PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today allowed the applications by former Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and his son Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin for an interim stay of the summary judgment obtained by the Inland Revenue Board (IRB) for them to pay more than RM1.7 billion in tax arrears pending their leave to appeal at the Federal Court.
A three-member bench of the Court of Appeal led by judge Datuk Azizah Nawawi granted the stay after hearing submissions by counsel Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, representing Najib and Mohd Nazifuddin, and IRB deputy solicitor, Dr Hazlina Hussain.
The other two judges on the bench were Justices Datuk M.Gunalan and Datuk Che Mohd Ruzima Ghazali.
"This is our unanimous decision. We find that there are special circumstances that warrant us to exercise our discretion to allow an interim stay of the execution of summary judgment in both applications until the hearing of the leave application in the Federal Court," said justice Azizah.
Earlier, lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah submitted that there were special circumstances for a stay to be granted.
He said there would be a trail of repercussions, such as Najib losing his position as a Member of Parliament (MP) and will no longer be able to contest in any elections, if he was declared bankrupt.
"The execution is now happening because they (IRB) are pursuing at lightning speed to make my client bankrupt. The enforcement (of the summary judgment) has got to stay to allow my client to go to the leave application as well as the appeal itself," he said.
He also argued that there was bad faith conducted on part of the government to declare Najib bankrupt as there were clear errors in the additional assessments.
He said the IRB had maliciously calculated as income, donations received by his client from the late King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, which had been refunded, the interbank transfers within Najib's bank accounts and cancelled cheques, among others.
"This is rather a mala fide (bad faith) eagerness to declare my client bankrupt despite the obvious deformity of assessment," he added.
Meanwhile, Hazlina said the allegation that IRB had acted in bad faith in the recovery action was unfounded.
The applicant (Najib) should have come forward and do installment payment, as it is a common action taken by any judgment creditor, she added.
On Sept 9, the Court of Appeal affirmed the High Court's decision to allow IRB's applications to enter summary judgment to recover tax arrears of RM1.69 billion from Najib and RM37.6 million from Nazifuddin.
On the same day, a Court of Appeal three-member panel led by Justice Datuk Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil had allowed an interim stay application brought by Najib and Mohd Nazifuddin with conditions that they filed their notice of motion and stay application by this week.
A summary judgment is when the court decides a particular case summarily, without calling witnesses to testify in a trial.
They had appealed to the Court of Appeal against two previous High Court rulings.
On July 22, last year, High Court judge Datuk Ahmad Bache allowed the IRB's application for a summary judgment to be entered against Najib in its suit to recover the RM1.69 billion in taxes from the latter for the period between 2011 and 2017.
As for Mohd Nazifuddin, High Court judge Ahmad Zaidi Ibrahim, had on July 6 last year, ordered him to pay RM37.6 million in unpaid taxes to IRB after allowing the board's application to enter a summary judgment against him in its tax arrears suit seeking to recover the unpaid amount from him between 2011 and 2017.
On Feb 4 this year, the IRB issued a bankruptcy notice against Najib for his failure to pay the amount as the summary judgment was not stayed, while Mohd Nazifuddin was also served with a bankruptcy notice on April 30 this year over failure to pay the amount as ordered by the High Court.
Najib and Nazifuddin subsequently filed separate notices of motion on Sept 14 this year to the Federal court seeking leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision in dismissing their appeals.
They sought the Federal Court to determine nine legal questions.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Thu Oct 21 2021
A three-member bench of the Court of Appeal led by judge Datuk Azizah Nawawi granted the stay after hearing submissions by counsel Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah. - BERNAMA photo
10 Berita Pilihan - (15 Ogos 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Pasukan PBB lawat Bangladesh, siasat pembunuhan protes pelajar
Pasukan penyiasat Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu (PBB) akan melawat Bangladesh minggu depan untuk menyiasat ratusan kematian semasa protes yang diketuai pelajar baru-baru ini, menurut pegawai badan dunia itu pada Khamis.
Gempa bumi bermagnitud 5.7 gegar timur laut Taiwan
Gempa bumi berukuran 5.7 skala richter melanda daerah Timur Laut Taiwan pada Khamis.
Angka kematian di Gaza cecah 40,000 individu
Pasukan tentera Israel melakukan tiga pembunuhan beramai-ramai terhadap keluarga-keluarga di Semenanjung Gaza dalam tempoh 24 jam lepas, mengakibatkan sekurang-kurangnya 40 rakyat Palestin terbunuh dan 107 lagi cedera, menurut sumber perubatan.
Jepun tamatkan amaran gempa bumi mega
Dalam tempoh berjaga-jaga, Agensi Meteorologi Jepun tidak melihat sebarang pergerakan gempa bumi yang luar biasa atau kerak bumi.
Rakyat UK terancam dengan imigran rampas peluang pekerjaan
Bimbang golongan imigran akan merampas peluang peluang pekerjaan menjadikan rakyat United KIngdom terutamanya mereka yang mempunyai masalah ekonomi melihat imigran sebagai satu ancaman.
Parti Pheu Thai pilih anak perempuan Thaksin calon PM
Paetongtarn, 37, adalah anak perempuan kepada jutawan yang juga bekas Perdana Menteri Thailand, Thaksin Shinawatra.
Pemilihan anak Thaksin sebagai PM Thailand dianggap tidak efektif
Pemilihan anak perempuan bekas Perdana Menteri Thailand, Thaksin Shinawatra, Paetongtarn Shinawatra, untuk menggantikan Srettha Thavisin sebagai Perdana Menteri negara itu dianggap sebagai tidak efektif.
Angka kematian di seluruh Semenanjung Gaza meningkat kepada 40,005, lebih 92,401 cedera
Perkhidmatan kecemasan masih tidak dapat membantu ramai mangsa dan membawa keluar mayat yang terperangkap di bawah runtuhan.
DNA mangsa kebakaran di Pagoh diperoleh, jenazah dijangka dikebumikan esok
Polis mengesahkan telah menerima laporan ujian asid deoksiribonukleik (DNA) dua mayat mangsa yang rentung dalam kebakaran rumah di Kampung Paya Redan, Pagoh, Johor Jumaat lepas.
Pengarah SRC adalah profesional, bukan boneka yang diupah oleh Najib - Ismee
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Ahli Lembaga Pengarah SRC International adalah sekumpulan profesional dan bukannya 'boneka' Najib.
Najib bantah permohonan Majlis Peguam cabar keputusan Lembaga Pengampunan
Najib Razak memfailkan bantahan awal terhadap tindakan Majlis Peguam mencabar keputusan Lembaga Pengampunan mengurangkan hukuman penjara dan denda.
Belum ada keputusan mengenai representasi Najib untuk gugurkan pertuduhan
Pejabat Peguam Negara belum memutuskan mengenai representasi Najib bagi menggugurkan tiga pertuduhan tambahan pengubahan wang haram membabitkan RM27 juta dana SRC International.
Mahkamah tolak permohonan Najib, anak lelaki tangguh prosiding bankrap
Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak dan anaknya Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin untuk menangguhkan prosiding kebankrapan terhadap mereka.
Rayuan Najib tangguh prosiding kebankrapan ditolak
Mahkamah Tinggi KL menolak permohonan Datuk Seri Najib Razak dan anaknya, Datuk Mohd Nazifuddin untuk menangguh prosiding kebankrapan tunggakan cukai lebih RM1.7 bilion dan RM37.6 juta kepada LHDN.
Mahkamah tolak permohonan DNAA Najib, Mohd Irwan
Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan Najib dan Mohd Irwan Serigar supaya dilepas tanpa dibebaskan (DNAA) dari tuduhan pecah amanah RM6.6 bilion.
Rosmah nafi barang kemas, beg tangan, aksesori mewah dibeli hasil aktiviti haram
Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor menegaskan bahawa barang kemas, beg tangan dan barangan mewah lain yang berada dalam milikannya bukan dibeli dengan wang hasil aktiviti haram.
Noh Omar sah sertai Bersatu berkuat kuasa serta-merta
Bekas Pengerusi UMNO Selangor, Tan Sri Noh Omar sah menyertai Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu) berkuat kuasa serta-merta.
Najib gagal dalam permohonan cabar kewujudan titah adendum jalani tahanan di rumah
Mahkamah Tinggi KL tolak permohonan Najib untuk dapatkan kebenaran mulakan semakan kehakiman bagi mencabar kewujudan Titah Adendum.
Pembelaan Najib dibenar sertai semakan kebenaran keputusan Lembaga Pengampunan
Najib dibenarkan untuk menyertai prosiding permohonan Badan Peguam Malaysia, bagi mendapatkan kebenaran memulakan semakan kehakiman, di Mahkamah Tinggi di sini, pada Selasa.