NEW YORK: You may never have to read another news story in your life, if you have artificial intelligence that can digest all the web’s information and serve up a summary on demand.
That’s the stuff of nightmares for media barons as Google and others experiment with what's called generative AI, which creates new content drawing from past data.
Since May, Google has begun rolling out a new form of search powered by generative AI, after industry observers questioned the tech giant's future prominence in providing consumers with information following the rise of OpenAI's query-answering chatbot, ChatGPT.
The product, called Search Generative Experience (SGE), uses AI to create summaries in response to some search queries, triggered by whether Google’s system determines the format would be helpful. Those summaries appear on the top of the Google search homepage, with links to “dig deeper,” according to Google’s overview of SGE.
If publishers want to prevent their content from being used by Google’s AI to help generate those summaries, they must use the same tool that would also prevent them from appearing in Google search results, rendering them virtually invisible on the web.
Searching for “Who is Jon Fosse” – the recent Nobel Prize in Literature winner – for instance, generates three paragraphs on the writer and his work. Drop-down buttons provide links to Fosse content on Wikipedia, NPR, The New York Times and other websites; additional links appear to the right of the summary.
Google says that the AI-generated overviews are synthesized from multiple web pages and that the links are designed to be a jumping off point to learn more. It describes SGE as an opt-in experiment for users, to help it evolve and improve the product, while it incorporates feedback from news publishers and others.
To publishers, the new search tool is the latest red flag in a decades-long relationship in which they have both struggled to compete against Google for online advertising, and relied on the tech giant for search traffic.
The still-evolving product – now available in the United States, India and Japan – has raised concerns among publishers as they try to figure out their place in a world where AI could dominate how users find and pay for information, according to four major publishers who spoke to Reuters on the condition of anonymity to avoid complicating ongoing negotiations with Google.
Those concerns relate to web traffic, whether publishers will be credited as the source of information that appears in the SGE summaries, and the accuracy of those summaries, those publishers say. Most significantly, publishers want to be compensated for the content on which Google and other AI companies train their AI tools – a major sticking point around AI.
A Google spokesperson said in a statement: “As we bring generative AI into Search, we’re continuing to prioritize approaches that send valuable traffic to a wide range of creators, including news publishers, to support a healthy, open web.”
On compensation, Google says it is working to develop a better understanding of the business model of generative AI applications and get input from publishers and others.
In late September Google announced a new tool, called Google-Extended, that gives publishers the option to block their content from being used by Google to train its AI models.
Giving publishers the option to opt out of being crawled for AI is a “good faith gesture,” said Danielle Coffey, president and chief executive of the News Media Alliance, an industry trade group that has been lobbying Congress over these issues. “Whether payments will follow is a question mark, and to what extent there is openness to having a healthier value exchange.”
The new tool doesn’t allow publishers to block their content from being crawled for SGE, either the summaries or the links that appear with them, without disappearing from traditional Google search.
Publishers want clicks to secure advertisers, and showing up in Google search is key to their business. The design for SGE has pushed the links that appear in traditional search further down the page, with potential to reduce traffic to those links by as much as 40%, according to an executive at one of the publishers.
More alarming is the possibility that web surfers will avoid clicking any of the links if the SGE passage fulfills the users’ need for information – satisfied, for example, to learn the best time of year to go to Paris, without having to click on a travel publication’s website.
SGE is “definitely going to decrease publishers’ organic traffic and they’re going to have to think about a different way to measure the value of that content, if not click through rate,” said Forrester Research Senior Analyst Nikhil Lai. Even so, he believes publishers’ reputations will remain strong as a result of their links appearing in SGE.
Google says that it designed SGE to highlight web content. “Any estimates about specific traffic impacts are speculative and not representative, as what you see today in SGE may look quite different from what ultimately launches more broadly in Search,” a company spokesperson said in a statement.
While publishers and other industries have spent decades adjusting their websites to show up prominently in traditional Google search, they don’t have enough information to do the same for the new SGE summaries, these publishers say.
“The new AI section is a black box for us,” said an executive at one publisher. “We don’t know how to make sure we’re a part of it or the algorithm behind it.”
Google said publishers do not need to do anything different than what they have been doing to appear in search.
Publishers have long allowed Google to “crawl” their content for the purposes of appearing in search results – using a bot, or piece of software, to automatically scan and index it. “Crawling” is how Google indexes the web to make content show up in search.
Publishers’ concerns with SGE boil down to a key point: They say that Google is crawling their content, for free, to create summaries that users may read instead of clicking on their links, and that Google hasn’t been clear about how they can block content from being crawled for SGE.
Google’s new search tool, said one publisher, “is even more threatening to us and our business than a crawler that is crawling our business illegally.”
Google did not comment on that assessment.
When given the option, websites are blocking their content from being used for AI if doing so doesn’t impact search, according to exclusive data from AI content detector Originality.ai. Since its Aug. 7 release, 27.4% of top websites are blocking ChatGPT’s bot – including The New York Times and Washington Post. That’s compared to 6% that are blocking Google-Extended since its Sept. 28 release.
Reuters
Sun Oct 22 2023
Google says that the AI-generated overviews are synthesized from multiple web pages and that the links are designed to be a jumping off point to learn more. - REUTERS
Bomba selamatkan tiga subkontrakor terkandas di kren pengangkat
Ketiga-tiga mangsa lelaki itu masing-masing berusia 24, 26 dan 32 tahun terkandas dengan anggaran ketinggian dua tingkat.
Hulu Perak daerah terbaharu dilanda banjir kilat
Banjir kilat berlaku disebabkan hujan lebat berterusan selama dua jam di sekitar Gerik.
Kejayaan pembangunan Sabah jadi kayu ukur pada PRN, PRU16 - Rafizi
Rafizi berkata kerjasama antara parti adalah perkara yang terus dibincangkan dalam kerangka semangat Kerajaan Perpaduan.
88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara dapat pengiktirafan JAKIM
Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) telah memberikan pengiktirafan kepada 88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara setakat Mei tahun ini.
eWarga Emas bentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan berkesan, bersepadu - Noraini
Portal sistem warga emas (eWarga Emas) dibangunkan bagi membentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan warga emas yang berkesan dan bersepadu.
MITRA lulus lebih RM95 juta untuk 11 program masyarakat India
Kesemua program yang dalam pelaksanaan itu memberi tumpuan kepada usaha memperkasakan sosioekonomi komuniti India dalam negara.
Kestabilan sosiopolitik Sabah bolehkan agihan ekonomi saksama - Juhar
Smber daya, kekayaan alam semula jadi dan potensi ekonomi dalam masyarakat dapat dibahagi dengan cara memberi peluang sama kepada rakyat.
Kenanga jangka OPR stabil 3.0 peratus pada 2025
Kenanga Investment Bank Bhd menjangka Kadar Dasar Semalaman (OPR) kekal stabil pada 3.0 peratus sepanjang 2025.
Johor sasar jumlah ternakan cecah 200,000 ekor pada 2027
Johor menyasarkan jumlah ternakan di negeri ini mencapai hingga 200,000 ekor pada 2027 setelah berjaya mencapai jumlah pengeluaran ternakan sebanyak 152,000 ekor hingga bulan lepas.
Hargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat dan penglibatan - Lee Lam Thye
Lee Lam Thye menekankan keperluan mendesak untuk menghargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat, dan penglibatan yang lebih baik.
Kerjasama Malaysia-Negara ASEAN kekalkan aliran bakat berkemahiran tinggi - Sim
Kerjasama antara Malaysia dengan negara-negara ASEAN penting untuk menarik, membangunkan dan mengekalkan aliran bakat berkemahiran tinggi, dinamik dan pelbagai, kata Menteri Sumber Manusia Steven Sim.
Google bawa lebih banyak AI ke enjin carian dalam kemas kini 'signifikan'
Google mengumumkan beberapa kemas kini berkuasa kecerdasan buatan (AI) pada enjin carian mereka, menyifatkannya sebagai "antara kemas kini Carian paling signifikan setakat ini".
Google mungkin perkenal Android 16 lebih awal
Jika benar, maka ia mungkin merubah landskap pengeluar peranti, di mana lebih ramai akan berlumba memperkenalkan peranti dengan sokongan sistem operasi terbaharu Android.
Pusat Data Google: Sime Darby Property pemaju tunggal pertama di Malaysia laksana pajakan bina ikut kesesuaian
Pengaturan pajakan unik ini menandakan yang pertama dan satu-satunya yang seumpamanya setakat ini oleh pemaju di Malaysia.
ASEAN lancar inisiatif celik AI disokong geran Google bernilai AS$5 juta
Inisiatif dipimpin Yayasan ASEAN dan disokong geran AS$5 juta daripada Google.org, dilancarkan pada Forum Peluang AI Asia Tenggara pada Rabu.
Apple Intelligence perlu 4GB storan pada iPhone
Ini adalah perkara yang sama seperti Gemini pada peranti Google Pixel 9 Pro yang turut mengambil ruang storan peranti.
Google guna rekaan Doodle Merdeka lebih kurang sama sejak 2021
Pada tahun ini, apabila anda klik pada logo Google Malaysia, ia akan turut membawa kepada halaman carian yang dilengkapi dengan animasi letusan mercun.
Google tidak akan keluarkan Pixel Flip
Google tiada perancangan mengeluarkan telefon katup kerana Samsung dan Motorola telah mempunyai peranti yang baik.
Google perkenal ciri berbual guna suara Gemini Live
Buat masa ini, ia hanya ditawarkan dalam mod berbayar untuk pelanggan Gemini Advance, selain terhad kepada komunikasi dalam bahasa Inggeris.
Google tamatkan sokongan Chrome untuk MacOS 10.15
Bermula Chrome 129, ia akan memerlukan pengguna menjalankan sistem operasi macOS 11 dan terkini untuk menggunakannya.