Do cinemagoers care if a movie takes liberties with facts?
More critically in awards season, can doubts about the truth of a film torpedo Academy hopes?
Or do Oscars voters not really mind as long as they get a good story?
For several of the pictures eyeing Oscars glory on Sunday, in theory based on real events, those are vital questions.
Director Ava DuVernay's Martin Luther King Jr movie "Selma" is accused of misrepresenting president Lyndon Johnson as an enemy of the civil rights icon.
Some critics have slammed "American Sniper," Clint Eastwood's movie about elite US sharpshooter Chris Kyle -- credited with killing at least 160 people in Iraq -- for allegedly glorifying a mass murderer.
Other recent films which generated polemics included "Zero Dark Thirty," which competed for the Oscars in 2013.
Some accused it of making a heroine out of a CIA agent who practiced torture, while others said it helped re-elect President Barack Obama.
That was the year that the Best Picture Oscar went to "Argo," about a bold CIA operation to rescue six US diplomats trapped in Iran by the 1979 hostage crisis.
[INFOGRAPHICS]: OSCARS FUN FACTS YOU NEED TO KNOW: NOMINATIONS AND HOSTS
American hero attacked
The film, directed by Ben Affleck, was accused of playing fast and loose with the facts, notably failing to give credit for the major role Canada had in securing the US diplomats' freedom.
In earlier years Oliver Stone's "JFK" in 1991 and Ron Howard's 2001 movie "A Beautiful Mind" also fueled controversy.
"It doesn't help a movie to have controversy over it," said Tom Nunan, who produced the Oscar Best Picture "Crash" and who teaches at the UCLA School of Theatre, Film and Television.
Moreover, "it is not a coincidence that those controversies are happening now," when it could help to eliminate a rival in the crucial final stages of an Oscars campaign.
"Your competition is often responsible for pulling the tapestry out from under your feet," he told AFP.
Tom O'Neil, of the award season ranking and analysis website Goldderby.com, is more nuanced.
Members of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences "are very tolerant of liberties screenwriters take and of the fact that a role can get sanitized," he said.
"I don't think the 'American Sniper' controversy could hurt Bradley Cooper," its main star, he added, saying: "It could even help him. Voters might want to help an American hero if they feel he's under attack."
'Help viewers escape'
"The Theory of Everything," about British astrophysicist Stephen Hawking, is another accused of taking liberties -- this time with chronology and mis-portraying his relationship with his first wife Jane.
O'Neil said: "It's a love story that's being told, people are rooting for this story," so it probably didn't impact the movie's awards season prospects.
But he added: "The controversy over Lyndon Johnson in 'Selma' may have hurt that film.
"They can tinker with facts but you need to know who's the hero and who's the villain."
Oscars voters don't like it when a character's historical role or personality is transformed from one to the other, he said.
But Nunan said that some playing with the facts -- though not too much -- was inevitable.
"A motion picture has to take some liberties, otherwise it won't win the viewers emotionally," he said.
"The cinema experience is meant to entertain and help viewers escape the real world," he added.
AFP
Wed Feb 18 2015
![Fact vs fiction: can doubts torpedo an Oscar movie? Fact vs fiction: can doubts torpedo an Oscar movie?](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2014-03/41393760177_295x200.jpg)
For several of the pictures eyeing Oscars glory on Sunday, in theory based on real events, those are vital questions. - File Photo
![Watsons Malaysia bawa sambutan ulang tahun ke-30 ke ruang udara Watsons Malaysia bawa sambutan ulang tahun ke-30 ke ruang udara](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/81720195269_TBwatson.jpg)
Watsons Malaysia bawa sambutan ulang tahun ke-30 ke ruang udara
Bersempena dengan ulang tahun ke-30, peneraju peruncit produk penjagaan kesihatan dan kecantikan, Watsons Malaysia, menjalin kerjasama baharu dengan syarikat penerbangan tambang rendah, AirAsia.
![Pezeshkian dahului pilihan raya presiden Iran Pezeshkian dahului pilihan raya presiden Iran](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/51719657438_MasoudPezeshkian.jpg)
Pezeshkian dahului pilihan raya presiden Iran
Masoud Pezeshkian mendahului pusingan penentuan pilihan raya presiden Iran selepas 70 peratus undi selesai dikira setakat ini.
![Indeks Keamanan Global: Malaysia sasar kekal kedudukan 10 teratas - Saifuddin Indeks Keamanan Global: Malaysia sasar kekal kedudukan 10 teratas - Saifuddin](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41720081108_TBSAIFUDDINjpg.jpg)
Indeks Keamanan Global: Malaysia sasar kekal kedudukan 10 teratas - Saifuddin
Bagi GPI, Malaysia berada di kedudukan ketiga di peringkat Asia Pasifik, iaitu di belakang New Zealand dan Singapura.
Lahir 'darah pahlawan', Jojo juga amal disiplin ketat
Tiada apa yang mustahil, jika bekalan displin, minat, dan konsistensi diterapkan dalam sukan yang diceburi.
Petarung sensasi muda Malaysia, Johan “Jojo” Ghazali berkata beliau juga bertuah dikurniakan 'darah pahlawan' menyebabkan namanya kini sentiasa disebut-sebut sebagai masa hadapan dunia sukan Muay Thai.
Petarung sensasi muda Malaysia, Johan “Jojo” Ghazali berkata beliau juga bertuah dikurniakan 'darah pahlawan' menyebabkan namanya kini sentiasa disebut-sebut sebagai masa hadapan dunia sukan Muay Thai.
Johan 'Jojo' Ghazali mahu buka gelanggang di Sarawak?
Meskipun baru menginjak usia 18 tahun, sensasi muay thai negara Johan 'Jojo' Ghazal' tidak menolak kemungkinan untuk membawa sukan muay thai ke suatu tempat yang lebih tinggi.
Beliau berimpian besar untuk mewujudkan arena gelanggang muay thai di tempat beliau membesar sendiri iaitu di Sarawak, seperti juga Ratu Terjun Negara, Pandelela Rinong.
Beliau berimpian besar untuk mewujudkan arena gelanggang muay thai di tempat beliau membesar sendiri iaitu di Sarawak, seperti juga Ratu Terjun Negara, Pandelela Rinong.
Platform dekatkan Astro dengan masyarakat setempat
Bukan sahaja menjadi platform dalam membawa pengalaman baharu untuk Astro lebih dekat kepada pelanggan malah Jelajah Hello Kedah yang diadakan di Stadium Sultan Abdul Halim, Alor Setar mampu menjadi ruang terbaik untuk komuniti sekitar bertemu artis-artis kegemaran masing-masing.
![EURO 2024: Perancis pertahan tindakan Kylian Mbappe tidak habiskan permainan EURO 2024: Perancis pertahan tindakan Kylian Mbappe tidak habiskan permainan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/71720240313_KylianMbappe.jpg)
EURO 2024: Perancis pertahan tindakan Kylian Mbappe tidak habiskan permainan
Deschamps berkata adalah menjadi satu tindakan yang sia-sia untuk membiarkan Kylian Mbappe yang tampak keletihan untuk 15 minit terakhir masa tambahan.
Jabatan Perikanan Johor beri amaran kehadiran Petropoda berbahaya di perairan Mersing
Jabatan Perikanan Johor mengeluarkan amaran mengenai kehadiran sejenis hidupan laut gastropoda berbahaya yang dikenal pasti sebagai Petropoda Khususnya di perairan daerah Mersing.
!['Dugaan memang banyak, tapi Allah rezekikan kami' - Amy Mastura selamat tunai haji 'Dugaan memang banyak, tapi Allah rezekikan kami' - Amy Mastura selamat tunai haji](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61720240200_AmyMasturatunaih.jpg)
'Dugaan memang banyak, tapi Allah rezekikan kami' - Amy Mastura selamat tunai haji
Amy juga mendoakan agar Allah mengurniakan ibadah haji yang mabrur buatnya dan jemaah yang lain.
![PRK Sungai Bakap: Proses pengundian berjalan lancar pagi ini - Polis PRK Sungai Bakap: Proses pengundian berjalan lancar pagi ini - Polis](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/71720239876_tbmengundi.jpg)
PRK Sungai Bakap: Proses pengundian berjalan lancar pagi ini - Polis
Proses pengundian PRK Sungai Bakap pagi ini berjalan lancar dan tiada sebarang kejadian tidak diingini berlaku setakat ini.