PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court has quashed the development order granted by the Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) for a proposed development of a high-rise residential project in Taman Rimba Kiara in Taman Tun Dr Ismail (TTDI), Kuala Lumpur.
A three-member bench comprising Chief Judge of Malaya Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah, Federal Court Judges Datuk Nallini Pathmanathan and Datuk Rhodzariah Bujang, in a unanimous decision today, said there were no merits in the appeal.
The proposed development comprises 9 blocks of high-rise apartments, particularly 8 blocks of 42-54-storey serviced apartments and 1 block of 29-storey affordable apartments, with a basement and podium carparks.
In 2021, the Court of Appeal had quashed the development order after it ruled in favour of a judicial review sought by the TTDI Residents Association.
When reading out the judgment, Justice Nallini ruled that the development order ought to be set aside as there was a conflict of interest since the mayor was on the board of trustees for Yayasan Wilayah Persekutuan (YWP), which is one of the four appellants.
Apart from DBKL and YWP, the other two appellants were Memang Perkasa Sdn Bhd and Bukit Kiara Public Housing Residents Association.
Justice Nallini held that when the foundation (YWP) entered into a joint venture agreement with Memang Perkasa prior to the alienation of the land, the mayor knew from the KL Structure Plan 2020 that the land use was green open space for public use.
"The alienation of the land to YWP in conjunction with the joint venture agreement with Memang Perkasa would entail a change in land use to mixed development. However, there was no compliance with the Federal Territories Act in terms of variation or amendment to the KL Structure Plan 2020.
"The mayor, therefore, wore three hats in three capacities, namely, the mayor was part of the entity that approved the subject land's alienation, the mayor was part of the applicant for planning permission, ie YWP as it was a member of the board of trustees, and the mayor was also the entity that granted the impugned development order on July 13, 2017," she added.
Justice Nallini also said that the decision-making behind the development order was flawed as it violated a requirement under the Federal Territories Act to inform members of the public and let them participate in the planning process.
This is particularly so in the present appeal where the local authority departed from the KL Structure Plan 2020 in issuing the development order, the judge added.
"The public ought not to have to wait until they file legal proceedings for the authority to then give reasons in the course of the legal proceedings. We hold that as public authorities act in the public interest, such authorities owe the public a duty of candour in judicial review proceedings to make full and fair disclosure of all relevant materials," she said.
Justice Nallini said such authorities have a primary duty to assist the court with all the materials necessary to enable the court to arrive at an accurate decision.
She said when the court finds of its own accord that there are issues relevant to the case which have not been brought to its attention, the court cannot be precluded from considering and deciding on such issues.
Justice Nallini also insisted that the TTDI residents have the legal standing to sue, as they had a genuine interest in the land.
The judge said it is incumbent upon the court to protect the public interest when land allocated for public space is removed from public use and utilised for private ownership, that too without the knowledge of the public.
"We have found the reasons stated in our full grounds of judgment that the Federal Territories Act and the KL Structure Plan 2020 have been contravened by the issuance of the impugned development order. It is therefore null and void and was correctly quashed by the Court of Appeal," said Justice Nallini.
The court then ordered DBKL to pay RM100,000 in legal costs to the residents, while YWP and Memang Perkasa have to pay RM80,000 and RM70,000, respectively.
On Jan 27, 2021, the Court of Appeal set aside the Nov 28, 2018 decision of the High Court which dismissed the judicial review brought by the residents to quash the conditional planning permission and development order by DBKL.
The residents filed the judicial review application on Aug 11, 2017, through the management bodies of Trellises Apartment, Kiara Green Townhouses, Residence Condominium, TTDI Plaza Condominium, The Greens Condominium, as well as TTDI Residents Association and four TTDI residents and home owners.
They named DBKL, the foundation, Memang Perkasa and the Bukit Kiara Public Housing Residents Association as respondents in the judicial review.
The residents sought a certiorari order to quash DBKL's development order as they claim that the 10.08ha Taman Rimba Kiara is a public park located in TTDI and Bukit Kiara area and a green lung of Kuala Lumpur.
The residents were represented by lawyer Datuk Gurdial Singh Nijar, while B. Thangaraj appeared for DBKL.
Counsel Tan Sri Cecil Abraham represented the foundation, while Khoo Guan Huat acted for Memang Perkasa and Jayanthi Balaguru for Bukit Kiara Public Housing Residents Association.
Youth and Sports Minister Hannah Yeoh, who is MP for Segambut, was present during today's online proceedings.
--BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Apr 18 2023
The alienation of the land to YWP in conjunction with the joint venture agreement with Memang Perkasa would entail a change in land use to mixed development, Justice Nallini said. - Filepic
Hulu Perak daerah terbaharu dilanda banjir kilat
Banjir kilat berlaku disebabkan hujan lebat berterusan selama dua jam di sekitar Gerik.
Kejayaan pembangunan Sabah jadi kayu ukur pada PRN, PRU16 - Rafizi
Rafizi berkata kerjasama antara parti adalah perkara yang terus dibincangkan dalam kerangka semangat Kerajaan Perpaduan.
88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara dapat pengiktirafan JAKIM
Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) telah memberikan pengiktirafan kepada 88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara setakat Mei tahun ini.
eWarga Emas bentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan berkesan, bersepadu - Noraini
Portal sistem warga emas (eWarga Emas) dibangunkan bagi membentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan warga emas yang berkesan dan bersepadu.
MITRA lulus lebih RM95 juta untuk 11 program masyarakat India
Kesemua program yang dalam pelaksanaan itu memberi tumpuan kepada usaha memperkasakan sosioekonomi komuniti India dalam negara.
Kestabilan sosiopolitik Sabah bolehkan agihan ekonomi saksama - Juhar
Smber daya, kekayaan alam semula jadi dan potensi ekonomi dalam masyarakat dapat dibahagi dengan cara memberi peluang sama kepada rakyat.
Kenanga jangka OPR stabil 3.0 peratus pada 2025
Kenanga Investment Bank Bhd menjangka Kadar Dasar Semalaman (OPR) kekal stabil pada 3.0 peratus sepanjang 2025.
Johor sasar jumlah ternakan cecah 200,000 ekor pada 2027
Johor menyasarkan jumlah ternakan di negeri ini mencapai hingga 200,000 ekor pada 2027 setelah berjaya mencapai jumlah pengeluaran ternakan sebanyak 152,000 ekor hingga bulan lepas.
Hargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat dan penglibatan - Lee Lam Thye
Lee Lam Thye menekankan keperluan mendesak untuk menghargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat, dan penglibatan yang lebih baik.
Malaysia perlu bersedia penuhi keperluan TBB yang semakin meningkat - Fadillah
Keperluan tenaga boleh baharu (TBB) di negara ini semakin meningkat seiring dengan keyakinan pelabur asing khususnya untuk mewujudkan pusat-pusat data.
Mahkamah Persekutuan putuskan tiada projek pembangunan di Taman Rimba Kiara
Mahkamah Persekutuan menolak perintah pembangunan yang diberikan oleh Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur (DBKL) bagi cadangan pembangunan projek kediaman di Taman Rimba Kiara di Taman Tun Dr Ismail (TTDI).
Tanah di Taman Rimba Kiara untuk pembangunan kediaman, bukan taman - Peguam
Tanah di kawasan Taman Rimba Kiara yang diperuntuk bagi projek pembangunan adalah untuk membina kediaman dan bukan sebagai taman awam.
Mahkamah Persekutuan benar Laporan Ketua Audit Negara diguna dalam rayuan Taman Rimba Kiara
Hakim memutuskan dokumen yang diminta oleh penduduk TTDI adalah dokumen awam di bawah Akta Keterangan dan boleh diterima.
Pembangunan Taman Rimba Kiara: DBKL dan tiga lagi dibenarkan merayu
DBKL dan tiga lagi memperoleh kebenaran untuk meneruskan rayuan terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Rayuan yang membatalkan perintah pembangunan projek perumahan Taman Rimba Kiara.
Tapak Taman Rimba Kiara: DAP, jangan terus tipu rakyat - Yayasan WP
Zaizalnizam berkata, sekiranya benar projek itu akan menjejaskan alam sekitar, mengapa menteri Pakatan Harapan sebelum ini tetap meneruskan projek itu.
Taman Rimba Kiara: C4 puji keputusan Mahkamah Rayuan, gesa siasat Ku Nan
C4 puji keputusan yang dibuat oleh Mahkamah Rayuan bagi projek pembinaan unit kediaman di Taman Rimba Kiara.
Mahkamah Rayuan batal perintah pembangunan DBKL bagi projek perumahan di Taman Rimba Kiara
Mahkamah Rayuan hari ini membatalkan perintah pembangunan yang dikeluarkan Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur (DBKL) bagi projek pembinaan unit kediaman di Taman Rimba Kiara.
Taman Rimba Kiara masih dibuka kepada orang ramai - Annuar Musa
Tindakan diambil oleh pemilik tanah iaitu Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur (DBKL) untuk menandakan sempadan perundangan.
Hanya mahkamah tentukan projek Taman Rimba Kiara - Khalid
Beliau sudah buat yang terbaik untuk menangani isu tersebut dan pada masa ini pihaknya sedang menyiapkan laporan berkenaan cadangan isu projek pembangunan berkenaan untuk perhatian Kabinet.
Wakil rakyat Segambut sambut baik isu Taman Rimba Kiara dibawa ke Kabinet
Yeoh berkata ini membolehkan cadangan balas yang dikemukakan oleh beliau bersama penduduk TTDI dan penghuni rumah panjang didengar oleh Kabinet.