WASHINGTON: At a summit with South Korean leader Yoon Suk Yeol on Wednesday, U.S. President Joe Biden will seek to reassure South Koreans that the U.S. nuclear umbrella is sufficient protection from North Korean attack.
But with North Korean missiles now a direct threat to the United States, an old Cold-War dilemma has resurfaced: would the United States risk nuclear retaliation against itself to defend an ally?
WHY IS SOUTH KOREA WORRIED?
U.S. "extended deterrence" protection for South Korea rests on a simple, if grim, assumption: if North Korea were to attack South Korea with nuclear weapons, it would face devastating U.S. retaliatory strikes.
For years after Pyongyang first tested a nuclear bomb in 2006 this was a believable threat - North Korea had relatively few bombs and limited ability to send them far beyond its own borders.
But its arsenal has grown and it now has intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) that can reach U.S. cities, making the cost of defending South Korea potentially far higher.
Skeptical that the United States would really risk its own cities to defend its ally - the more so after former President Donald Trump questioned the value of the South Korean alliance when he was in office - many South Koreans now support the idea of their country developing its own nuclear weapons.
A poll last month found over 64% of South Koreans support this, something the Biden administration is set against.
WHAT ARE SOUTH KOREA'S OPTIONS?
Yoon vowed in his election campaign to seek redeployment of U.S. tactical nuclear weapons in South Korea and possibly "nuclear sharing," meaning joint command over U.S. weapons. In January, he raised the possibility that Seoul might someday need to develop its own nuclear arsenal, saying it could do this quickly given its scientific expertise.
Yoon never pursued redeployment of tactical nuclear weapons, which Washington said it would not support, and walked back his comments on a South Korean bomb, saying his administration was committed to the nuclear non-proliferation treaty (NPT).
But his comments have driven a growing debate that one former senior U.S. defense official said threatens to normalize a once unthinkable concept of a South Korean nuclear arsenal.
WHAT TO EXPECT FROM THE BIDEN-YOON SUMMIT
To counter such sentiment, Biden will pledge what senior U.S. officials say will be "substantial" steps to strengthen extended deterrence. A "Washington Declaration" will include creation of a "Nuclear Consultative Group" to give South Korea additional insight on U.S. planning for major contingencies and "a voice in those deliberations," one official said.
The aim was to make clear "our absolute and enduring commitment to provide extended deterrence to (South Korea), including, as necessary, a decisive response," another said.
The leaders will announce plans to make deterrence more visible through regular deployments of strategic assets, including a first U.S. nuclear ballistic-missile submarine visit to South Korea since the early 1980s.
However, the officials stressed there was "no vision" of returning U.S. nuclear weapons to the Korean peninsula and that decisions on their use was the sole authority of U.S. president, while Seoul would reaffirm its commitment to the NPT and its non-nuclear status.
WHAT WOULD BE THE IMPLICATIONS OF A NUCLEAR SOUTH KOREA?
Nuclear expert Siegfried Hecker warned in January there could be disastrous downsides to Seoul acquiring its own bomb, spurring North Korea to build an even bigger arsenal and likely triggering highly damaging sanctions on South Korea's economy.
Despite South Korea's technical expertise and civilian nuclear program, creating a nuclear arsenal would take years and could spell the end of its U.S. alliance and the protection of the U.S. nuclear umbrella, he wrote.
It would also threaten worldwide non-proliferation efforts.
"South Korea would be the first democratic country to withdraw from the NPT, dealing a blow to decades of U.S. leadership in preventing nuclear proliferation," Hecker said. "Washington would have no choice but to condemn and counter the South's decision to build the bomb."
"The South can have its own nuclear arsenal - at great expense and sacrifice - or work with the Americans to remain under the nuclear umbrella with American troops stationed on the peninsula. It cannot have both."
Reuters
Wed Apr 26 2023
South Korean leader Yoon Suk Yeol vowed in his election campaign to seek redeployment of US tactical nuclear weapons in South Korea and possibly "nuclear sharing," meaning joint command over US weapons. - REUTERS
AS minta imigran dari empat negara keluar apabila permit tamat
Imigran dari Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, dan Venezuela yang memasuki Amerika Syarikat melalui "program parol" perlu meninggalkan negara itu apabila permit dua tahun mereka tamat jika mereka tidak memperoleh cara lain yang sah untuk tinggal, umum pentadbiran Biden pada Jumaat.
Persiapan sedang dilakukan untuk di ibu negara Laos
Persiapan sedang giat dilakukan untuk Laos menjadi tuan rumah Sidang Kemuncak ASEAN ke-44 dan ke-45 serta mesyuarat berkaitan, dengan pihak berkuasa dari pelbagai sektor bersiap sedia untuk menyambut ketibaan pemimpin dan delegasi yang akan menghadiri mesyuarat berkenaan.
Ribuan penduduk dunia berhimpun, solidariti ke atas Palestin
Rangkuman ribuan penduduk dunia mengadakan perhimpunan di negara masing-masing sebagai tanda solidariti ke atas penduduk Gaza ekoran kekejaman Zionis.
Banjir, tanah runtuh ragut 16 nyawa di Bosnia
Hari Jumaat nyata hari yang tragik buat Alka Gusic, apabila dia kehilangan empat ahli keluarganya sekaligus, susulan kejadian tanah runtuh melanda kampung mereka di Donja, Jablanica, di Bosnia.
31 pemberontak Maoist terbunuh dalam pertempuran dengan tentera India
Sekurang-kurangnya 31 pemberontak disyaki dari kumpulan Maoist, terbunuh dalam pertempuran dengan tentera India di India Tengah.
Pertempuran meletus pada hari Jumaat apabila pasukan penentang pemberontakan, mengepung hampir 50 pemberontak di kawasan hutan Abhujmaad di sepanjang sempadan daerah Narayanpur dan Dantewada di negeri Chhattisgarh.
Pertempuran meletus pada hari Jumaat apabila pasukan penentang pemberontakan, mengepung hampir 50 pemberontak di kawasan hutan Abhujmaad di sepanjang sempadan daerah Narayanpur dan Dantewada di negeri Chhattisgarh.
Pasukan keselamatan harungi banjir untuk selamatkan gajah
Pasukan penyelamat di Wilayah Chiang Mai, Thailand, telah mengharungi arus deras banjir bagi menyelamatkan sekumpulan gajah daripada mati lemas.
Daerah Mae Taeng, yang merupakan lokasi beberapa kem penempatan gajah, telah dilanda banjir kilat susulan hujan monsun lebat.
Daerah Mae Taeng, yang merupakan lokasi beberapa kem penempatan gajah, telah dilanda banjir kilat susulan hujan monsun lebat.
Pesara guru maut ditikam anak lelaki
Seorang pesara guru maut akibat ditikam anak lelakinya di rumahnya di Kampung Senaling, Kuala Pilah di sini, petang tadi.
Malaysia amal perdagangan terbuka, terdedah kepada kesan ketidaktentuan ekonomi global - Rafizi
Rakyat perlu memahami bahawa Malaysia adalah negara yang mengamalkan perdagangan terbuka dan terdedah kepada kesan daripada ketidaktentuan ekonomi dunia, kata Menteri Ekonomi Rafizi Ramli.
JDT ikat bekas bintang Real Madrid
Bekas bintang Real Madrid, Jese Rodriguez telah menandatangani kontrak bersama Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT), menurut rakaman video yang dimuat naik di laman Facebook Johor Southern Tigers hari ini.
Taman Sri Muda diserbu, 602 pendatang asing ditahan
Sebanyak 602 pendatang tanpa izin ditahan hasil pemeriksaan terhadap 1,091 warga asing dalam operasi bersepadu diketuai Jabatan Imigresen Malaysia (JIM) di Pusat Perniagaan Taman Sri Muda, Seksyen 25 di Shah Alam pada Sabtu.
Korea Selatan tekad tangani kadar kelahiran rendah - Presiden
Presiden Korea Selatan Yoon Suk Yeol berikrar akan berusaha sepenuhnya untuk menangani kadar kelahiran yang sangat rendah di negara itu.
Presiden Korea Selatan Yoon gesa bantuan segera untuk mangsa banjir
Presiden Korea Selatan Yoon Suk Yeol pada Ahad menggesa kerajaan bertindak pantas membantu mangsa yang dilanda hujan lebat baru-baru ini.
Presiden Korea Selatan akan hadiri sidang kemuncak NATO dan melawat Poland
Yoon dijadual mengadakan sekurang-kurangnya 10 pertemuan dua hala di luar sidang kemuncak NATO itu.
Korea Selatan tamatkan hampir semua sekatan COVID-19
Presiden Korea Selatan Yoon Suk Yeol pada Khamis mengisytiharkan bahawa hampir semua sekatan COVID-19 ditamatkan termasuk pengasingan mandatori.
Pakar Korea Selatan dihantar ke Jepun periksa sisa air radioaktif
Korea Selatan bersetuju menghantar pakarnya ke Jepun untuk memeriksa sisa air radioaktif di loji nuklear Fukushima.
PM Jepun adakan lawatan sulung ke Korea Selatan sejak 12 tahun
Lawatan Kishida itu berikutan keputusan Seoul pada Mac lalu untuk memberi pampasan kepada mangsa rakyat Korea yang menjadi buruh paksa ketika zaman perang.
Korea Selatan boleh beri bantuan ketenteraan ke Ukraine jika Rusia sasar orang awam - Presiden Yoon
Presiden Yoon Suk Yeol berkata Korea Selatan boleh memberikan bantuan melangkaui bantuan kemanusiaan atau kewangan jika Ukraine diserang secara besar-besaran membabitkan orang awam.
Diplomat dan pegawai pertahanan Korea Selatan, Jepun mulakan rundingan keselamatan
Kedua-dua pihak dijangka berkongsi penilaian tentang situasi keselamatan di Asia Timur Laut dan di Semenanjung Korea serta dasar pertahanan dan keselamatan masing-masing.
Pelancaran peluru berpandu Korea Utara, Presiden Korea Selatan beri amaran
Pelancaran terbaru peluru berpandu antara benua disifatkan beliau sebagai satu lagi tindakan provokasi.
Presiden Moon tinggalkan kediaman rasmi pada 9 Mei, sehari sebelum pelantikan rasmi Yoon
Presiden Korea Selatan Moon Jae In akan berpindah dari kediaman rasminya Cheong Wa Dae (Rumah Biru) pada 9 Mei, sehari sebelum penggantinya Yoon Suk Yeol angkat sumpah jawatan.