Facebook Inc chief executive Mark Zuckerberg took the witness stand in Dallas federal court on Tuesday and denied an allegation by a rival company that the virtual-reality technology of Facebook's Oculus unit was stolen.
Zuckerberg, the founder of one of the world's largest companies, faced hours of tough, public questioning about where Oculus obtained its ideas and how much he knew about the startup when Facebook bought it for $2 billion.
A jury is hearing evidence in a civil lawsuit brought by videogame publisher ZeniMax Media Inc against Oculus in 2014, in the middle of the Facebook-Oculus deal. ZeniMax said that Oculus unlawfully used its intellectual property to develop the virtual-reality system that includes the Rift headset.
During one heated exchange with ZeniMax lawyer Tony Sammi, Zuckerberg told a jury in the crowded courtroom that the technology was not even fully formed when Facebook bought it.
"Improving on that technology doesn't make it yours," Sammi countered. "If you steal my bike, paint it and put a bell on it, does that make it your bike?"
Zuckerberg, wearing a dark suit and striped tie rather than his typical T-shirt and jeans, answered, "no," but then added: "The idea that Oculus technology is based on someone else's is just wrong."
The 32-year-old Facebook founder has spoken about virtual reality as an important part of the company's future business, especially as the technology becomes less expensive and its uses clearer.
The Oculus acquisition was more expensive than the $2 billion price tag indicated, Zuckerberg said in court, describing $700 million spent to retain employees and $300 million in payouts for reaching milestones. Oculus originally wanted $4 billion, he said.
Sammi questioned whether Facebook knew what it was doing when it made the acquisition. Zuckerberg said the Oculus deal was done over a weekend in 2014, which Sammi said did not show sufficient due diligence. Zuckerberg said, though, in later testimony that Facebook researched Oculus for months.
At the time, Zuckerberg testified, he was not aware of any theft claims against Oculus.
"It's pretty common when you announce a big deal that people just come out of the woodwork and claim they own some part of the deal," Zuckerberg said.
On the stand, he also gave details about Facebook's $22 billion purchase of messaging service WhatsApp in 2014. While the deal was in progress, another company he did not identify made a last-minute bid that was higher, Zuckerberg said, but WhatsApp declined because of its good relationship with Facebook.
The Oculus lawsuit, in the sixth day of a jury trial, relates in part to programmer John Carmack.
Well-known for helping to conceive games such as "Quake" and "Doom," Carmack worked for id Software LLC before that company was acquired by ZeniMax. He is now the chief technology officer at Oculus.
Zuckerberg denied that Carmack has unfairly used computer code from his previous position. "There is no shared code in what we do," he said.
Zuckerberg said he has been interested in virtual reality since he was a student, but thought it was decades away from happening before he encountered Oculus. He told jurors how he used virtual reality to capture his daughter's first steps, so her grandparents could experience it later.
"We want to get closer to this kind of perfect representation, so you can capture a moment you had," he said.
The case is ZeniMax Media Inc et al v. Oculus VR Inc et al, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, No. 3:14-cv-1849.
Reuters
Tue Jan 17 2017
![Facebook's Zuckerberg questioned at trial over virtual-reality technology Facebook's Zuckerberg questioned at trial over virtual-reality technology](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2016-12/71482210067_MarkZuckerberg.jpg)
![Pelihara khazanah geologi Bukit Dinding, milik batuan tertua di KL Pelihara khazanah geologi Bukit Dinding, milik batuan tertua di KL](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/71724032473_BukitDindingSetia.jpg)
Pelihara khazanah geologi Bukit Dinding, milik batuan tertua di KL
Batuan di Bukit Dinding merupakan batuan tertua di Kuala Lumpur yang terdiri daripada Syis Dinding dengan usia sekitar 479 juta tahun.
Pelan Transformasi Ekonomi Bumiputera 2035
Kerajaan akan melancarkan Pelan Transformasi Ekonomi Bumiputera 2035 pada petang ini dan Astro AWANI akan membawakan secara langsung pelancaran tersebut.
![Kamala Harris seru genjatan senjata dalam kempen di Pennsylvania Kamala Harris seru genjatan senjata dalam kempen di Pennsylvania](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/51724031079_KamalaHarrisGaza.jpg)
Kamala Harris seru genjatan senjata dalam kempen di Pennsylvania
Kamala Harris memulakan kempen merentasi barat Pennsylvania dengan menyeru perjanjian gencatan senjata untuk Gaza.
FBM KLCI kembali ke paras 1,620 paras sebelum Monday Selloff
Adakah kembalinya FBM KLCI ke paras 1620 ini membawa maksud kembalinya rally dalam pasaran tempatan yang disokong oleh pengukuhan nilai ringgit dan pertumbuhan KDNK negara yang memberangsangkan.
![Suspek utama pembunuhan kejam Cikgu Istiqomah tiba di mahkamah Suspek utama pembunuhan kejam Cikgu Istiqomah tiba di mahkamah](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/61724031789_Suspek.jpg)
Suspek utama pembunuhan kejam Cikgu Istiqomah tiba di mahkamah
Suspek tiba di pekarangan Mahkamah Alor Gajah dengan menaiki kenderaan PDRM dan diiringi oleh anggota CID, jam 9.05 pagi.
Niaga hadapan MSM didagangkan berhati-hati minggu ini
Jumlah dagangan mingguan MSM susut kepada 312,466 lot daripada 427,161 manakala kepentingan terbuka jatuh kepada 225,277 kontrak daripada 278,122 yang dicatatkan pada minggu sebelum ini.
[Data & Statistik] Prestasi Bursa Malaysia setakat 19 Ogos 2024
Indeks petunjuk pasaran yang dibuka 2.28 mata lebih tinggi kepada 1,614.63, turun naik antara 1,605.69 dan 1,614.69 sepanjang sesi dagangan.
[Data & Statistik] Kedudukan MYR berbanding SGD setakat 19 Ogos 2024
Niaga AWANI bawakan prestasi terkini prestasi Ringgit Malaysia berbanding dolar Singapura.
![Kapal Filipina didakwa 'sengaja langgar' kapal China di Laut China Selatan Kapal Filipina didakwa 'sengaja langgar' kapal China di Laut China Selatan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-08/61724030372_tbSecondThomasShoa.jpg)
Kapal Filipina didakwa 'sengaja langgar' kapal China di Laut China Selatan
China dakwa, Filipina telah berulang kali mencetuskan provokasi dan menimbulkan masalah, melanggar peraturan sementara antara dua negara.
[Data & Statistik] Prestasi ringgit setakat 19 Ogos 2024
Ketua Ahli Ekonomi Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid berkata ringgit meningkat dengan ketara berbanding dolar AS sejak isyarat untuk penurunan kadar di AS mendapat momentum.