In 2013, two users of the popular online message board Reddit began tracking mass shootings in the United States. The effort began at the Guns Are Cool subreddit, an ironically named group of gun-control proponents who share articles about shootings in the United States.
Brock Weller, a cook in Oregon who was involved in the early evolution of the tracker, told the online news organization the Trace earlier this year that he became interested in the subject of gun violence after he was held at gunpoint by a man wielding a shotgun in 2008.
Since then, a crowd-sourced mass shooting tracker has become a near-daily source of information about shootings in the United States. It is a list of all shooting incidents in which four or more people are killed or injured by gunfire, culled mainly from media reports.
Reddit users submit mass shooting incidents on the subreddit, which then feeds the standalone tracker website.
As the nation has endured several years of prominent shootings, most recently in San Bernardino, California, on Wednesday, the tracker has become a source of data for stories in media across the country. But it also raised a question about what we define as a mass shooting in the United States - particularly how many people must be harmed or killed - and the differences between regular shootings, mass shootings, mass killings and massacres.
Given that the numbers on the mass shooting tracker come from a mostly anonymous group of pro-gun-control Reddit users, some have asked whether their numbers are biased. The tracker's contributors say that they have been careful when documenting their sources. Each incident in the database is accompanied by at least one link to a local media story reporting on the details of the shooting. They invite users of the data to check their work and report any problems they find.
But there is no question that it uses a broader definition than what has been previously understood. The government has never defined "mass shooting" as a standalone category.
The FBI used to consider someone who killed four or more people during one event a "mass murderer," regardless of weapons used. But starting in 2013, federal statutes defined "mass killing" as three or more people killed, regardless of weapons.
But, according to the tracker's users, that definition has a bit of a problem. It includes non-gun killings, for instance, and it excludes cases in which a lot of people are shot but few of them die.
Earlier this year, a gunman killed two people and wounded nine others during a shooting at a theater in Lafayette, Louisiana. Because only two people died, not including the gunman, that incident would not meet the federal definition of a "mass killing" - even though it garnered widespread media attention.
The Redditors who started the tracker deliberately wanted to use a broader definition that would capture instances similar to the Lafayette shooting as well as other multiple-casualty events. So they settled on the definition of four or more people killed or injured.
Some observers, such as independent researcher and gun-rights proponent John Lott, object to the tracker's methodology because it counts "a lot of shootings where people aren't killed, criminal gangs are involved, and cases take place out of public view."
He argues that gang violence and domestic violence spring from different causes than instances in the Colorado Springs or San Bernardino shootings and that they should be considered separately.
"The causes and solutions to drug gang violence are dramatically different than for the vast majority of mass public shootings, where attacks are designed to kill or wound as many people as possible," Lott said in a post on the Crime Prevention Research Center Web site earlier this year. "Padding the numbers by lumping the two together doesn't make much sense."
Others argue that the use of the tracker's data sends a misleading signal to the public. "Fear is running rampant," criminologist James Alan Fox of Northeastern University said in an e-mail. "The source of the panic rests squarely with the way in which media outlets cover these tragedies, and in this case, the mass shooting tracker that is attracting so much ink."
"I'm not saying four-plus injured isn't important," he added. "But it is certainly not as serious as four-plus killed, or three-plus killed, or even two-plus killed (as in Roanoke). The problem is that we then are dealing with two variables: number of victims and type of victimization."
But the people running the tracker consider their approach a feature, not a bug. If we are looking to wrap our heads around the totality of gratuitous gun violence in this country, the argument goes, it makes sense to consider the many instances of this type of violence that happen behind closed doors or within regions plagued by gun violence. A life lost is a life lost, whether that person lived in the South Side of Chicago or suburban Colorado Springs.
The tracker uses the same definition of mass shooting as the Gun Violence Archive, a nonprofit organization that tracks firearm injuries and deaths across all categories in the United States, but with one crucial distinction: The tracker includes the attackers in its death tallies if the incident ends in the attacker's death.
"Just because someone commits suicide by cop doesn't mean that the bystanders weren't subjected to an act of violence," one of the tracker's founders told the Trace last month, "or that the cop who pulled the trigger to end the incident won't have to deal with the psychological ramifications of killing another human being."
Other researchers have also been including domestic violence and gang-related shootings as mass shootings for years. Harvard University's David Hemenway said he considers public shootings, domestic violence and gang violence as the three main categories of mass shootings. He said that in many cases, it makes sense to consider them all together.
Regardless of the cause, "four people are still dead," he said in an interview.
Still, it can be useful to separate the three subcategories. "Last year, overall mass shootings weren't increasing that much," he said. But, "the more public ones were increasing. Those look like they're 'contagious' much more than the intimate partner violence ones."
Jim Bueermann, a former police chief in Redlands, Calif. - the city where the San Bernardino suspects lived - said it does not make much sense to distinguish for this purpose between an injury and a death.
"I would submit that sometimes the only difference between a shooting and a murder could be a centimeter, an inch, an unlikely ricochet, whatever," Bueermann, who is now president of the Police Foundation, a kind of think tank for research into effective law enforcement practices, said in an interview. "If we're trying to capture true gun violence in our country, a broader definition [of mass shooting] is probably more useful than a narrow one."
The Washington Post
Sat Dec 05 2015
![What makes a shooting a 'mass shooting'? What makes a shooting a 'mass shooting'?](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2015-10/61446202561_GUNSHOT.jpg)
Starting in 2013, federal statutes defined "mass killing" as three or more people killed, regardless of weapons.
![Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41721021538_TBSHAMSUL.jpg)
Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia
Rang Undang-Undang Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia 2024 yang bertujuan menubuhkan MCBA diluluskan persidangan Dewan Rakyat, hari ini.
![PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024 PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-03/61710922383_MasErmieyatiSamsud.jpg)
PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024
Jawatankuasa Kira-Kira Wang Negara (PAC) akan memulakan prosiding bagi empat isu yang dibangkitkan dalam Laporan Ketua Audit Negara (LKAN) Siri 2/2024.
AWANI Ringkas: Kes bunuh Nur Farah Kartini | Skandal LCS
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
ADUN Rembia sertai Pas, kenapa tak umum tahun lepas? - MP Kampar
Chong Zhemin, tindakan tersebut seolah-olah satu penghinaan paling besar kepada Parlimen yang telah meluluskan pindaan Perlembagaan Persekutuan berkait Akta Antilompat Parti.
Masuk Pas untuk sama-sama susah dengan rakyat - ADUN Rembia
Muhamad Jailani berkata, sebelum ini beliau pernah menghantar surat kepada Lembaga Disiplin UMNO memohon untuk memecat keahliannya daripada parti Melayu itu.
[TERKINI] Astro dipilih sebagai penyiar rasmi Olimpik Paris 2024
Astro dipilih sebagai penyiar rasmi bagi Sukan Olimpik Paris 2024 bermula hujung bulan ini.
[TERKINI] Speaker DUN Melaka tunggu surat rasmi Muhammad Jailani
DUN Melaka masih menunggu surat rasmi daripada Pas berhubung tindakan ADUN Rembia, Datuk Muhamad Jailani Khamis yang menyertai Pas.
Sasar sumbang RM500 bilion kepada kdnk tempoh tiga tahun
Selangor perlu merancakkan semula kapasiti pembuatan untuk tidak hanya memenuhi keperluan tempatan, tetapi menjadikan negeri itu sebagai asas kepada pelan peluasan ke rantau Asia Tenggara dan Asia.
![Wanita dihempap kayu balak mula sedarkan diri Wanita dihempap kayu balak mula sedarkan diri](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61720789446_Wanitadihempapkay.jpg)
Wanita dihempap kayu balak mula sedarkan diri
Wanita yang nyaris maut akibat dihempap kayu balak dalam kejadian di lampu isyarat di Persimpangan Bendahara, Jalan Gua Musang-Kuala Krai di sini 9 Julai lepas, kini dilaporkan mula sedarkan diri.
Sah suspek anggota polis
Ketua Polis Selangor, Datuk Hussein Omar Khan mengesahkan suspek bunuh Nur Farah Kartini, ialah anggota polis.
Suspek juga yang dipercayai teman lelaki mangsa dan bertugas di Perak.
Suspek juga yang dipercayai teman lelaki mangsa dan bertugas di Perak.
![FBI kenal pasti suspek penembak Trump sebagai Thomas Matthew Crooks FBI kenal pasti suspek penembak Trump sebagai Thomas Matthew Crooks](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61720938687_DonaldTrump.jpg)
FBI kenal pasti suspek penembak Trump sebagai Thomas Matthew Crooks
FBI berkata mereka masih berusaha untuk mencari motif di sebalik cubaan pembunuhan itu.
![FBI anggap tembakan di perhimpunan Trump sebagai 'cubaan bunuh' FBI anggap tembakan di perhimpunan Trump sebagai 'cubaan bunuh'](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/51720935938_DonaldTrump.jpg)
FBI anggap tembakan di perhimpunan Trump sebagai 'cubaan bunuh'
Biro Penyiasatan Persekutuan (FBI) masih belum mengenal pasti suspek penembak dalam serangan terhadap bekas Presiden Donald Trump di Pennsylvania, Amerika Syarikat (AS).
![Peluru mengenai telinga kanan saya - Trump Peluru mengenai telinga kanan saya - Trump](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/81720929828_PresidentDonaldTru.jpg)
Peluru mengenai telinga kanan saya - Trump
Kejadian tembakan itu sedang disiasat dan Perkhidmatan Rahsia telah memaklumkan secara rasmi kepada Biro Penyiasatan Persekutuan (FBI).
![Faizal Ismail guna platform media sosial beri motivasi tunai haji Faizal Ismail guna platform media sosial beri motivasi tunai haji](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/61717899792_TBFaizalIsmail.jpg)
Faizal Ismail guna platform media sosial beri motivasi tunai haji
Walaupun menyedari dirinya banyak kekurangan, FBI terus berdakwah ke arah kebaikan, berbekalkan sedikit ilmu.
![FBI tawar ganjaran AS$10 juta tangkap pembangun perisian tebusan Lockbit FBI tawar ganjaran AS$10 juta tangkap pembangun perisian tebusan Lockbit](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-05/71715228627_FBIjpg.jpg)
FBI tawar ganjaran AS$10 juta tangkap pembangun perisian tebusan Lockbit
PERISIAN tebusan Lockbit menyerang dunia siber sejak 2019 tetapi mula mendapat perhatian orang ramai selepas syarikat terkemuka seperti Thales, Royal Mail, TSMC dan Continental menjadi mangsa.
![Hakim tangguh perbicaraan dokumen sulit Trump Hakim tangguh perbicaraan dokumen sulit Trump](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-05/81714980397_DonaldTrump.jpg)
Hakim tangguh perbicaraan dokumen sulit Trump
Perbicaraan berkemungkinan tidak akan bermula sebelum pilihan raya presiden AS pada November.
![Pas gesa kerajaan tidak ikut telunjuk luar isu keselamatan, kedaulatan negara Pas gesa kerajaan tidak ikut telunjuk luar isu keselamatan, kedaulatan negara](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-10/81697887951_DatukSeriTuanIbra.jpg)
Pas gesa kerajaan tidak ikut telunjuk luar isu keselamatan, kedaulatan negara
Tuan Ibrahim berkata, perkara ini mesti diuruskan dengan kewibawaan kerajaan Malaysia sendiri tanpa didorong oleh campur tangan asing.
![KDN dapatkan gambaran tepat 3 pemimpin NGO Islam dalam senarai FBI KDN dapatkan gambaran tepat 3 pemimpin NGO Islam dalam senarai FBI](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-02/81708319166_SaifuddinNasution.jpg)
KDN dapatkan gambaran tepat 3 pemimpin NGO Islam dalam senarai FBI
KDN sedang mendapatkan gambaran tepat dan akan menyemak fakta berkaitan tiga pemimpin badan bukan kerajaan (NGO) Islam negara ini yang berada dalam senarai FBI.
![Bekas anggota CIA dipenjara, bocor rahsia ke WikiLeaks Bekas anggota CIA dipenjara, bocor rahsia ke WikiLeaks](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-02/41706836007_CIA.jpg)
Bekas anggota CIA dipenjara, bocor rahsia ke WikiLeaks
Joshua Schulte didapati bersalah atas tuduhan pengintipan dan lain-lain kesalahan pada 2022, dalam tragedi yang digelar 'Pearl Harbor digital.'
![FBI dakwa serangan siber ke atas Malaysia meningkat, bermotifkan wang dan politik - Laporan FBI dakwa serangan siber ke atas Malaysia meningkat, bermotifkan wang dan politik - Laporan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-05/61683697104_CyberAttack.jpg)
FBI dakwa serangan siber ke atas Malaysia meningkat, bermotifkan wang dan politik - Laporan
FBI mendakwa, serangan siber itu bukan hanya keuntungan, tetapi juga oleh penyangak yang cuba mendapatkan kelebihan ekonomi dan strategik.