SYDNEY: An Australian court on Monday ordered Google to pay a former lawmaker A$715,000 ($515,000), saying its refusal to remove a YouTuber's "relentless, racist, vilificatory, abusive and defamatory" videos drove him out of politics.
The Federal Court found the Alphabet Inc GOOGL.O company intentionally made money by hosting two videos on its YouTube website attacking the then-deputy premier of New South Wales, Australia's most populous state, that have been viewed nearly 800,000 times since being posted in 2020.
The ruling revives the question of how much culpability technology firms have for defamation conveyed by users on their websites in Australia, one of few Western nations where online platforms have the same legal responsibility as publishers.
Australia is reviewing what legal exposure platforms should have for defamatory posts. A landmark case in 2021, where a newspaper was found liable for defamatory reader comments below an article posted on Facebook, drove global firms to reduce their social media presence in the country.
The judgment showed Google had denied the videos carried defamatory imputations, and said the YouTuber had the right to an honestly held opinion and should be protected by the right to criticise a politician.
A Google spokesperson was not available for comment.
"They (Google) were advised that those defamatory videos were there, they looked into it, they decided for themselves that they weren't, and left them up," said Prof David Rolph, a specialist in media law at the University of Sydney Law School.
"That's an orthodox application of the basic principles of publication in defamation law (but) leaves the larger question about whether we need to reform the principles of publication."
HATE SPEECH
The court heard that content creator Jordan Shanks uploaded videos in which he repeatedly brands lawmaker John Barilaro "corrupt" without citing credible evidence, and calls him names attacking his Italian heritage which the judge, Steve Rares, said amounted to "nothing less than hate speech".
By continuing to publish the content, Rares said Google breached its own policies aimed at protecting public figures from being unfairly targeted, and "drove Mr Barilaro prematurely from his chosen service in public life and traumatised him significantly."
Barilaro quit politics a year after Shanks posted the videos, and "Google cannot escape its liability for the substantial damage that Mr Shanks' campaign caused," Rares said.
Shanks, who has 625,000 YouTube subscribers and 346,000 followers on Meta Platforms Inc's FB.O Facebook, was a co-defendant until a settlement with Barilaro last year which involved the YouTuber editing the videos and paying the former politician A$100,000.
But Shanks "needed YouTube to disseminate his poison (and) Google was willing to join Mr Shanks in doing so to earn revenue as part of its business model," the judge said.
Before the lawsuit was resolved, Shanks continued to make disparaging comments about Barilaro and his lawyers in YouTube videos, and the judge said he would refer him and Google to the authorities "for what appear to be serious contempts of court by bringing improper pressure ... not to pursue this proceeding".
In a Facebook post after the ruling, Shanks, who goes by the handle friendlyjordies, mocked Barilaro, saying "you finally scored the coin from Google ... without ever having the truth tested in court".
Shanks added, without evidence, that Barilaro "withdrew (his) action against us so we wouldn't testify or present our evidence" in support of the YouTuber's claims.
Barilaro told reporters outside the courthouse that he felt "cleared and vindicated".
"It was never about money," he said. "It was about an apology, removal. Of course, now an apology is worthless after the campaign has continued. It's taken a court to force Google's hand."
($1 = 1.3883 Australian dollars)
Reuters
Mon Jun 06 2022
Google logo and Australian flag are displayed in this illustration taken, Feb. 18, 2021. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo
Tindakan keras terhadap penjualan racun makhluk perosak haram - CAP
CAP menggesa Lembaga Racun Makhluk Perosak segera mengambil tindakan keras terhadap penjualan racun makhluk perosak haram di negara ini dan menguatkuasakan dengan tegas Akta Racun Perosak 1974.
PDRM gerak unit skuba forensik, K9 cari bukti hari ini
Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM) akan menggerakkan unit skuba (Unit Forensik) serta Unit Anjing Pengesan (K9) ke lokasi penemuan mayat Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah, 25, di Kampung Sri Kledang, Hulu Selangor, pagi esok.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Dewan Rakyat: Langkah meknoktahkan kemisikan tegar di Sabah antara tumpuan hari ini
Langkah-langkah untuk meknoktahkan kemiskinan tegar di Sabah terutamanya di lapan daerah yang dikategorikan termiskin di Malaysia antara tumpuan persidangan Dewan Rakyat hari ini.
Kagame, menang 99.5 peratus pilihan raya Rwanda
Paul Kagame meneruskan khidmatnya buat penggal keempat berturut-turut sebagai Presiden Rwanda, selepas memenangi 99.15 peratus undi dalam pilihan raya negara itu.
Polis kerah lebih 300 anggota kawal perlawanan Piala FA
Seramai 351 anggota polis ditugaskan bagi mengawal perlawanan separuh akhir Piala FA antara Terengganu FC (TFC) dengan Selangor FC di Stadium Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin (SSMZA) Jumaat ini.
Perisik Korea Utara berpaling tadah
Seorang diplomat Korea Utara berprofil tinggi yang ditempatkan di Cuba dikenali sebagai Ri II Kyu, 52 tahun, berpaling tadah ke Korea Selatan.
Dua warga AS antara yang ditemui maut di bilik hotel di Thailand
Jabatan Negara Amerika Syarikat ambil maklum mengenai laporan mengenai dua warganegaranya yang ditemui mati di sebuah hotel di Thailand.
EU tolak label UNRWA sebagai organisasi pengganas
Ketua Dasar Luar Kesatuan Eropah (EU), Josep Borrell mengulangi penolakan blok itu melabel Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) sebagai organisasi pengganas.
Mengimbau sedekad tragedi MH17
Pesawat MH17 Malaysia Airlines ditembak jatuh di timur Ukraine sejurus berlepas dari Lapangan Terbang Schiphol di Amsterdam, mengorbankan kesemua 283 penumpang dan 15 anak kapal di dalamnya.
Tragedi yang berlaku pada 17 Julai 2014 itu, kini memasuki tahun ke-10 kejadiannya.
Tragedi yang berlaku pada 17 Julai 2014 itu, kini memasuki tahun ke-10 kejadiannya.
Kerajaan teliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap, pastikan kewangan negara lebih mampan
Kerajaan sedang meneliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap bagi memastikan pengurusan kewangan negara yang lebih mampan.
Tarif elektrik antara terendah di Asia Tenggara tarik pelabur asing ke Malaysia
Kadar tarif elektrik yang kompetitif dan antara terendah di Asia Tenggara antara tarikan buat pelabur asing masuk ke Malaysia.
Dua syarikat teknologi ini guna elektrik lebih banyak berbanding 100 negara
Google dan Microsoft menggunakan lebih banyak tenaga berbanding lebih 100 negara, termasuklah Iceland, Jordan dan Ghana.
Semua pengguna Google akan layak menerima laporan web gelap
Laporan web gelap Google ini menyemak nama, alamat, nombor telefon dan emel pengguna yang mungkin telah tertiris.
Keperluan tenaga pusat data punca pelepasan karbon Google meningkat 48% sejak 2019
Google memperlihatkan peningkatan kadar jejak karbon untuk beberapa tahun sekarang, di mana peningkatan dari tahun ke tahun ialah sebanyak 13 peratus.
Tiada lagi tatalan tanpa henti, paparan muka surat kembali pada keputusan carian Google Search
Sebagai peringatan ciri keputusan carian dengan skrol tanpa henti diperkenalkan pada peranti mudah alih pada Oktober 2021 dan kemudian di desktop pada Disember 2022. Menurut Google ciri klasik ini dik
Pelaburan Google bukti kepada daya saing semasa Malaysia - Tengku Zafrul
Pelaburan terkini Google memaparkan daya saing Malaysia, kemudahan menjalankan perniagaan dan kepentingan yang semakin meningkat sebagai hab serantau untuk inovasi digital.
Malaysia berada di kedudukan strategik sebagai hab pusat data serantau - Pakar
Perjalanan Malaysia ke arah menjadi hab serantau untuk pusat data didorong oleh gabungan faktor strategik termasuk kestabilan ekonomi dan ketersambungan yang kukuh.
Google uji ciri AI antikecurian bagi telefon pintar Android di Brazil
Mulai Julai, pengguna di Brazil yang memiliki peranti Android yang bersesuaian akan dapat mengakses versi beta kunci pengesanan kecurian Google, kunci peranti luar talian dan kunci jarak jauh.
Bekas kakitangan Google, OpenAI ingin perlindungan jika beri amaran bahaya AI
Antara taktik yang digunakan bekas majikan ialah meminta mereka menandatangani dokumen tidak mendedahkan maklumat (NDA).
Google, Microsoft dan Intel tubuh UALink bangunkan piawaian terbuka penyambung pemecut cip AI
Dengan penglibatan syarikat-syarikat teknologi utama untuk menggunakan UALink, setiap ahli boleh menyumbang kepakaran mereka untuk faedah bersama.