Ahead of Tuesday's presidential election, the Rev. Frank Pavone took an aborted fetus, laid it upon an altar Sunday and posted a live video on Facebook. Pavone, a Catholic priest who heads New York-based Priests for Life, said the fetus was entrusted to him by a pathologist for burial.
During an already heated and divisive campaign season, Pavone's video has raised questions for some about what is appropriate antiabortion and political activism in the church. As of Monday afternoon, the video, which is 44 minutes long, had 236,000 views. In it, he holds up a poster of graphics of abortion procedures.
In Pavone's Facebook appeal, he wrote, "we have to decide if we will allow this child killing to continue in America or not. Hillary Clinton and the Democratic platform says yes, let the child-killing continue (and you pay for it); Donald Trump and the Republican platform says no, the child should be protected."
A call placed to the spokesman for the Diocese of Amarillo in Texas, which is Pavone's diocese, was not immediately returned Monday. The receptionist, however, said her phone has been ringing off the hook.
In a blog post for Patheos, Scott Eric Alt argued that what Pavone did was sacrilege, a violation of Catholic Church canon law, which states that the altar is "reserved for divine worship alone, to the exclusion of any secular usage."
"Being pro-life is about respecting the dignity of the human person," Alt wrote. "It is the antithesis of respect for the dignity of the human person to use a dead child as a political prop to lobby for your presidential candidate the day before an election."
Pavone is a high-profile antiabortion activist who has clashed with leadership within the Catholic Church. In 2014, Cardinal Timothy Dolan cut ties with the priest after Dolan suggested that Pavone had stonewalled financial reform within his organization, which is based out of Staten Island. A spokesperson for Dolan, who is also chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Committee on Pro-Life Activities, said the archdiocese does not have a relationship with Pavone and has no comment on the video.
In a blog post for the Archdiocese of New York, Ed Mechmann wrote about the "revulsion" he felt about the video.
"A human being has been sacrificed and the altar of God has been desecrated, all for politics," he wrote. "Everyone who respects the dignity of every human person should reject and disavow this atrocity."
Trump has been a divisive candidate for antiabortion activists, who have tried to keep women at the forefront. Earlier this year, the GOP candidate suggested that women who have abortions should be punished, a position he later reversed.
If anything, Pavone's actions are a signal that the older antiabortion groups are on their way out, said Charles Camosy, a bioethics professor at Fordham University and a board member of Democrats for Life of America. The use of graphic images has been a divisive issue in the antiabortion movement, and Camosy said Monday that nearly everyone he knows, including conservatives, have condemned Pavone's video.
"This plays into the narrative so many people have of us, that this is a bunch of wild extremists who will put an aborted fetus on Facebook Live. Come on!" Camosy said. "This is the death rattle for the culture-war-focused pro-life movement."
The video comes after a group of Catholics inserted fliers into parish bulletins in San Diego claiming that a vote for a Democrat is a mortal sin. San Diego's Bishop Robert McElroy criticized the flier.
And on Saturday, Pope Francis condemned the political use of fear and the building of walls, describing the refugee crisis as "a problem of the world" and urging political leaders to do more.
The Washington Post
Tue Nov 08 2016
Trump has been a divisive candidate for antiabortion activists.
Yahya Sinwar sah dibunuh Israel - Hamas
Hamas mengesahkan Ketua Biro Politiknya, Yahya Sinwar terbunuh dalam serangan Israel.
Mohd Yusoff dilantik Ketua Polis Kelantan yang baharu
Polis Diraja Malaysia umum pertukaran empat pegawai kanan berkuat kuasa 18 Nov ini.
Bilangan warga asing di Jepun cecah rekod 3.5 juta setakat Jun
Bilangan warga asing yang menetap di Jepun mencapai rekod tertinggi lebih 3.5 juta pada separuh pertama 2024, menurut data kerajaan.
Industri perbankan sifatkan Belanjawan 2025 langkah positif ke arah ekonomi mampan, inklusif
Institusi kewangan sifatkan Belanjawan 2025 langkah positif ke arah mencapai ekonomi inklusif yang mampan di samping mengekalkan tanggungjawab fiskal dan keadilan sosial.
Pembinaan WCE beri manfaat kepada Melaka - Ketua Menteri
Laluan berkenaan bakal menjadi alternatif untuk pengguna ke Melaka selain Lebuhraya Utara-Selatan.
Belanjawan 2025: Komitmen berterusan kerajaan terhadap tanggungjawab fiskal, pertumbuhan seimbang - Khazanah
Khazanah dan syarikat-syarikat portfolionya kekal selaras dengan visi Belanjawan 2025 dan sedia menyokong agenda yang berpandangan jauh.
Belanjawan 2025: Microsoft komited bekerjasama dengan kerajaan untuk pacu inovasi AI
Microsoft komited bekerjasama dengan kerajaan untuk memacu inovasi kecerdasan buatan (AI).
Peruntukan RM65 juta dapat pastikan pekebun kecil peroleh MSPO - Johari
Peruntukan sebanyak RM65 juta menerusi Belanjawan 2025 diharapkan dapat memberi suntikan kepada lebih ramai pekebun kecil untuk mendapatkan Pensijilan Minyak Sawit Mampan Malaysia (MSPO).
Belanjawan 2025: Naik taraf prasarana, rawatan penyakit kritikal & program penjagaan kesihatan
Kementerian kesihatan menerima peruntukan sehingga RM45.3 bilion dengan fokus menaik taraf prasarana, rawatan penyakit kritikal, dan program penjagaan kesihatan.
Belanjawan 2025: Perolehan kapal baharu APMM mampu tingkat keupayaan jaga perairan negara
Pengumuman peruntukan pembelian tiga kapal baharu bagi APMM dalam Belanjawan 2025 dilihat tepat pada masanya.