Apple attorneys in the US antitrust case on e-books went on the offensive Thursday, attacking the credibility of government witnesses and seeking to debunk key elements of the government's case.
Apple attorneys grilled a trio of witnesses from Apple rival Amazon and undertook a bruising cross-examination of a Google executive.
Apple attorney Howard Heiss peppered Amazon executives during a series of contentious exchanges with skeptical questions on Amazon statements about its business profile and pointed out inconsistencies between Amazon testimony and documentary evidence.
Amazon is very "metrics-focused," Heiss said to Amazon's vice president for Kindle Russell Grandinetti during a cross examination.
Grandinetti had previously testified that he did not know Amazon's market share of the e-books market.
"We were a very large seller of e-books," Grandinetti said, while denying he could estimate Amazon's market share.
Heiss then presented a news article quoting another Amazon executive estimating the company's market share at 70-80 percent.
Amazon is a key witness in the government's case, which maintains that Apple conspired with publishers to orchestrate a transformation of the e-book market in early 2010 that cost consumers hundreds of millions of dollars.
In entering the market, Apple signed a series of "agency" model contracts with publishers, in which publishers set the price and guaranteed Apple a 30 percent commission.
Prior to Apple's entry, the e-book industry was dominated by Amazon and run on a "wholesale" model where retailers set the prices. Amazon charged $9.99 for bestsellers prior to Apple's entry into the market.
Part of the government's case is that Apple and publishers forced Amazon to switch to the agency model, resulting in higher prices.
Apple attorneys sought to show that Amazon faced an increasingly difficult market in late 2009 and early 2010 in which publishers were already planning hardball tactics -- even before Apple's entry.
Amazon's pricing model was unpopular not only with publishers, but also with agents and authors who worried about the erosion of intellectual property.
Grandinetti confirmed that by the end of 2009 four of the "Big Six" publishers announced plans to "window" bestselling books, meaning they would delay release of the Amazon e-book for a period of months until after the release of the physical book.
As five of the major publishers signed agency models with Apple, they contacted Amazon to renegotiate terms.
The first negotiation was with MacMillan Chief Executive John Sargent, who presented Amazon with the choice of shifting to an agency model or accepting a wholesale model with windowing for seven months.
"We expressed quite strongly how unpalatable the choice was," Grandinetti said of his encounter with Sargent. "The meeting was very tense."
Amazon initially tried to punish MacMillan by removing the "buy" button from MacMillan titles.
But Amazon ultimately capitulated after three days and quickly negotiated the agency model with MacMillan.
Soon after that, Amazon negotiated similar contracts with the other four publishers.
Apple attorneys sought to show that Amazon's shift to the agency model was its own decision and not orchestrated by Apple.
But Amazon officials testified that the publishers were forcing the change at Apple's behest.
Laura Porco, who was director of Amazon's Kindle Books at the time, told the court in a written declaration that the publishers informed Amazon that they were switching to agency "because that's what Apple made them do."
Porco told the court Thursday she was "alarmed" when the publishers demanded agency from Amazon.
"I felt like we were being pushed into something that was really terrible for consumers," Porco said.
Following Porco's testimony, Apple attorney Orin Snyder aggressively questioned Thomas Turvey, an executive in Google's book selling division.
Turvey said in a written deposition that publishers told him that they could not accept wholesale terms with Google because of their terms with Apple.
During the testimony, Turvey was unable however to name a single publishing executive who said this.
AFP
Fri Jun 07 2013
Pentagon, Jabatan Negara AS beri amaran jenayah perang Israel
Pegawai-pegawai tersebut telah memberi amaran peningkatan jumlah kematian di Gaza mungkin melanggar undang-undang antarabangsa.
200,000 pelarian tiba di Syria selepas serangan Israel ke atas Lubnan - UNHCR
Lebih 200,000 warga Syria dan Lubnan telah tiba di Syria dari Lubnan sejak serangan Israel bermula pada 23 Sept.
Belanjawan 2025: Kesalinghubungan internet di sekolah, kampus jadi keutamaan - Fahmi
Kementerian Komunikasi akan memberikan keutamaan dengan meneruskan usaha untuk meningkatkan dan memantapkan lagi prasarana kesalinghubungan melibatkan isu Internet, dalam Belanjawan 2025 yang akan dibentangkan pada 18 Okt ini.
Setahun solidariti, sokongan global untuk Palestin di tengah-tengah genosid berterusan Israel
Ribuan manusia di seluruh dunia turun ke jalanan untuk menyuarakan sokongan kepada Palestin dan menuntut keadilan.
Indonesia kecewakan China, raih kejuaraan badminton berpasukan campuran remaja dunia
Indonesia menewaskan China untuk muncul Juara Badminton Berpasukan Campuran Remaja Dunia dengan kemenangan 110-103 (mata terkumpul).
Bomba selamatkan tiga subkontrakor terkandas di kren pengangkat
Ketiga-tiga mangsa lelaki itu masing-masing berusia 24, 26 dan 32 tahun terkandas dengan anggaran ketinggian dua tingkat.
Hulu Perak daerah terbaharu dilanda banjir kilat
Banjir kilat berlaku disebabkan hujan lebat berterusan selama dua jam di sekitar Gerik.
Kejayaan pembangunan Sabah jadi kayu ukur pada PRN, PRU16 - Rafizi
Rafizi berkata kerjasama antara parti adalah perkara yang terus dibincangkan dalam kerangka semangat Kerajaan Perpaduan.
88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara dapat pengiktirafan JAKIM
Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) telah memberikan pengiktirafan kepada 88 badan pensijilan halal luar negara setakat Mei tahun ini.
eWarga Emas bentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan berkesan, bersepadu - Noraini
Portal sistem warga emas (eWarga Emas) dibangunkan bagi membentuk sistem penyampaian perkhidmatan warga emas yang berkesan dan bersepadu.
Amazon arahkan pekerja kembali bekerja di pejabat lima hari seminggu
Pekerja Amazon diarah kembali bekerja sepenuh masa di pejabat, dengan menekankan kepentingan bekerja secara bersemuka.
Amazon dilapor akan guna Claude AI untuk kuasakan Alexa generasi baharu
Amazon mungkin bekerjasama dengan Anthropic dan menggunakan Claude AI untuk menguasakan Alexa generasi baharu.
Langganan bulanan Alexa dengan AI akan tiba pertengahan Oktober ini
Alexa serba baharu ini turut akan lebih memahami konteks arahan pengguna secara mendalam termasuk dengan bertanya mengenai perkara yang disukai serta menyampaikan promosi jualan di Amazon.
Pelaburan AWS: Cerminan keyakinan pelabur terhadap Ekonomi Madani - PM
Anwar berkata ia bukan sahaja membawa limpahan besar kepada negara, malah kemakmuran berpanjangan buat rakyat.
AWS Region dilancarkan di Malaysia hari ini
Ia akan membuat pelaburan AS$6.2 bilion di Malaysia menjelang 2038, meningkatkan pertumbuhan ekonomi dan membantu perniagaan tempatan.
Amazon dilapor pertimbang kenakan caj bulanan untuk Alexa
Caj bulanan ini bakal menawarkan sejumlah akses tambahan dan kebolehan yang lebih baik melalui Alexa. Mengikut
NVIDIA pintas Amazon sebagai syarikat kelima paling bernilai di dunia
Nilai pasaran NVIDIA mencecah $1.78 trilion (RM 8.52 trilion) selepas pasaran saham ditutup berbanding Amazon dengan nilai $1.75 trilion (RM 8.37 trilion).
Amazon perkenal chatbot beli-belah AI 'Rufus'
Rufus masih di peringkat ujian beta dalam kelompok pengguna kecil di AS, sebelum dilancarkan lebih meluas pada minggu akan datang.
Amazon lancar cip Trainium2, Graviton4 untuk latihan AI serta pelayar data
Trainium2 direka untuk mempercepatkan proses latihan model sehingga empat kali lebih pantas berbanding cip generasi pertama.
Amazon bakal aktifkan AWS Region di Malaysia pada 2024
AWS Region membolehkan pelbagai data berkaitan disimpan di Malaysia, dan pada masa sama menawarkan kadar pendam rendah (low-latency rate) untuk perkhidmatan yang digunakan dalam negara.