structures present challenges to the “Environment Ministers” to function optimally.
Under the MESTECC and KASA ministry structures, the natural resources sector is separated from the environment sector, i.e. green issues (forestry and wildlife conservation) are not combined with brown issues (pollution control). This makes it difficult to draw the line in determining which party is responsible to tackle the destruction of natural habitat caused by pollution, for example, the impact of plastic pollution to marine life. In addition, the environment sector is also responsible for climate change, which in turn, is heavily connected to forestry (as carbon sink) hence wildlife and biodiversity. Separating green and brown issues to different ministries results in a disjointed and fragmented climate change agenda.
Furthermore, the natural resources sector in Malaysia is also responsible for land management. There are generally two types of pollution sources for water bodies: i. point source, which is a single identifiable source of pollutants such as effluent from factories and sewage treatment plants; and ii. non-point source, which is based on geographical scales for example, agricultural water runoff etc. Separating the sectors responsible for land management and pollution control will not only make it trickier to manage pollution on land (soil pollution) but also water bodies (from non-point source).
As for NRE and MESTECC ministry structures, the water sector is separated from the environment sector. Not only does this confuse the public as to which ministry has punca kuasa over river issues, it also causes coordination challenges in handling river pollution which, adding to the complication, also involves state governments. This becomes especially evident in a water-stressed area like the Klang Valley with a low reserve margin in its water supply system.
In short, environmental governance in Malaysia has always been fragmented for the past few decades.
Therefore, I am very happy to see that the current environment ministry combines natural resources, pollution control, climate change and water sector all under one roof. This will surely avoid unnecessary lost time spent in inter-ministerial coordination and ensure holistic environmental governance.
It will be even more perfect if Solid Waste Management Department (JPSPN), which is a small part of Housing and Local Government Ministry (KPKT) jurisdictions, can be moved to Environment Ministry as practiced in many other countries.
Is a ministry that covers forestry and wildlife conservation, pollution control, climate change, water, as well as waste management too big to handle? No. The table below shows the responsibilities of the Environment Ministry in different countries and the combinations of jurisdictions. If these countries can do it, there’s no excuse that in Malaysia, we need two or more ministries to do it. Some of these countries have an even bigger population than Malaysia!
All in all, the new government under Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has made the most important fundamental change, i.e the ministerial structure change, towards a more holistic environmental governance. I am looking forward to see holistic changes to environmental conservation and protection efforts in the country under the leadership of my friend, the newly-minted Environment Minister, Nik Nazmi.
Media Statement
Wed Dec 07 2022
Yeo Bee Yin looks forward to see holistic changes to environmental conservation and protection efforts in the country. - BERNAMA/Filepic
Gitar milik George Harrison dijangka cecah RM3.38 juta dalam lelongan
Gitar Futurama berkenaan dibeli di sebuah kedai alat muzik di Liverpool dan dimain oleh Harrison pada awal tahun 1960-an.
Lebih 800 maut akibat wabak mpox di Afrika
Sebanyak 34,297 kes direkodkan di seluruh benua itu sejak Januari lalu, termasuk 38 kes di Ghana.
AWANI Pagi: Ada apa dengan cinta ekspres?
7.30 pagi Sabtu bersama Dr. Norsafatul Aznin A.Razak, Pensyarah Kanan Jabatan Psikologi Pendidikan dan Kaunseling, Fakulti Pendidikan, Universiti Malaya dan Amni Sahira Muhammad Azam, Kaunselor Pelatih, Fakulti Pendidikan, Universiti Malaya membincangkan mengenai isu hubungan khususnya dalam soal memperjudikan hubungan dengan cinta ekspres.
Banjir Bosnia: Tiada rakyat Malaysia terkesan, Wisma Putra terus pantau rapat keadaan semasa
Setakat ini, tiada rakyat Malaysia dilaporkan terlibat atau terkesan dalam bencana alam tersebut.
19 terkorban akibat banjir, tanah runtuh di Bosnia
Sebahagian besar bandar dan kawasan pedalaman terputus hubungan akibat jalan raya yang ditenggelami air banjir.
Lelaki maut kereta terbabas langgar pokok di Manjung
Mangsa disahkan maut di lokasi oleh pihak Kementerian Kesihatan Malaysia.
Durian segar Malaysia di China habis dijual tidak sampai 24 jam
Tidak sampai 24 jam, hampir 40 tan durian segar pertama Malaysia ke China yang dipasarkan pada 26 Ogos lepas di outlet peruncitan terpilih di enam wilayah negara Tembok Besar itu habis terjual.
Keldai akaun ditahan sebabkan kerugian hampir RM60,000
Polis menahan lelaki berumur 58 tahun dipercayai keldai akaun kepada sindiket penipuan yang menawarkan kerja sambilan tidak wujud secara dalam talian sehingga menyebabkan mangsa kerugian RM59,569 baru-baru ini.
Lebih 200 maut akibat taufan Helene di AS
Seramai 200 orang disahkan maut sehingga Jumaat selepas Taufan Helene melanda beberapa negeri di tenggara Amerika Syarikat (AS), menjadikannya ribut paling membahayakan kedua yang melanda AS dalam lebih setengah abad.
Taiwan laksana operasi pembersihan selepas taufan Krathon
Taiwan sedang giat membersihkan kerosakan akibat banjir dan angin kencang selepas Taufan Krathon melanda bandar pelabuhan utama, sementara penduduk di sebahagian besar kawasan lain di pulau itu kembali bekerja dan pasaran kewangan dibuka semula.
Dua ahli politik DAP tarik balik rayuan keputusan mahkamah berhubung saman fitnah
Dua ahli politik DAP menarik balik rayuan mereka terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Tinggi yang memerintahkan mereka membayar RM350,000 kepada bekas setiausaha agung MCA Datin Paduka Chew Mei Fun.
Pengurusan alam sekitar lebih baik jika diuruskan satu kementerian - Yeo Bee Yin
Pengurusan alam sekitar di Malaysia sentiasa berpecah-pecah kepada beberapa kementerian sejak beberapa dekad lalu, menyukarkan usaha memelihara dan memulihara alam sekitar secara holistik.
"Mahathir pernah berhasrat pecat Yeo Bee Yin" - Lim Kit Siang
Kejadian ini menyerlahkan kerumitan dalam kerajaan Pakatan Harapan yang dipimpin Dr Mahathir ketika itu, kata Kit Siang.
Kes saman selesai, Jamal Yunos mohon maaf kepada Yeo
Membacakan kenyataan maaf itu di perkarangan Kompleks Mahkamah Kuala Lumpur, Jamal berkata beliau memohon maaf kerana memfitnah Yeo sebelum ini.
Baiki SOP, benarkan restoran beroperasi selepas 8 malam - Ahli Parlimen pembangkang
Ahli Parlimen pembangkang menggesa MKN untuk memperbaiki SOP tersebut kerana ia memberi kesan kepada para peniaga yang hanya bergantung kepada pendapatan harian mereka.
Mengenang Tun Rahah: Malaysia kehilangan seorang wanita hebat - Wakil rakyat DAP
Ketabahan Allahyarham memelihara lima putera selepas pemergian Allahyarham Tun Abdul Razak mempamerkan kegigihannya.
Ketepi politik, bersatu perangi COVID-19 - DAP
Pimpinan DAP berpendapat semua pihak perlu ketepikan perbezaan politik, bersama-sama untuk membendung penularan COVID-19 di negara ini.
Rang Undang-Undang Jerebu merentas sempadan tidak diteruskan - Kasa
Penelitian itu merangkumi kebolehlaksanaan undang-undang yang akan digubal, hubungan diplomatik dan elemen pencegahan pencemaran alam sekitar.
Isu alam sekitar, Program Subsidi Petrol tumpuan Dewan Rakyat hari ini
Isu PSP terkandung dalam sesi Pertanyaan-Pertanyaan Bagi Jawab Lisan yang diajukan oleh Shaharizukirnain Abd Kadir (PH-Setiu) kepada Menteri Perdagangan Dalam Negeri dan Hal Ehwal Pengguna.
Jamal tarik balik permohonan untuk bicara bersama kes saman dua bekas menteri
Bekas Menteri Tenaga, Sains, Teknologi, Alam Sekitar dan Perubahan Iklim Yeo Bee Yin dan bekas Menteri Industri Utama Teresa Kok Suh Sim memfailkan saman itu secara berasingan pada 2017.