AS events unfold in France centring around Islamophobia, there is a feeling of déjà vu. We have witnessed a few times before this sequence of events. There is some provocation or other targeting the Prophet Muhammadinitiated by a non-Muslim group or institution. Predictably, Muslims react. In the midst of demonstrations and rallies, an act of violenceoccurs perpetrated by an offended Muslim and/orhis co-religionists. The violent act leads to further demonization of Muslims in the media which by this time is in a frenzy. Feeling targeted, some Muslim groups escalate their emotional response, sometimes causing more deaths to occur of both Muslims and non-Muslims even in countries far away from the place where the provocation first occurred. One also hears of calls to boycott goods produced in the country where it all started.
On this occasion too it was French president Emmanuel Macron’s vigorous assertion that cartoons of the Prophet produced by the satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo, in January 2015 and republished since represented freedom of speech that angered a lot of Muslims in France and elsewhere, though some other remarks he had made recently about ‘Islam being in crisis’ and ‘Islamic separatism’ had also annoyed some people. However, it was the beheading of a French schoolteacher who had shown the cartoons in a class discussion on freedom of speech by a Muslim youth of Chechen origin that provoked not only Macron but also other leaders and a huge segment of French society to react with hostility towards Muslims and even Islam. It should be emphasised that almost all major Muslim leaders and organisations in France also condemned the beheading.So did many Muslims in other parts of the world.
It is not enough just to denounce an ugly, insane murder of this sort. Not many Muslim theologians have argued publicly that resorting to mindless violence to express one’s anger over a caricature of the Prophet is an affront to the blessed memory of God’s Messenger. For even when he was physically abused in both Mecca and Medina, Prophet Muhammad did not retaliate with violence against his adversaries. He continued with his mission of preaching justice and mercy with kindness and dignity. It is such an attitude that should be nurtured and nourished in the Muslim world todayespecially by those who command religious authority and political influence among the masses.
If a change in approach is necessary among some Muslims, French society as a whole should also re-appraise its understanding of freedom of speech. Freedom of speech should never ever glorify the freedom to insult, to mock, to humiliate another person or community or civilisation. Respect for the feelings and sentiments of the religious other should be integral to one’s belief system, whether it is secular or not. Just because the French State andmuch of French society havemarginalised religion, it does not follow that it should also show utter contempt for a Muslim’s love and reverence for his/her Prophet especially when 6 million French citizens profess the Islamic faith.
Indeed, respecting and understanding the sentiments and values that constitute faith and belief has become crucial in a globalised world where at least 80 % of its inhabitants are linked in one way or another to some religion or other. We cannot claim to be champions of democracy and yet ignore, or worse, denigrate what is precious to the majority of the human family. This does not mean that we should slavishly accept mass attitudes towards a particular faith. Reforms should continue to be pursued within each religious tradition but it should not undermine respect for the foundations of that faith.
French leaders and elites who regard freedom of speech or expression as the defining attribute of their national identity, should also concede that there have been a lot of inconsistencies in their stances. A French comedian, Dieudenne, has been convicted in Court eight times for allegedly upsetting “Jewish sentiment” and is prohibited from performing in many venues. A cartoonist with Charlie Hebdo was fired for alleged “ anti-Semitism.” There is also the case of a writer, Robert Faurisson in the sixties who was fined in Court and lost his job for questioning the conventional holocaust narrative. Many years later, the French intellectual Roger Garaudy was also convicted for attempting to re-interpret certain aspects of the holocaust.
The hypocrisy of the French State goes beyond convictions in Court. While officials are rightfully aghast at the violence committed by individuals, France has a long history of perpetrating brutal massacres and genocides against Muslims and others. The millions of Algerians, Tunisians and Moroccans who died in the course of the French colonisation of these countries bear tragic testimony to this truth. Vietnam and the rest of Indo-China reinforce this cruel and callous record. Even in contemporary times, the French State has had no qualms about embarking upon military operations from Afghanistan and Cote d’ Ivore to Libya and North Mali which serveits own interests of dominance and control rather than the needs of the people in these lands.
Honest reflections upon its own misdeeds past and present are what we expect of the French state and society in 2020. There is no need to pontificate to others.This is what we would like to see all colonial powers of yesteryear do ----partly because neo-colonialism is very much alive today.
*Dr Chandra Muzaffar is the president of the International Movement for a Just World (JUST)
Dr Chandra Muzaffar
Mon Nov 02 2020
French leaders and elites who regard freedom of speech or expression as the defining attribute of their national identity, should also concede that there have been a lot of inconsistencies in their stances. - FILEpic/REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol
Sarawak bakal laksana persempadanan semula kawasan DUN tahun ini
Walaupun tidak mendedahkan jumlah sasaran kawasan baharu, Pengerusi GPS itu berkata beberapa faktor akan diteliti oleh SPR untuk melaksanakan persempadanan semula.
Terlantar atas katil, diusung ke pusat mengundi
Zul Majid, yang lumpuh separuh badan terpaksa menggunakan khidmat ambulans swasta untuk ke pusat mengundi di Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan (SMK) Ampang Pechah, di sini, kira-kira jam 12.30 tengah hari tadi.
Mesej tular dakwa Amerika Syarikat kenakan sekatan ke atas Malaysia adalah palsu - Fahmi
Mesej tular yang mendakwa Malaysia negara ASEAN pertama dikenakan sekatan oleh Amerika Syarikat adalah palsu, kata Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil.
Sheriff: Raih RM55 juta, cipta fenomena tersendiri!
Filem aksi terhebat karya pengarah, Syafiq Yusof, Sheriff kini sudah meraih kutipan RM55 juta!
Pemergian Mutang: Fadillah, Wan Junaidi akui hilang sahabat baik
Pemergian Yang Dipertua Dewan Negara Datuk Mutang Tagal bukan sahaja satu kehilangan besar kepada negara malah kepada masyarakat Orang Ulu di Sarawak.
Persempadanan semula DUN Sarawak perlu libatkan kawasan bandar dan luar bandar - Abang Jo
Premier Sarawak, Tan Sri Abang Johari Tun Openg berkata, kawasan yang terlibat wajar melibatkan penduduk pelbagai bangsa serta pembahagian kawasan bandar dan luar bandar
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: 55.79 peratus keluar mengundi setakat 4 petang
Peratusan keluar mengundi bagi PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu mencatatkan 55.79 peratus setakat 4 petang, menurut Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya (SPR).
AWANI Ringkas: Dakwaan palsu | Negara hilang pemimpin reformis
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
UNFF19: Malaysia nyata komitmen kekal 50 peratus liputan kawasan berhutan
Sehingga kini Malaysia mempunyai 54.58 peratus atau 18.05 juta hektar kawasan berhutan dan litupan pokok.
Patuhi adab, etika semasa ziarah di Bukit Uhud
Jemaah haji Malaysia yang menyertai ziarah luar di beberaap lokasi di Madinah sebagaimana diuruskan Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH) dinasihat mengambil ikhtibar daripada aktiviti dijalankan selain mengelak daripada melakukan perkara yang boleh menimbulkan khurafat semasa menziarah
Kerajaan disaran kaji semula kontrak bekalan alat ketenteraan dari Perancis
Akhramsyah berpendapat tindakan itu dikhuatiri akan membahayakan negara jika rakan kongsi negara berkenaan terus mengamalkan sikap anti Islam.
Pendirian Macron sukarkan proses perdamaian kaum, Islamofobia - Penganalisis
Pendekatan Presiden, Emmanuel Macron yang dilihat menekankan nilai permusuhan dan Islamofobia, menyukarkan lagi jalan perdamaian.
Presiden Perancis Emmanuel Macron tidak bertamadun - Tun M
Dr Mahathir menegaskan, Perancis harus mendidik rakyatnya agar menghormati perasaan orang lain.
Dua terbunuh dalam serangan di sebuah gereja di Nice, Perancis
Dua individu dilaporkan maut dalam satu kejadian serangan di sebuah gereja di bandaraya Nice, Perancis pada Khamis.
Karikatur nabi: Jangan ambil tindakan luar batasan agama, undang-undang - Jakim
Datuk Abdul Aziz Jusoh berkata ini kerana tindakan itu dibimbangi boleh mencetuskan suasana tidak harmoni antara penganut berbilang agama di negara ini.
Macron tidak hormat kebebasan beragama, bersifat perkauman - NGO
Menerusi satu kenyataan bersama, mereka menegaskan rakyat Malaysia perlu untuk bangkit bersama menunjukkan bantahan mengikut ruang lingkup undang-undang.
Malaysia kecam sekeras-kerasnya ucapan benci dan fitnah Islam
Malaysia menjunjung hak kebebasan bersuara serta hak asasi manusia selagi mana ia digunakan secara bertanggungjawab dan penuh hormat, sekali gus tidak menafikan serta melanggar hak pihak lain.
Hina Islam: Pas seru umat Islam boikot barangan buatan Perancis
Datuk Seri Abdul Hadi Awang menyeru umat Islam memboikot barangan buatan Perancis bagi menunjukkan solidariti terhadap Islam dan kemajmukan beragama dalam masyarakat.
Isu karikatur Nabi Muhammad: Dr Zulkifli titip surat kepada duta Perancis
Dr Zulkifli menulis surat khusus berhubung isu karikatur Nabi Muhammad SAW oleh Charlie Hebdo kepada Duta Perancis di Malaysia.
Isu karikatur Nabi Muhammad: Umat Islam serata dunia protes
Protes itu juga sebagai respons kepada tindakan Presiden Perancis Emmanuel Macron yang mempertahankan seorang guru yang mati dibunuh kerana membawa kartun itu ke dalam kelasnya.