KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here dismissed Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak's bid to set aside the Mareva injunction obtained by 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) and one of its subsidiaries, to prevent him from disposing of or reducing the value of any of his assets in Malaysia amounting to US$681 million.
Judge Atan Mustaffa Yussof Ahmad today ruled that the injunction should be retained until the end of 1MDB's suit.
A Mareva injunction is an order preventing someone from disposing of property pending the outcome or completion of a legal action.
On Feb 8 last year, the court granted an ex-parte application for a Mareva injunction by 1MDB and Global Diversified Investment Company Limited (formerly known as 1MDB Global Investments Limited), who are the first and fifth plaintiffs in the suit against Najib and several other individuals.
The injunction also limits Najib from withdrawing no more than RM100,000 per month for living and legal expenses, and if more is required, he would need to get written permission from the lawyers of 1MDB and Global Diversified.
In his ruling, Judge Atan Mustaffa said that the court finds that the plaintiffs (1MDB and its subsidiary) have a good arguable case against the defendant (Najib) that he has assets within the jurisdiction, that there is a risk of the assets being removed or dissipated before judgment could be satisfied.
The judge also contended that the plaintiffs have complied with Order 29 rule 1(2A) of the Rules of Court 2012 in fulfilling the duty to make full and frank disclosure to this court at the time they made their ex parte application.
"Najib, as a shadow director, owes the plaintiffs the same fiduciary duties as a formal director. These duties include acting in good faith, being honest, and not advancing personal interests over the company's interests," he said adding that, Najib breached these duties by diverting funds, particularly siphoning US$681 million from the US$3 billion bonds into his personal account.
The judge also said that the plaintiffs have demonstrated that Najib, while serving as Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, had committed misfeasance in public office by abusing his authority.
"Specifically, he directed the creation of the 2013 bonds, which resulted in the misappropriation of US$1,592,311,599, including a transfer of US$681 million to his personal account. This was done with either malicious intent or reckless indifference, causing harm to the plaintiffs and the public," said the judge.
Judge Atan Mustaffa also pointed out that Najib had previously given "inconsistent" accounts about the sum of RM114 million seized by authorities at Pavilion Residences after the 2018 General Election and Najib had alleged that the RM114 million was held in trust for UMNO.
"If the funds were genuinely held in trust for UMNO, the defendant, who was no longer the party president, should have taken steps to transfer the funds to the party. Instead, evidence shows that the money was received by his representative, indicating personal custody rather than fiduciary responsibility," he said.
The judge said Najib also failed to make full disclosure of his assets, as required under the terms of the injunction.
"A critical analysis of his conduct, particularly on his failure to make complete asset disclosures, demonstrates a blatant disregard for the procedural obligations of these proceedings," he said and ordered Najib to pay costs of RM20,000 to the entities.
The five plaintiffs in the suit were 1MDB, 1MDB Energy Holdings Limited, 1MDB Energy Limited, 1MDB Energy (Langat) Limited and Global Diversified Investment Company Limited.
And named as defendants were Najib, 1MDB's former deputy chief financial officer and executive finance director Terence Geh Choh Heng, former general counsel Jasmine Loo Ai Swan, executive director of business development Casey Tang Keng Chee, former director of investments and chief investment officer Vincent Beng Huat Koh, former chief financial officer and subsequently chief operating officer Radhi Mohamad, former director of investments Kelvin Tan Kay Jim and former chief investment officer Nik Faisal Ariff Kamil.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Sep 27 2023
The High Court dismissed Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak's bid to set aside the Mareva injunction obtained by 1MDB and one of its subsidiaries. - BERNAMA/Filepic
8,500 premis diberi amaran susulan pelaksanaan Akta 852 - Dzulkefly
Sejumlah 8,500 premis di seluruh negara diberi amaran kerana melanggar Akta Kawalan Produk Merokok Demi Kesihatan Awam 2024 (Akta 852) yang berkuat kuasa pada 1 Okt lepas.
JDT raih kejuaraan berganda, julang Piala Futsal Malaysia 2024
Skuad futsal Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT) meraih kejuaraan berganda musim ini apabila muncul juara Piala Futsal Malaysia 2024 selepas menewaskan Selangor 3-2.
AWANI Ringkas: 21 warga Bangladesh ditahan cuba masuk Malaysia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Teo Nie Ching dipilih Pengerusi DAP Johor
Ketua Wanita DAP Teo Nie Ching dipilih sebagai Pengerusi DAP Johor bagi penggal 2024/2027 menggantikan Liew Chin Tong yang menyandang jawatan itu sejak 2014.
AWANI 7:45 [06/10/2024] – Tuduhan palsu | Krisis kemanusiaan semakin parah | Tindakan akibat tekanan anak di Gaza | Misi lawatan PM di Pakistan
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Dzulfitri Yusof dibawakan oleh #Maxis5G
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Tiada perbincangan ubah Islam agama rasmi, kata PM
- Setahun genosid di Gaza, yang mati lebih baik, kerana hidup terus merana
- Wanita Palestin mohon maaf kepada rakyat Malaysia
- Wartawan Malaysia tempuh detik cemas terkepung di Islamabad
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- Tiada perbincangan ubah Islam agama rasmi, kata PM
- Setahun genosid di Gaza, yang mati lebih baik, kerana hidup terus merana
- Wanita Palestin mohon maaf kepada rakyat Malaysia
- Wartawan Malaysia tempuh detik cemas terkepung di Islamabad
PRESMA cadang ‘kedai mamak’ tidak lagi jual rokok
Persatuan Pengusaha Restoran Muslim Malaysia (PRESMA) mengesyorkan semua premis makanan naungannya agar tidak lagi menjual rokok di premis mereka.
DAP tidak pernah cadang Kerajaan Perpaduan, selesa sebagai pengimbang di Johor - Loke
DAP tidak pernah mencadangkan agar Kerajaan Perpaduan ditubuhkan di Johor, sebaliknya parti itu selesa memainkan peranan sebagai pengimbang di negeri itu.
AWANI Global: konflik Asia Barat: Perang Israel-Hezbollah
Israel semakin 'menggila' memperluaskan tujuan perangnya menyerang sempadan negara berdaulat yang bersekutu dengan Hamas. Sejauh mana keangkuhan Israel membuka mata dan merubah pandangan dunia terhadap kekejaman peristiwa di Palestin pada 7 Oktober tahun lalu?
AWANI Ringkas: Kelapa diletak di bawah Lembaga Koko Malaysia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Kejadian tembak di Selama, polis tahan pemilik kebun
Polis menahan seorang lelaki tempatan kerana disyaki terlibat kes tembakan sehingga menyebabkan seorang individu cedera di Kampung Sumpit Beras, Rantau Panjang dekat Selama Jumaat lepas.
Keputusan sama ada Najib perlu bela diri kes 1MDB 30 Okt ini
Keputusan sama ada Najib yang menghadapi pertuduhan menyalah guna kedudukan dan pengubahan wang dana 1MDB perlu membela diri atau tidak akan diputuskan 30 Okt ini.
Saksi utama pendakwaan boleh dipercayai, beri keterangan konsisten terhadap Najib - DPP
Saksi terbabit mengesahkan bahawa mereka telah bertindak atas kepercayaan bahawa arahan kepada mereka datang terus daripada Najib.
Tindakan Najib jelas menunjukkan kepentingannya dalam 1MDB - Pendakwaan
Mahkamah diberitahu tindakan dan kelakuan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak dalam pelbagai insiden berkaitan dengan 1MDB jelas menunjukkan beliau mempunyai kepentingan peribadi.
Keyakinan Najib RM2 bilion adalah derma dari Arab Saudi munasabah - Peguam
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa keyakinan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak bahawa RM2 bilion merupakan derma dari Arab Saudi adalah munasabah.
Rayuan Najib, anak tangguh prosiding bankrap didengar 6 Jan 2025
Rayuan Najib dan anak terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Tinggi menolak permohonan mereka untuk menangguhkan prosiding kebankrapan terhadap mereka akan didengar pada 6 Jan tahun depan.
Kes 1MDB: Hakim tanya peguam Najib beza perbelanjaan peribadi dan politik
Hakim dalam kes 1MDB Najib mengajukan soalan kepada pasukan pembelaan mengenai perbezaan antara perbelanjaan untuk tujuan peribadi dan politik.
Najib: Tugas Lembaga Pengarah urus dana SRC
Najib berkata beliau mempercayai BOD untuk mengendalikan hal ehwal syarikat itu kerana ia terdiri daripada individu yang berkelayakan tinggi.
Najib: Akaun bank saya digunakan bagi tujuan CSR
Najib berkata meskipun akaun semasa tersebut didaftarkan atas nama beliau, ia tidak digunakan bagi perbankan peribadi atau urusan persendirian.
Najib tidak minta kajian kebolehlaksanaan untuk pinjaman SRC
Najib berkata ini kerana Lembaga Pengarah SRC International adalah terdiri daripada individu yang mahir dan berkebolehan.
Saman SRC: Najib nafi arah SRC menerusi Nik Faisal
Najib Tun memberitahu bahawa bekas Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif SRC Nik Faisal Arif Kamil bukanlah penghubung antara syarikat itu dan dirinya.