WASHINGTON: Early in the Biden administration, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken vowed that the United States would only hold talks with China if they led to "tangible outcomes" to resolve disputes between the strategic rivals.
Two-and-a-half years later, that approach appears to have changed.
Since the start of the summer, the administration has embarked on a largely unreciprocated push to talk with Beijing, establishing working groups and sending three cabinet-level officials and its top climate envoy to Beijing.
The strategy, intended in part to salvage a relationship that fell to a dangerous level earlier this year when the U.S. shot down a Chinese spy balloon, could lead to a meeting between U.S. President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping in November, their first in a year.
"The goal truly is channels of communication and ensuring we don't veer into conflict - simple as that," said a senior Biden administration official. "Temperatures are lower than they were."
But critics say the approach carries its own risk: that the talks and working groups will only pull focus away from - and possibly delay - sanctions, export controls and competition.
"The return to high-level economic dialogues is a win for China, especially as Beijing continues to stonewall and gaslight on military risk reduction, cyber theft, and human rights," said Ivan Kanapathy, a former White House National Security Council deputy senior director for Asia.
HARD CONVERSATIONS
China is a daunting diplomatic challenge for the United States. The Biden administration wants to counter the country's growing military without provoking a conflict and to push back on what it considers unfair business practices while avoiding an all-out trade war.
Officials say they are imposing tough measures when necessary while reiterating that the U.S. is open for dialogue to keep relations stable.
They point to the high-tech sector, where the U.S. has imposed sweeping restrictions on the export of semiconductors and bans on U.S. investment in certain Chinese tech companies while offering new incentives for companies to expand instead in the United States.
"The criticism we get from some on (Capitol) Hill and some in the academic community, of course, is that competing means you can't talk to China," said the administration official.
"That is a fundamental misunderstanding of diplomacy. The hard, difficult conversations are always with competitors."
Those conversations, said the official, include explaining concerns that U.S. technology is being used to improve the capabilities of China's military.
When successful, such dialogue can also ease tensions.
One possible sign of a thaw is China's recent assistance with the return of Travis King, a U.S. soldier detained in North Korea and transferred back home through Chinese territory.
Nonetheless, the rush of visits by U.S. officials to China – intended in part to queue up a meeting between Biden and Xi at November's Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation leaders summit in San Francisco – doesn't sit well with some critics and Republicans in Congress, who see stricter reciprocity as a wiser starting point.
A year of U.S. "diplomatic accommodation" has yielded no action to address market access for U.S. companies in China, theft of U.S. intellectual property, or Beijing's aggression in the disputed South China Sea, said Republican Congressman Mike Gallagher, who has run the House of Representative's select committee on China's Communist Party (CCP), often in close cooperation with Democratic lawmakers.
"Meanwhile, the administration has delayed, diluted or otherwise sacrificed defensive actions like tougher export controls or sanctions on CCP officials," he said.
NO DELAY IN CHINA POLICIES
Administration officials acknowledge China may see the U.S. push to engage as a chance to weaken or slow Washington's policies targeting China, particularly on exports in strategic industries such as semiconductors, but deny that this is happening.
They point to new fentanyl-related sanctions on China this week as evidence Beijing is not getting a pass, adding that long-delayed regulations to close loopholes on export controls to Chinese technology companies, such as Inspur Group, are coming soon.
The administration official denied the delays were to avoid upsetting China but were about "getting the technical pieces right, and balancing economic impact on our own domestic competitiveness."
Diplomats say engagement with China, while necessary, will rarely yield quick results.
A senior State Department official said the June visit to Beijing by Blinken - the first senior engagement since the spy balloon incident in February - helped reopen diplomatic channels even though it hasn't yielded tangible progress on issues such as restoring military-to-military communications, curbing fentanyl and reducing tensions in the South China Sea.
Still, said the official, those interactions have been important so that both sides can lay out clearly what their "bottom lines" are.
"This diplomacy is often very difficult. It’s often tense. Sometimes not particularly pleasant. But I think both sides believe it’s vitally important."
Reuters
Fri Oct 06 2023
Early in the Biden administration, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken vowed that the United States would only hold talks with China if they led to "tangible outcomes" to resolve disputes between the strategic rivals. - UNSPLASH
88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara dapat pengiktirafan JAKIM
Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) telah memberikan pengiktirafan kepada 88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara setakat Mei tahun ini.
eWarga Emas bentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan berkesan, bersepadu - Noraini
Portal sistem warga emas (eWarga Emas) dibangunkan bagi membentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan warga emas yang berkesan dan bersepadu.
MITRA lulus lebih RM95 juta untuk 11 program masyarakat India
Kesemua program yang dalam pelaksanaan itu memberi tumpuan kepada usaha memperkasakan sosioekonomi komuniti India dalam negara.
Kestabilan sosiopolitik Sabah bolehkan agihan ekonomi saksama - Juhar
Smber daya, kekayaan alam semula jadi dan potensi ekonomi dalam masyarakat dapat dibahagi dengan cara memberi peluang sama kepada rakyat.
Kenanga jangka OPR stabil 3.0 peratus pada 2025
Kenanga Investment Bank Bhd menjangka Kadar Dasar Semalaman (OPR) kekal stabil pada 3.0 peratus sepanjang 2025.
Johor sasar jumlah ternakan cecah 200,000 ekor pada 2027
Johor menyasarkan jumlah ternakan di negeri ini mencapai hingga 200,000 ekor pada 2027 setelah berjaya mencapai jumlah pengeluaran ternakan sebanyak 152,000 ekor hingga bulan lepas.
Hargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat dan penglibatan - Lee Lam Thye
Lee Lam Thye menekankan keperluan mendesak untuk menghargai warga emas melalui penjagaan, hormat, dan penglibatan yang lebih baik.
Malaysia perlu bersedia penuhi keperluan TBB yang semakin meningkat - Fadillah
Keperluan tenaga boleh baharu (TBB) di negara ini semakin meningkat seiring dengan keyakinan pelabur asing khususnya untuk mewujudkan pusat-pusat data.
Belanjawan 2025: Kesalinghubungan internet di sekolah, kampus jadi keutamaan - Fahmi
Fahmi berkata ia termasuk isu Internet di kawasan terpencil, pedalaman dan pulau-pulau dalam memastikan akses Internet berkelajuan tinggi lebih meluas.
Pelajar tahfiz perlu teroka bidang teknologi
Kira-kira 200,000 pelajar tahfiz di negara ini, perlu dipastikan untuk mempunyai kemampuan dan peluang menjadi tenaga penggerak kepada umat Islam Malaysia dalam meneroka bidang yang dahulu dilihat sebagai asing., tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Perjanjian gencatan senjata di Gaza perlu selesai segera - Antony Blinken
AS, Mesir dan Qatar akan melakukan segala yang mungkin untuk memastikan Hamas bersetuju dengan "cadangan perantara" tersebut.
Blinken bincang usaha terkini di Gaza dengan Al-Sissi di Mesir
Setiausaha Negara Amerika Syarikat Antony Blinken membincangkan rundingan gencatan senjata pusingan terkini di Gaza dengan Presiden Mesir Abdel-Fattah al-Sissi di bandar pesisir utara Al-Alamein.
Tentera Israel serang bangunan di Nuseirat, 5 terkorban
Kejadian dilaporkan berlaku menjelang lawatan Setiausaha Negara AS, Antony Blinken untuk mengadakan rundingan gencatan senjata.
Blinken tiba di Asia Barat usahakan gencatan senjata Gaza
Blinken akan bertemu dengan pemimpin kanan Israel termasuk Perdana Menteri Benjamin Netanyahu.
AS terlibat diplomasi sengit redakan ketegangan Timur Tengah - Blinken
Setiausaha Negara Amerika Syarikat (AS) Antony Blinken memaklumkan Washington terlibat dalam diplomasi sengit meredakan ketegangan di Timur Tengah pada Isnin.
Ribuan umat Islam di Tehran beri penghormatan terakhir kepada Ismail Haniyeh
Timbalan Ketua Hamas di Semenanjung Gaza, Khalil al-Hayya berkata ribuan umat Islam di Tehran mengiringi perjalanan pengebumian Ismail Haniyeh pada Khamis.
AS akan usahakan gencatan senjata di Gaza walaupun Ismail Haniyeh sudah tiada - Blinken
Gencatan senjata di Gaza adalah keperluan mendesak dan AS akan terus berusaha ke arah itu setiap hari.
Blinken dijadual adakan pertemuan dengan Wang Yi di Laos
Isu berkenaan situasi dan konflik di Myanmar mendominasi perbincangan dalam beberapa siri pertemuan Menteri Luar ASEAN.
AS semak penghantaran 900kg bom kepada Israel - Blinken
Bagaimanapun, kata Blinken, pentadbiran AS masih menyemak sekatan berkenaan.
Blinken dijadual hadir persidangan bantuan kemanusiaan untuk Gaza
Setiausaha Negara Amerika Syarikat Antony Blinken dijadual menghadiri persidangan bantuan kemanusiaan bagi Semenanjung Gaza yang dihoskan Jordan pada Selasa.