NEW DELHI: The conviction of Indian opposition leader Rahul Gandhi in a criminal defamation case last week has led to calls for change to a law that treats defamation as a crime and instead to make it a civil offence.
Gandhi was found guilty of defamation for comments he made in a 2019 election speech and sentenced to two years in jail. He is out on bail and is expected to appeal.
Below is a history of laws that govern defamation in India and attempts to amend them.
HISTORY OF DEFAMATION AS A CRIMINAL OFFENCE
Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code enacted by British colonial rulers in 1860 made defamation a criminal offence and Section 500 set out punishment.
These statutes have survived multiple challenges including in the Supreme Court.
India's law of torts considers defamation a civil offence.
Anyone found guilty of criminal defamation can be jailed but a civil offence means they can only be made to pay damages.
The criminal law has been invoked in cases filed against journalists, politicians and industry leaders but convictions have been rare.
"Criminal defamation laws, including insult provisions that increase protection for public officials or that grant similar safeguards to State institutions are often used by powerful actors to silence criticism, limit public discussion and protect interests, rather than to legitimately ensure respect for the right of reputation,” UNESCO said in a 2022 report.
WHERE ELSE IS DEFAMATION CRIMINAL?
UNESCO, the U.N. cultural agency that promotes press freedom, said in 2021 at least 160 countries had laws that consider defamation a criminal offence.
"Criminal defamation laws have an inhibitory and silencing effect, even before a conviction,” it said.
Defamation remains a criminal offence in 39 of 47 countries in Africa, all Arab states, 38 of the 44 UNESCO member states in South, Southeast and East Asia, and 20 of 25 UNESCO member states in west Europe and North America also have it on their statutes.
WHICH COUNTRIES HAVE DECRIMINALISED DEFAMATION?
Since the 1990s, dozens of countries have decriminalised defamation. India's law on defamation borrows from British laws, but Britain itself repealed it in 2009.
Some other countries that have decriminalised defamation since 2000 include Ukraine (2001), Sri Lanka (2002), Ireland (2009), Norway (2015), Zimbabwe (2016), Kenya (2017) and the Maldives (2018).
While the United States does not have any federal criminal defamation laws, about 20 of its states and territories still have them, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe said in a 2021 report.
UNESCO said advances in jurisprudence and soft law, as well as strong pushes by advocacy groups, had resulted in some progress towards decriminalisation in a number of countries in the past two decades.
WHAT ATTEMPTS HAVE BEEN MADE IN INDIA TO DECRIMINALISE DEFAMATION?
In a landmark 2016 case, India's Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the penal code section that makes defamation a criminal offence. The two dozen petitioners who challenged the criminalisation of defamation included Rahul Gandhi.
The top court rejected the challenge to the provision and held that it was a reasonable restriction on free speech and was neither "vague, nor excessive nor arbitrary" and did not consider criminal defamation disproportionate.
"Protection of reputation is a fundamental right. It is also a human right. Cumulatively it serves the social interest," the court said.
WHAT DO LEGAL EXPERTS SAY?
As conviction with maximum punishment is uncommon in criminal defamation cases, researchers with the Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy think tank argued that in most cases "conviction of the accused is rarely the goal".
"Harassment and intimidation through the process of prosecution is the actual punishment, particularly when an alternative civil remedy against defamation is available," they wrote in the Times of India on Saturday.
However, Supreme Court advocate Raju Ramachandran said the section on criminal defamation "is carefully and elaborately worded" and should stay. "The test should be how it affects the common citizen and not journalists or politicians," he told Reuters.
Reuters
Wed Mar 29 2023
![Why Indian opposition leader Gandhi faces jail for defamation Why Indian opposition leader Gandhi faces jail for defamation](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-03/71680074560_INDIA.jpg)
India's main opposition Congress partys leader Rahul Gandhi holds a news conference, after he was disqualified as a lawmaker by India's parliament on Friday, at partys headquarter in New Delhi, India. - REUTERS
![Kerajaan lihat semula perjanjian penjualan air kepada Singapura - Fadillah Kerajaan lihat semula perjanjian penjualan air kepada Singapura - Fadillah](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/81720085306_FadillahYusof.jpg)
Kerajaan lihat semula perjanjian penjualan air kepada Singapura - Fadillah
Fadillah berkata perkara itu sudah berlaku ketika zaman pentadbiran bekas Perdana Menteri Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad lagi.
![Pelancong asing ditahan disyaki cabul pekerja spa di Pulau Perhentian Pelancong asing ditahan disyaki cabul pekerja spa di Pulau Perhentian](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2022-07/51658407048_Cabul.jpg)
Pelancong asing ditahan disyaki cabul pekerja spa di Pulau Perhentian
Polis menahan seorang pelancong lelaki warga Maghribi kerana disyaki mencabul seorang juruterapi wanita rakyat tempatan di Pulau Perhentian.
Warga Thailand seludup diesel dihadapkan mahkamah
Seorang pemandu lori warga Thailand dihadapkan ke mahkamah atas menyeleweng 322 liter minyak diesel minggu lalu.
ADUN Rembia sertai Pas: YB Kampar minta buka riben putih
Susulan pengumuman ADUN Rembia sertai Pas dalam sidang media, YB Kampar, Chong Zhemin kemuka Peraturan Mesyuarat dan menyifatkan satu penghinaan besar buat Parlimen.
#SisiTVParlimen
#AWANInews
#SisiTVParlimen
#AWANInews
![Malaysia, Brunei dalam proses rundingan muktamad sempadan darat negara - Mohamad Malaysia, Brunei dalam proses rundingan muktamad sempadan darat negara - Mohamad](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41720590984_DatukSeriMohamadH.jpg)
Malaysia, Brunei dalam proses rundingan muktamad sempadan darat negara - Mohamad
Mohamad Hasan berkata buat masa ini, kerja-kerja penandaan dan pengukuran di lapangan telah meliputi 175.96 km atau 33.3 peratus daripada keseluruhan jarak sempadan.
Kim Pan Gon undur diri kesan kepada Harimau Malaya
Apa reaksi peminat Harimau Malaya dan penganalisis sukan mengenai peletakan jawatan Kim Pan-Gon?
Masuk Pas untuk sama-sama susah dengan rakyat - ADUN Rembia
Muhamad Jailani berkata, sebelum ini beliau pernah menghantar surat kepada Lembaga Disiplin UMNO memohon untuk memecat keahliannya daripada parti Melayu itu.
![Perang berlarutan antara punca kelewatan penghantaran Black Hawk Perang berlarutan antara punca kelewatan penghantaran Black Hawk](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-04/51712121864_TBADLYZAHARIjp.jpg)
Perang berlarutan antara punca kelewatan penghantaran Black Hawk
Perkara itu dimaklumkan pihak Aerotree Defence and Services Sdn Bhd iaitu syarikat yang dipertanggungjawabkan dalam kontrak perolehan perkhidmatan sewaan helikopter berkenaan.
Keghairahan final Euro 2024 dibawakan ke restoran mamak
Kemeriahan dan keghairahan perlawanan final UEFA EURO 2024 antara Sepanyol dengan England di Berlin, Jerman dirasai di Malaysia, dibawakan oleh 'Astro BizOne Watch Party' di Restoran Hakim, Seksyen 7, Shah Alam.
![Polis kesan remaja lelaki hilang sejak enam hari lepas Polis kesan remaja lelaki hilang sejak enam hari lepas](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61721115027_MuhammadAdiLagik.jpg)
Polis kesan remaja lelaki hilang sejak enam hari lepas
Polis sedang berusaha mengesan seorang remaja lelaki yang dilaporkan hilang oleh keluarganya di Kuala Pilah sejak enam hari lepas.
![Rahul Gandhi ketua pembangkang parlimen India Rahul Gandhi ketua pembangkang parlimen India](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-05/51714751562_TBRAHULGANDHI.jpg)
Rahul Gandhi ketua pembangkang parlimen India
Ahli politik terkemuka, Rahul Gandhi akan menjadi ketua pembangkang parlimen India.
![Pegawai kanan Parti Kongres India letak jawatan selepas keluar kenyataan rasis Pegawai kanan Parti Kongres India letak jawatan selepas keluar kenyataan rasis](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-05/61683990723_partikongresindia.jpg)
Pegawai kanan Parti Kongres India letak jawatan selepas keluar kenyataan rasis
Seorang pegawai kanan Parti Kongres India meletak jawatan selepas beliau membuat kenyataan didakwa rasis.
![Kerajaan Modi berjaya ketepikan usul undi tidak percaya Kerajaan Modi berjaya ketepikan usul undi tidak percaya](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-07/51689907250_NarendraModi.jpg)
Kerajaan Modi berjaya ketepikan usul undi tidak percaya
Usul undi tidak percaya ini dikecam keras Modi dan beliau mendakwa kumpulan pemimpin ini tidak percaya kepada demokrasi.
![India: Rahul Gandhi tamatkan perarakan perpaduan nasional dengan mesej menentang keganasan India: Rahul Gandhi tamatkan perarakan perpaduan nasional dengan mesej menentang keganasan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-01/41675113864_IndiasoppositionC.jpg)
India: Rahul Gandhi tamatkan perarakan perpaduan nasional dengan mesej menentang keganasan
Rahul dan ketua parti Kongres memulakan 'Bharat Jodo Yatra' pada 7 Sept di Kanyakumari, selatan India, merentasi 12 negeri, sejauh 3,500km.
![Ekonomi India terjejas akibat undang-undang kewarganegaraan baru Ekonomi India terjejas akibat undang-undang kewarganegaraan baru](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2019-12/51576361567_Congresspartyworke.jpg)
Ekonomi India terjejas akibat undang-undang kewarganegaraan baru
Ia berikutan kontroversi Rang Undang-Undang (RUU) Pindaan Kewarganegaraan (CAB) yang bertujuan memberi kewarganegaraan kepada pelarian bukan Islam dari tiga negara islam yang berjiran dengan India.
![Rahul Gandhi letak jawatan Presiden Parti Kongres Rahul Gandhi letak jawatan Presiden Parti Kongres](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2019-03/71552022439_INDIA.jpg)
Rahul Gandhi letak jawatan Presiden Parti Kongres
Rahul Gandhi semalam meletak jawatan sebagai pemimpin parti pembangkang utama India, Parti Kongres ekoran kekalahan memalukan kali kedua dalam pilihan raya.
![Ceritalah India: Kalau bukan Modi, siapa? Ceritalah India: Kalau bukan Modi, siapa?](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2019-04/41556506563_CERITALAHINDIA.jpg)
Ceritalah India: Kalau bukan Modi, siapa?
Veena pasti bahawa jika Perdana Menteri yang bertahan dipilih semula, anaknya akan mendapat pekerjaan: "Modi akan menyelesaikan masalah kami. Jika tidak Modi, siapa?"
![900 juta rakyat India keluar mengundi hari ini 900 juta rakyat India keluar mengundi hari ini](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2019-04/41554950977_INDIAELECTION.jpg)
900 juta rakyat India keluar mengundi hari ini
900 juta pengundi berdaftar layak menunaikan tanggungjawab masing-masing dalam pilihan raya terbesar di dunia bermula hari ini di India.
![Parti pembangkang utama India INC keluar senarai pertama calon PRU Parti pembangkang utama India INC keluar senarai pertama calon PRU](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2019-03/71552022439_INDIA.jpg)
Parti pembangkang utama India INC keluar senarai pertama calon PRU
Sebanyak 15 nama telah diumumkan dalam senarai calon pertama INC termasuk Presiden Parti Rahul Gandhi serta ibunya, Sonia Gandhi.