The epic patent clash between Apple and Samsung went before the US Supreme Court on Tuesday, as the smartphone giants debated the value of design in a case with major implications for the technology sector.
The eight justices on the top court appeared divided on how to resolve the complex dispute over damages the South Korean smartphone giant owes Apple for copying key design features of the iPhone.
The case arguments came as Samsung faces a fresh but unrelated crisis as it halted production of a flagship handset for safety reasons, potentially imperiling the powerhouse South Korean brand.
Samsung, which has been ordered to pay $400 million for violating certain iPhone features, is challenging the legal precedent which requires the forfeiture of all profits from a product even if only a single design patent is infringed upon.
This key question on the value of design patents has rallied Samsung supporters in the tech sector, and Apple backers in the creative and design communities.
The justices Tuesday offered some support for both sides without providing a hint on the outcome of the case.
Justice Anthony Kennedy said Samsung's argument would create confusion for jurors in trying to apportion damages.
"If I'm the juror, I just don't know what to do," Kennedy told attorneys during the hearing. "I'd have the iPhone in the jury room; I'd -- I'd look at it. I just wouldn't know."
VW Beetle example
The court debate moved from smartphones to automobiles, and the importance of design to the Volkswagen Beetle, for example.
Justice Samuel Alito appeared to lean toward Samsung's position, saying, "Nobody buys a car, even a Beetle, just because they like the way it looks... What if it broke down every 50 miles?"
Offering a similar view, Justice Stephen Breyer said a single component cannot account for all profits: "A Rolls Royce thing on the hood? No, no, no. You don't get all the profit from the car."
Samsung attorney Kathleen Sullivan said the justices should consider all the components of a smartphone.
"A smartphone is smart because it contains hundreds of thousands of the technologies that make it work," she said.
She said the case could lead to more litigations because patent holders "carve the product up into multiple partial design claims... and find a little sliver of the phone on which infringement can be found."
Design 'not a component'
Apple lawyer Seth Waxman fired back that Samsung made a conscious decision to revive its fortunes by copying the iPhone.
"A design is not a component, a design is applied to a thing," Waxman said.
Waxman contended that Samsung's own documents showed that the South Korean giant acted to deal with "a crisis of design" and sought to copy the iPhone.
He noted that limiting the damages would offer little deterrence and encourage "counterfeiters and copyists."
Observers are watching to see how the court -- which has not taken up a design patent case in more than a century -- tips the balance between technological innovation and protecting intellectual property. A ruling is expected in several months.
The case is one element of the $548 million penalty Samsung was ordered to pay for copying the iPhone's distinctive front screen and graphical touchscreen interface.
Matt Levy of the Computer & Communications Industry Association said the debate suggested the justices were open to lowering the jury award.
"The damages statute for design patents was written to protect products like rugs, where the design was essentially the entire thing being sold," Levy said in a blog post.
"Congress certainly didn't intend to treat complex products as if only the outer appearance is what matters.... Based on what I heard, I think it's very likely that the (justices) will modify the lower court's decision."
Samsung has won the backing of major Silicon Valley and other IT sector giants, including Google, Facebook, Dell and Hewlett-Packard.
Apple is supported by big names in fashion and manufacturing. An amicus brief filed on behalf of design professionals, researchers and academics said they have no financial interest in the case but argue on the basis of "fundamental principles of visual design."
They cite precedents like the Coca-Cola bottle, which is an integral part of the value of the product.
The Supreme Court hearing took place hours after Samsung announced it was scrapping the production of Galaxy Note 7 smartphones, its new flagship device that has been mired in a disastrous recall over exploding lithium-ion batteries.
AFP
Wed Oct 12 2016
![Apple, Samsung clash in top US court patent battle Apple, Samsung clash in top US court patent battle](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2016-10/51476238686_AppleSamsung.jpg)
The case is one element of the $548 million penalty Samsung was ordered to pay for copying the iPhone's distinctive front screen and graphical touchscreen interface.
AWANI 7:45 [16/07/2024] - Suspek dibawa ke lokasi | Selamat tinggal rakyat Malaysia | Harimau Malaya hilang taring?
- Polis sahkan suspek bunuh Kartini anggota polis.
- Pan-Gon enggan dedah punca letak jawatan.
- Faisal Halim sedih mentor Pan-Gon undur diri.
- Pakai reben putih di Parlimen, tak salah.
- Pan-Gon enggan dedah punca letak jawatan.
- Faisal Halim sedih mentor Pan-Gon undur diri.
- Pakai reben putih di Parlimen, tak salah.
![E-sukan harus dijadikan kepentingan sehingga ke peringkat lebih tinggi E-sukan harus dijadikan kepentingan sehingga ke peringkat lebih tinggi](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61721128633_MohdHidayatMohdSa.jpg)
E-sukan harus dijadikan kepentingan sehingga ke peringkat lebih tinggi
Kerajaan juga harus wujudkan sebuah dasar yang jelas supaya kepentingan e-sukan ini mampu diperkembangkan ke masa hadapan.
![Kerajaan pandang serius penularan ideologi liberalism, pluralism Kerajaan pandang serius penularan ideologi liberalism, pluralism](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/61721122322_ZulkifliHasan.jpg)
Kerajaan pandang serius penularan ideologi liberalism, pluralism
Kerajaan sentiasa memandang serius terhadap penularan ideologi dan aliran pemikiran yang bercanggah dengan ajaran Islam seperti ideologi liberalism dan pluralism agama.
![Tidak dapat tidak, atlet RTG mesti bawa pulang emas - MOM Tidak dapat tidak, atlet RTG mesti bawa pulang emas - MOM](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-03/61710754100_MohdNazifuddinNaji.jpg)
Tidak dapat tidak, atlet RTG mesti bawa pulang emas - MOM
Atlet di bawah projek Road To Gold (RTG) tidak mempunyai pilihan selain memenangi emas yang diidam-idamkan Malaysia pada Sukan Olimpik 2024 di Paris.
![KEDA peruntuk RM3.37 juta tahun ini bagi keterjaminan makanan KEDA peruntuk RM3.37 juta tahun ini bagi keterjaminan makanan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-09/41693913999_RubiahWang.jpg)
KEDA peruntuk RM3.37 juta tahun ini bagi keterjaminan makanan
Lembaga Kemajuan Wilayah Kedah (KEDA) memperuntukkan RM3.37 juta pada tahun ini bagi memastikan keterjaminan makanan negara.
![Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41721021538_TBSHAMSUL.jpg)
Dewan Rakyat lulus RUU Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia
Rang Undang-Undang Agensi Kawalan dan Perlindungan Sempadan Malaysia 2024 yang bertujuan menubuhkan MCBA diluluskan persidangan Dewan Rakyat, hari ini.
![PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024 PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-03/61710922383_MasErmieyatiSamsud.jpg)
PAC akan mulakan prosiding isu dibangkit LKAN Siri 2/2024
Jawatankuasa Kira-Kira Wang Negara (PAC) akan memulakan prosiding bagi empat isu yang dibangkitkan dalam Laporan Ketua Audit Negara (LKAN) Siri 2/2024.
AWANI Ringkas: Kes bunuh Nur Farah Kartini | Skandal LCS
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
ADUN Rembia sertai Pas, kenapa tak umum tahun lepas? - MP Kampar
Chong Zhemin, tindakan tersebut seolah-olah satu penghinaan paling besar kepada Parlimen yang telah meluluskan pindaan Perlembagaan Persekutuan berkait Akta Antilompat Parti.
Masuk Pas untuk sama-sama susah dengan rakyat - ADUN Rembia
Muhamad Jailani berkata, sebelum ini beliau pernah menghantar surat kepada Lembaga Disiplin UMNO memohon untuk memecat keahliannya daripada parti Melayu itu.
![Anda kini boleh uji iOS 18 Public Beta Anda kini boleh uji iOS 18 Public Beta](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41721100842_iOSPublicBeta.jpg)
Anda kini boleh uji iOS 18 Public Beta
Walaupun iOS 18 Public Beta sedia dimuat turun, ia masih lagi dalam peringkat pembangunan dan ujian.
![Apple sasar permintaan iPhone 16 lebih tinggi tahun ini, selari pengenalan integrasi AI Apple sasar permintaan iPhone 16 lebih tinggi tahun ini, selari pengenalan integrasi AI](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/81719026701_tbAppleIntelligence.jpg)
Apple sasar permintaan iPhone 16 lebih tinggi tahun ini, selari pengenalan integrasi AI
Apple turut menyasarkan pendapatan tahunan 2024 yang lebih tinggi, selari pengenalan ciri kecerdasan buatan pada sistem operasi mereka.
![Peranti IoT baharu Apple untuk rumah tertiris dengan cip A18 Peranti IoT baharu Apple untuk rumah tertiris dengan cip A18](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/71720154048_tbAppleA.jpg)
Peranti IoT baharu Apple untuk rumah tertiris dengan cip A18
Peranti ini dikatakan akan berada dalam kategori yang sama dengan HomePod dan Apple TV iaitu aksesori untuk rumah.
![Apple dijangka mulakan pengeluaran AirPods dengan kamera inframerah menjelang 2026 Apple dijangka mulakan pengeluaran AirPods dengan kamera inframerah menjelang 2026](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2023-09/81694917770_Airpods.jpg)
Apple dijangka mulakan pengeluaran AirPods dengan kamera inframerah menjelang 2026
Mengikut laporan awal, ia dikatakan akan diintegrasikan bersama penggunaan Vision Pro sekali gus memberikan pengalaman yang lebih baik kepada pengguna ketika memakai set kepala tersebut.
![Suruhanjaya Eropah lancar siasatan ke atas App Store Suruhanjaya Eropah lancar siasatan ke atas App Store](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/61719225623_EuropeanCommission.jpg)
Suruhanjaya Eropah lancar siasatan ke atas App Store
Suruhanjaya Eropah akan meneliti amalan gergasi teknologi itu mengenakan bayaran kepada gedung aplikasi alternatif dan pembangun aplikasi setiap kali pengguna iPhone memasang perisian mereka.
![Apple, Meta bincang kerjasama penawaran kecerdasan buatan Apple, Meta bincang kerjasama penawaran kecerdasan buatan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/81719026701_tbAppleIntelligence.jpg)
Apple, Meta bincang kerjasama penawaran kecerdasan buatan
Antara perkara yang dibincangkan adalah mengintegrasikan model kecerdasan buatan yang dibangunkan Meta terus ke sistem Apple Intelligence.
![Microsoft kembali atasi Apple, NVIDIA sebagai syarikat paling bernilai di dunia Microsoft kembali atasi Apple, NVIDIA sebagai syarikat paling bernilai di dunia](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/81719200626_Microsoft.jpg)
Microsoft kembali atasi Apple, NVIDIA sebagai syarikat paling bernilai di dunia
Microsoft berada di kedudukan teratas dengan nilai pasaran $3.343 trilion (RM 15.75 trilion), dengan Apple di tangga kedua dengan nilai $3.191 trilion, dan NVIDIA pula dengan nilai $3.113 trilion.
![Apple Store pertama di Malaysia guna tenaga lestari sepenuhnya Apple Store pertama di Malaysia guna tenaga lestari sepenuhnya](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/51718860047_AppleStore.jpg)
Apple Store pertama di Malaysia guna tenaga lestari sepenuhnya
Ia akan dibuka secara rasminya pada 22 Jun ini, sekali gus memudahkan pengguna tempatan mendapatkan pelbagai produk Apple.
![NVIDIA atasi Microsoft sebagai syarikat paling bernilai NVIDIA atasi Microsoft sebagai syarikat paling bernilai](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/51717639416_NVIDIA.jpg)
NVIDIA atasi Microsoft sebagai syarikat paling bernilai
NVIDIA, Microsoft dan Apple kekal sebagai syarikat yang mempunyai nilai pasaran melebihi $3 trilion.
![Apple fokus pembangunan iPhone 17 yang lebih nipis untuk 2025 Apple fokus pembangunan iPhone 17 yang lebih nipis untuk 2025](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-06/81718597559_iPhoneApple.jpg)
Apple fokus pembangunan iPhone 17 yang lebih nipis untuk 2025
Apple dijangka memperkenalkan peranti-peranti lain yang nipis dalam tahun-tahun akan datang.