KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today has directed the originating summons (OS) filed by former attorney-general Tan Sri Tommy Thomas regarding an investigation report on the contents of his memoir titled 'My Story: Justice In the Wilderness', to be converted to a civil suit and disposed off via full trial.
Judge Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh said he will now seek directions from the managing judge as to which civil court that the OS has to be transferred.
"I'm not prepared to strike out this OS. However, I am directing that this OS be heard and disposed via a full trial by a civil suit.
"Since the matter will be heard by a judge of a civil division, I will refrain from making any determination on the constitutionality or legality of the special task force (STF). It has to be canvassed at the civil court," the judge said.
Wan Ahmad Farid said this case also involves disputed issues of facts.
"The plaintiff (Thomas) is adamant that the whole exercise - the setting up of the STF, the declassification of the STF Report and its eventual release, the timing - which was close to the 15th General Election was due to one purpose - to attack the credibility of the plaintiff.
"In order to prove his point, the plaintiff relied on a speech made by the then Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob during a Barisan Nasional rally in Bagan Datuk on Oct 17, 2022. In the rally, Ismail Sabri purportedly told the crowd that he had caused the STF report to be made public so that it could be used as political bullets for the GE," he said.
According to Wan Ahmad Farid, in this OS, the plaintiff sought relief inter alia for the alleged reputational loss.
"The plaintiff said his constitutional rights were violated. He sought compensation. But the long and short of it is, it boils down to the claim of loss of reputation. The fact that the plaintiff anchored his claim on the potential breach of his constitutional rights does not dilute the main claim which is based on the tort of defamation.
"A claim of this nature cannot be resolved by way of affidavit evidence and shall be begun by writ," he said when delivering today's decision via Zoom proceeding. The judge made a decision with no order as to cost.
Thomas filed the suit on Oct 27, 2022, naming the special task force's chairman Datuk Seri Fong Joo Chung, seven other members of the team, as well as the government as defendants.
Besides Fong, the special task force comprises Datuk Seri Panglima Hashim Paijan, Datuk Dr Junaidah Kamaruddin, Datuk Jagjit Singh Bant Singh, Datuk Shaharudin Ali, K. Balaguru, Farah Adura Hamidi and Mohd Najib Surip.
Thomas, who was the Attorney-General from June 2018 to February 2020, had sought a declaration that the report titled 'Report of the Special Task Force - Investigation into the Allegations in the Book Titled "My Story: Justice In The Wilderness", was an invalid document and against the law.
In the originating summons, Thomas claimed the publication of the report violated Sections 499 and 500 of the Penal Code and/or Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 and sought a declaration that the publication of the report by the government, violated his right to his reputation as protected by Articles 5(1) and 13(1) of the Federal Constitution.
The book written by Thomas which was published in January 2021 courted a lot of controversies, which led to the Cabinet setting up a special task force on Oct 8, 2021, to conduct a study on the revelations contained in the book.
On Oct 13, 2022, the government declassified the special task force's report, which among other things, recommended that Thomas be investigated for possible offences.
Thomas was represented by counsel Mervyn Lai Wei Shiung and Haikaldin Mahyidin while Senior Federal Counsel Shamsul Bolhassan, Nur Irmawatie Daud and Liew Horng Bin acted for the defendants.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Oct 02 2023
Ex-AG Tan Sri Tommy Thomas sought a declaration, the report titled 'Report of the Special Task Force - Investigation into the Allegations in the Book Titled "My Story: Justice In The Wilderness", was an invalid document and against the law. - BERNAMA
LHDN berjaya kutip RM512.6 juta melalui PKPS 2.0 - Amir Hamzah
LHDN telah mengutip RM512.6 juta daripada keseluruhan taksiran cukai berjumlah RM1.29 billion sepanjang tempoh PKPS 2.0.
Positif COVID-19 tidak perlu kemaskini MySejahtera
Jika didapati positif Covid-19, para pesakit tidak lagi perlu untuk mengemaskini status kesihatan terkini di aplikasi Mysejahtera, kerana covid seharusnya dirawat sama seperti jangkitan saluran penafasan yang lain.
Kandungan video promosi Georgetown Festival diturunkan
Pasukan George Town Festival 2024 telah menurunkan semua siaran berkaitan video promosi sambutan 'George Town Festival 2024' atas dakwaan menyinggung perasaan budaya Melayu di Pulau Pinang yang seperti dilupai.
Ia berikutan tular penyiaran video promosi sambutan 'George Town Festival 2024' yang didakwa hanya mempromosikan kebudayaan kaum Cina dan India.
Ia berikutan tular penyiaran video promosi sambutan 'George Town Festival 2024' yang didakwa hanya mempromosikan kebudayaan kaum Cina dan India.
KPM teliti sukarelawan dari Singapura, alu-alukan pesara guru Bahasa Inggeris di Malaysia
KPM sentiasa terbuka dan mengalu-alukan pesara guru bahasa Inggeris dalam negara untuk terlibat dalam PdP bagi meningkatkan penguasaan bahasa tersebut.
Pengajar Bahasa Inggeris dari Singapura, antara tumpuan
Penglibatan tenaga pengajar dari Singapura antara yang menjadi tumpuan di Dewan Rakyat pada Isnin.
Negara kekurangan tekong, beri kesan kekurangan ikan
Malaysia berhadapan kekurangan tekong tempatan berpengalaman yang ketara untuk kapal nelayan tempatan, terutama bagi perikanan laut dalam.
Menteri Pertanian dan Keterjaminan Makanan Datuk Seri Mohamad Sabu berkata lebih ramai tekong tempatan perlu dilahirkan, kerana pada ketika ini orang luar terpaksa digunakan dan diberi peluang untuk berkhidmat sebagai tekong kapal nelayan tempatan di negara ini.
Menteri Pertanian dan Keterjaminan Makanan Datuk Seri Mohamad Sabu berkata lebih ramai tekong tempatan perlu dilahirkan, kerana pada ketika ini orang luar terpaksa digunakan dan diberi peluang untuk berkhidmat sebagai tekong kapal nelayan tempatan di negara ini.
Jenayah: Polis sahkan suspek teman lelaki Nur Farah Kartini
Lelaki yang ditahan polis bagi membantu siasatan berhubung penemuan mayat Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah, adalah teman lelakinya.
Suspek kes kematian Nur Farah Kartini direman tujuh hari
Seorang penjawat awam yang dikaitkan dengan penemuan mayat Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah, direman selama tujuh hari bagi membantu siasatan kes tersebut.
[TERKINI] Pan Gon bakal umum letak jawatan hari ini?
Tidak ada maklumat lanjut berkaitan sidang media berkenaan walaupun desas desus mengatakan ia melibatkan kepimpinan tertinggi FAM atau barisan kejurulatihan skuad Harimau Malaya?
Bukan masa sesuai untuk perkenalkan semula GST - Amir Hamzah
Menteri Kewangan II, Datuk Seri Amir Hamzah Azizan berkata bukan masa sesuai untuk perkenal semula GST. Katanya, kerajaan hanya akan perkenalkan cukai yang tidak memberi kesan kepada golongan rentan.
#AWANInews #SisiTVParlimen
#AWANInews #SisiTVParlimen
Najib mohon kerajaan halang tayangan dokumentari 'Man on the Run'
Muhammad Shafee berkata, apa yang lebih serius lagi adalah, Tommy turut membuat kesimpulan sendiri berhubung kes itu di luar mahkamah.
Laporan siasatan memoir: Tommy Thomas saman kerajaan, pasukan petugas khas
Tan Sri Tommy Thomas memfailkan saman terhadap pasukan petugas khas (STF) dan kerajaan Malaysia berhubung laporan siasatan memoirnya bertajuk "My Story: Justice In the Wilderness".
Rayuan Najib untuk kembalikan saman terhadap Tommy Thomas didengar 5 Feb
Peguam Daniel Annamalai, antara peguam yang mewakili Najib mengesahkan tarikh pendengaran rayuan itu.
Hakim Mahkamah Rayuan tarik diri dengar rayuan Najib saman Tommy Thomas
Beliau berhasrat menarik diri atas alasan suaminya pernah berkhidmat di bawah Thomas dan kerana kes berkenaan melibatkan kepentingan awam.
Najib dibenar ke mahkamah dengar rayuan saman RM1.9 juta terhadap Tommy Thomas pada 4 Okt
Najib dibenar hadir ke mahkamah minggu depan untuk pendengaran rayuannya berhubung saman RM1.9 juta terhadap bekas Peguam Negara, Tommy Thomas.
Senarai nama jawatankuasa RCI siasat buku Tommy Thomas akan dikemuka kepada Agong - Zahid
Ahmad Zahid berkata, butiran senarai nama itu akan dibawa oleh Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Undang-Undang dan Reformasi Institusi), Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said.
Rayuan Najib gugurkan dua peguam Tommy Thomas ditolak
Hakim Hanipah berkata tiada kaitan antara kedua-dua peguam cara itu dan punca tindakan Najib dalam saman tersebut.
Najib dibenar hadir ke mahkamah, ikuti prosiding rayuan berkaitan saman terhadap Tommy Thomas
Kehadiran bekas Perdana Menteri itu ke mahkamah adalah penting bagi membolehkan peguambela mendapat arahan yang sewajarnya daripadanya (Najib) berhubung rayuan itu.
Pendakwaan salah: Sundra Rajoo tidak teruskan saman terhadap Tommy Thomas, 12 lagi
Ini berikutan Sundra Rajoo telah memfailkan notis pemberhentian menerusi Tetuan Cheok Ng Lee Law Chambers pada 8 Mac lepas.
Laporan siasatan buku: Permohonan pasukan petugas, kerajaan batal saman Tommy Thomas didengar 15 Jun
Thomas memfailkan saman itu dengan menamakan Pengerusi Pasukan Petugas Khas, tujuh ahli pasukan itu dan kerajaan sebagai defendan.