DEVELOPED economies have largely tackled poverty, disease, ignorance, hygiene and idleness. It's time for a new approach.
There is a burgeoning sense among OECD policymakers that the 20th century policy paradigm — which emphasises material prosperity as an overarching goal — is played out.
A democratic revival and a new social contract are needed, perhaps to a wellbeing state; an upgrade from the welfare state. The times suit such a revival, with nations struggling with populist backlashes against technocratic rule by elites.
Unfortunately, the last forty years of (broadly desirable and effective) technocratic governance across the OECD, which have seen experts crafting large-scale policy reforms largely removed from the democratic oversight of those reforms, has left politicians ill equipped to prosecute this democratic revival.
Current policies are played out because, simply put, countries in the Global North are rich. Beveridge's welfare state sought to tackle the 'five great evils' of poverty, disease, ignorance, hygiene and idleness.
Developed economies today are wealthy, healthy, educated, clean, and employed. Many people have it tough, but this is largely a matter of redistribution, not further growth.
Awareness of this material abundance is mixed with an awareness of the unsustainable nature of our lifestyles and the need for a more environmentally-friendly political economy.
To work out how to best integrate wellbeing initiatives into public policy, the question of what is wellbeing first needs to be settled.
Scientists offer various answers depending on their discipline. Psychologists emphasise mental states like happiness and purpose in life, or the nourishment of basic psychological needs for autonomy, competence and relatedness.
Development practitioners and forward-thinking economists focus on 'capabilities' — wellbeing means having a wider set of options from which to choose the life that is best suited to you.
And philosophers emphasise a range of primary goods including pleasure, knowledge, virtue, enfranchisement and self-actualisation.
At a high level, wellbeing is what makes a life go well. Defining wellbeing thus requires making a value judgement and this is the domain of democracy, not science.
The transition to a wellbeing state is an opportunity to establish new values around which to organise society and policy. This must begin with politics, not science.
But other than in the high-profile cases of Bhutan and New Zealand, most wellbeing public policy is presented by politicians as a dull change in public administration: tweaking outcome measures to be more cognisant of sustainability and mental health and putting a bit less emphasis on cost savings.
This technocratic focus on high-level metrics and evaluation frameworks has merit. Twentieth-century statistics cannot capture 21st-century progress. But it can also be counterproductive.
Public policy already serves a variety of goals beyond income and growth. Its ability to do so is often handicapped by the desire of central agencies, notably treasuries and finance ministries, to control policy according to a narrow set of metrics.
Broadening these from income is welcome, but not if it just means bringing in more equally narrow indicators like life expectancy, years of schooling and household energy efficiency.
Most public policy is highly contextual, especially service delivery. For example, health in a neighbourhood may be a concern of air pollution along a major road, access to evening exercise in an unsafe park and the personality of the local doctor. Life expectancy doesn't inform you about any of these things.
Context-sensitive policy reforms and bespoke measures and evaluation frameworks are needed.
Citizens affected by policy can deliberate with practitioners who implement policy and technical experts who analyse it. This results in policy that is legitimate, implementable and rigorous.
Designing metrics for policy rather than contorting policy to fit metrics is better suited to the complexity of policymaking. Most public policy is delivered by systems — for example health, defence and social security.
These systems involve dozens of simultaneous, interlocking interventions that promote a wide variety of goals.
Systems are different from how most academics conceptualise policy and its evaluation. Academics think in terms of discrete interventions like subsidising marriage counselling.
The causal effect of these interventions can be identified experimentally using randomised-control trials (RCTs). And their effectiveness can be assessed using cost-benefit analysis (CBA).
Some policies can be implemented this way but many of them are actively harmed by insisting on RCTs and CBA as analytic frameworks.
For example, owing to a focus on employment as an outcome metric, social policies to address complex disadvantage in the UK have struggled to coordinate the range of services required to deal simultaneously with poverty, mental health, homelessness and substance use.
Hence a narrow conceptualisation of 'evidence-based policy' using RCTs and CBA and of wellbeing public policy aiming for 'life expectancy' or whatever other high-level goal can be actively counterproductive to wellbeing.
Public policy researchers have long noted that this sort of naivety about the reality of policymaking among academics impedes the translation of good science into good policy.
The wellbeing state requires democracy and political leadership first and foremost. The role of the scientist in wellbeing public policy is to enhance the quality of deliberation over policy in this political project.
* Mark Fabian is assistant professor of public policy at the University of Warwick, affiliate fellow at Cambridge University’s Bennett Institute for Public Policy and adjunct fellow at the Institute for Social Change at the University of Tasmania. He declares no conflict of interest.
360info
Sun Jun 11 2023
For nations that are already wealthy, healthy, educated, clean and employed what comes next? - FREEPIK
Pelajar tahfiz perlu teroka bidang teknologi
Kira-kira 200,000 pelajar tahfiz di negara ini, perlu dipastikan untuk mempunyai kemampuan dan peluang menjadi tenaga penggerak kepada umat Islam Malaysia dalam meneroka bidang yang dahulu dilihat sebagai asing., tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Perpaduan rakyat prasyarat ekonomi mampan
Tidak semua negara Islam mempunyai ruang dan kesempatan untuk terus aman dan damai, dan mempunyai peluang untuk menikmati ekonomi yang kukuh dan berkembang seperti Malaysia, tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Tidak perlu tergesa-gesa tukar ke lesen B - JPJ
Pemegang Lesen Memandu Malaysia (LMM) Kelas B2 dan B1 tidak perlu tergesa-gesa mendaftar Program Khas Peralihan LLM Kelas B2/B1 Kepada LMM Kelas B kerana tiada had masa ditetapkan untuk permohonan.
KPWKM teruskan lapan inisiatif bantu warga emas
Kementerian Pembangunan Wanita, Keluarga dan Masyarakat (KPWKM) akan terus menggerakkan lapan inisiatif utama dalam memenuhi keperluan jagaan dan sistem sokongan terhadap warga emas.
Warga emas maut ditikam anak kandung yang berhalusinasi
Seorang pesara guru maut ditikam anak kandungnya sendiri di sebuah rumah dekat Kampung Senaling, di sini, petang Sabtu.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Sabtu, 5 Oktober 2024.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Hezbollah lancar serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kompleks industri ketenteraan di utara Israel
Pergerakan Hezbollah di Lubnan berkata mereka telah melancarkan serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kemudahan ATA Defence Industries.
Tiada kaitan dengan pelantikan CEO MDEC, Anuar Fariz bukan adik saya - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil menyangkal dakwaan Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif (CEO) baharu Perbadanan Ekonomi Digital Malaysia (MDEC) Anuar Fariz Fadzil merupakan adiknya.
Israel lakukan persiapan untuk serang Iran - Laporan
Tentera Israel sedang bersiap untuk "tindakan balas besar-besaran dan ekstrem" terhadap Iran.
Kajian Ekonomi OECD: Malaysia di landasan tepat, mampu capai ekonomi berpendapatan tinggi menjelang 2028
Negara berada di landasan yang betul untuk mencapai status ekonomi berpendapatan tinggi, dengan jangkaan melepasi nilai ambang Bank Dunia pada 2028.
Malaysia pertimbang sertai OECD, pelihara hubungan baik dengan rakan dagang - Tengku Zafrul
Malaysia sedang mempertimbang untuk menyertai beberapa organisasi antarabangsa lain termasuk Pertubuhan Kerjasama Ekonomi dan Pembangunan (OECD) sejajar usaha memelihara hubungan baik dengan semua rak
Peraturan EU yang lebih ketat mengenai eksport sisa kepada bukan negara EU berkuat kuasa Isnin
Peraturan yang lebih ketat mengenai eksport sisa dari Kesatuan Eropah (EU) ke negara bukan EU akan berkuat kuasa pada Isnin, lapor Agensi Berita Jerman (dpa).
Peserta industri Labuan IBFC rayu MOF benarkan aktiviti perdagangan
Peserta industri IBFC Labuan mengemukakan rayuan kepada Kementerian Kewangan bagi pertimbangan supaya membenarkan kegiatan perdagangan dalam lingkungan pusat itu.
Kerajaan Itali, ahli perniagaan bergabung tangani inflasi
Inflasi di Itali mula meningkat 18 bulan lalu dan ia mencapai paras tertinggi pada 11.8 peratus pada Oktober dan November 2022.
OECD, Bank Dunia naikkan unjuran pertumbuhan ekonomi China
Pertubuhan Kerjasama dan Pembangunan Ekonomi (OECD) yang beribu pejabat di Paris telah menaikkan unjuran pertumbuhan ekonomi China bagi tahun 2023 kepada 5.4 peratus.
Lelaki Switzerland punyai jangka hayat paling tinggi di dunia
Menurut Stephane Cullati dari Universiti Fribourg, terdapat hubung kait antara tahap pendidikan dan purata jangka hayat.
WEF2023: ASEAN pamer keyakinan, tekad tinggi di Davos
ASEAN berada di landasan yang baik untuk menjadi ekonomi keempat terbesar menjelang 2030.
OECD beri amaran kemelesetan di Eropah
OECD menurunkan unjuran pertumbuhan ekonomi globalnya bagi 2023, serta memberi amaran bahawa banyak negara di Eropah berkemungkinan akan menghadapi kemelesetan pada tahun depan.
Malaysia setuju laksana cukai minimum global untuk syarikat multinasional
Malaysia adalah antara 136 negara yang sudah bersedia melakukan reformasi sistem percukaian antarabangsa itu.