The decision by the Ipoh High Court yesterday has put a fullstop to a four-year legal battle by kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi to keep her children in her own religion.
The judgement, which had quashed the certificates of conversion of the three children who had been converted to Islam by their father in 2009, was hailed a "landmark decision".
However, two legal academicians said that it was too early to call this judgement a landmark decision as the case has yet to reach the country’s supreme courts, both the Courts of Appeal and the Federal Court.
Constitutional expert Professor Emeritus Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi said that to call it a ‘landmark’ would be akin to “predicting a heavy weight fight after the first round.”
“It’s too early to say decisively. It is (still) a ding dong battle, and this is just one round and I expect this very sad saga, which is most painful for children caught in the middle, to continue,” said Shad.
The law professor said that the only way this issue can come to a conclusion was if a political decision is made by the country’s top leadership.
“This is an issue where the courts are divided. It is reluctant to take a stand. A political decision has to be made. The executive must step in and make a stand,” he said.
He proposed that legislation has to be debated in Parliament and therefore put an end to the “endless ding dong battle” once and for all.
Shad, who is of the opinion that Article 12(4) of the Federal Constitution which provides that "the religion shall be decided by his parent or guardian” denotes the plural, maintained that a Federal Court precedent on this matter was flawed.
In 2007, the Federal Court ruled that R. Subashini’s husband – who had embraced Islam – had the right to convert their children to his faith without her consent.
“These conversions are not conversion necessarily out of faith. In many cases, it was done to basically teach the wife the lesson. It is the easy way out and basically Islamic law us being abused to circumvent the procedures. That is not good for either the cause of justice or reputation of Islam,” commented Shad.
Differing from Shad’s interpretation, law lecturer from Universiti Islam Antarabangsa (UIA) Assoc Proffesor Dr Shamrahayu Abdul Aziz said that the Federal Court judgement was the prevailing legal standing at the moment.
“The previous Federal Court decision still stands, I don’t know how far the High Court in this case has considered that court’s decision, we have to look at the full written judgement,” said Shamrahayu.
She said that this was not a landmark case if the facts between this case and the Subashini case was similar, and added that it would likely still be appealed to higher courts.
“So far, the newspaper reports on the decision is confusing,” she said.
On whether the thought one parent should be able to convert a child, Shamrahayu said that the constitution is clear on the matter.
“Because the provision uses the term parent, not parents. Logically speaking that is the mother or father. If you want to ask parents who are divorcing can they both decide on the religion of the child? It may not be possible.”
Shamrahayu said that the argument that the interpretation for singular terms in the Constitution also include the plural has already been deliberated by the annexe courts and cannot be used anymore.
Earlier this month, the government has decided to withdraw the Administration of the Religion of Islam (Federal Territories) Bill 2013, which was introduced in Dewan Rakyat on June 26.
Section 107(b) of the Bill talks about conversion by a single parent, to be withdrawn and groups had argued that islamisation of children should have the consent of both parents.
The Bill was tabled for the first reading in Parliament on June 26.
Teoh El Sen
Fri Jul 26 2013
!['Stop ding-dong battle over child conversion' 'Stop ding-dong battle over child conversion'](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2013-06/61371305259_295x200.jpg)
![PPZ-MAIWP catat RM511 juta kutipan zakat tahun ini, naik 10 peratus PPZ-MAIWP catat RM511 juta kutipan zakat tahun ini, naik 10 peratus](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-04/61714481430_TBNAIM.jpg)
PPZ-MAIWP catat RM511 juta kutipan zakat tahun ini, naik 10 peratus
PPZ-MAIWP mencatat kutipan zakat sebanyak RM511 juta dari Januari hingga Jun tahun ini dengan peningkatan sebanyak 10 peratus berbanding tempoh sama pada 2023.
![Empat terbunuh, puluhan cedera dalam protes antikuota di Bangladesh Empat terbunuh, puluhan cedera dalam protes antikuota di Bangladesh](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/71721144143_TBBANGLADESHCAMPUS.jpg)
Empat terbunuh, puluhan cedera dalam protes antikuota di Bangladesh
Abu Sayeed, seorang daripada penyelaras dan pelajar di Universiti Begum Rokeya di Rangpur utara, terbunuh semasa pertempuran dengan polis.
![Misi ekonomi produk agrikomoditi ke India perkukuh hubungan dua hala Misi ekonomi produk agrikomoditi ke India perkukuh hubungan dua hala](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61721130378_JohariAbdulGhani.jpg)
Misi ekonomi produk agrikomoditi ke India perkukuh hubungan dua hala
KPK akan mengadakan Misi Ekonomi Produk Agrikomoditi Malaysia ke India pada 17-18 Julai ini.
![Golongan belia pemacu penting bentuk masa depan industri pembuatan Malaysia - FMM Golongan belia pemacu penting bentuk masa depan industri pembuatan Malaysia - FMM](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-05/41715247870_SohThianLaijpg.jpg)
Golongan belia pemacu penting bentuk masa depan industri pembuatan Malaysia - FMM
Pemimpin perniagaan dan usahawan daripada golongan belia merupakan pemacu penting yang akan membentuk masa depan industri pembuatan Malaysia, kata Presiden Persekutuan Pekilang-Pekilang Malaysia.
AWANI Tonight: 16 July 2024
#AWANITonight with @Hafiz_Marzukhi
1. Govt mulls amending Penal Code to deal with cyberbullying
2. England's Southgate resigns after Euro 2024 Final defeat
#AWANIEnglish #AWANINews
1. Govt mulls amending Penal Code to deal with cyberbullying
2. England's Southgate resigns after Euro 2024 Final defeat
#AWANIEnglish #AWANINews
![9,241 pelajar Palestin terbunuh dalam serangan Israel sejak 7 Oktober 9,241 pelajar Palestin terbunuh dalam serangan Israel sejak 7 Oktober](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/81718630490_Smokerises.jpg)
9,241 pelajar Palestin terbunuh dalam serangan Israel sejak 7 Oktober
9,318 pelajar terbunuh dan 14,671 lagi cedera di Semenanjung Gaza manakala di Tebing Barat, 103 pelajar terbunuh dan 505 lagi cedera.
![Penumpang Singapore Airlines meningkat hampir 14 peratus pada Jun Penumpang Singapore Airlines meningkat hampir 14 peratus pada Jun](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61721142800_AirbusA.jpg)
Penumpang Singapore Airlines meningkat hampir 14 peratus pada Jun
Rangkaian penumpang Kumpulan SIA meliputi 125 destinasi setakat Jun dan rangkaian kargo terdiri daripada 129 destinasi.
![Empat individu termasuk pasangan pempengaruh bebas tahanan reman Empat individu termasuk pasangan pempengaruh bebas tahanan reman](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-05/41716613114_TBsprm.jpg)
Empat individu termasuk pasangan pempengaruh bebas tahanan reman
Kesemua individu juga perlu hadir ke pejabat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) sebulan sekali untuk melaporkan diri.
![KPT alu-alukan syor PAC guna garis panduan pelaburan universiti awam untuk anak syarikat KPT alu-alukan syor PAC guna garis panduan pelaburan universiti awam untuk anak syarikat](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/81719822088_ZambryAbdKadir.jpg)
KPT alu-alukan syor PAC guna garis panduan pelaburan universiti awam untuk anak syarikat
KPT mengalu-alukan cadangan PAC berhubung pelaksanaan dan pemakaian Garis Panduan Pelaburan dan Pembiayaan oleh Universiti Awam 2024, kepada anak-anak syarikat di bawah seliaan kementerian itu.
![SUKMA 2024: Sepak takraw wanita mungkin digugurkan SUKMA 2024: Sepak takraw wanita mungkin digugurkan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61720679430_AbdulKarimRahman.jpg)
SUKMA 2024: Sepak takraw wanita mungkin digugurkan
Sepak takraw wanita berpasukan berkemungkinan akan digugurkan daripada senarai acara temasya Sukan Malaysia (SUKMA) 2024 berikutan jumlah penyertaan kurang daripada jumlah minimum yang ditetapkan.
![9 tip elak terlupa anak dalam kereta 9 tip elak terlupa anak dalam kereta](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2017-04/81493253752_carseat.jpg)
9 tip elak terlupa anak dalam kereta
Jangan letak kerusi kanak-kanak di belakang kerusi pemandu. Di situ adalah titik buta (blind spot).
![Mahkamah benarkan wanita batal saman bekas kekasih Bosnia Mahkamah benarkan wanita batal saman bekas kekasih Bosnia](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2013-12/51388488766_295x200.jpg)
Mahkamah benarkan wanita batal saman bekas kekasih Bosnia
Hakim Timothy Finlayson Joel dalam keputusannya turut menolak tuntutan balas oleh Chung Shun Yee, 29, terhadap Ervin Ahbabovic, 41.