PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal here today ordered independent speaker Wan Ji Wan Hussin to begin serving his nine-month prison sentence for publishing offensive words and insulting the Sultan of Selangor via Facebook 11 years ago.
This followed a unanimous decision by a panel of three judges led by Datuk Hadhariah Syed Ismail to reinstate the Shah Alam Sessions Court's decision, made on April 9, 2018, in sentencing Wan Ji to nine months in prison for the offence, and dismissed his appeal against the conviction and sentence.
In reinstating the Shah Alam Sessions Court's decision, Judge Hadhariah also set aside the decision of the Shah Alam High Court in July 2019 which sentenced Wan Ji, 41, to one year in prison.
She said Wan Ji's appeal had no merit because there was a lot of evidence showing that the appellant (Wan Ji) was the owner of the Facebook page.
"Regarding the issue of punishment, the High Court Judge has no reason to increase the punishment. The sentence (of nine months' imprisonment) should have been upheld.
"Therefore, the court sets aside the one-year prison sentence handed down by the Shah Alam High Court against Wan Ji and reinstates the decision of the Shah Alam Sessions Court," said Judge Hadhariah, who sat with Judge Datuk Azman Abdullah and Judge Datuk Azmi Ariffin.
On the claim of no offence in the Sedition Act 1948 by Wan Ji in his appeal, she reaffirmed that the appellant had used inappropriate language on Facebook.
"If you (want to) give religious advice, say it using good words. Don't use inappropriate words, especially against the Sultan of Selangor, because now there are the 3R's (religion, royalty, race). Be careful with these sensitive words," she added.
Judge Hadhariah said freedom of speech does not give an absolute right for someone to speak at will as there are still limits that need to be maintained.
At today's proceedings, the prosecution was conducted by deputy public prosecutor How May Ling, while lawyer Muhammad Faiz Fadzil represented Wan Ji.
Wan Ji had appealed against the one-year prison sentence imposed by the Shah Alam High Court in July 2019 after allowing the prosecution's cross-appeal to increase the nine-month prison sentence handed down by the Shah Alam Sessions Court on April 9, 2018.
On April 9, 2018, Sessions Court judge Mohd Sabri Ismail sentenced Wan Ji to nine months in jail after finding him guilty of publishing words that insulted the Sultan of Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah on his Facebook under the name wanji.attaaduddi.
He was charged under Section 4(1)(c) of the Sedition Act 1948 which provides for a maximum fine of RM5,000 or imprisonment of not more than three years or both for the first offence, and to a maximum of five years imprisonment for the second and subsequent offences.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Sep 25 2023
The order follows a unanimous decision by a panel of three judges to reinstate the Shah Alam Sessions Court's decision on April 9, 2018, in sentencing Wan Ji to nine months in prison for the offence. File pic by BERNAMA
Teka-teki terjawab, Nabila Razali hamil anak sulung
Penyanyi dan pelakon Nabila Razali umum sedang hamil anak sulung dan dijangka bersalin pada Januari tahun depan.
Atlet menembak sensasi Korea Selatan ditawar jadi 'pembunuh upahan'
Atlet menembak Korea Selatan Kim Ye-ji ditawar menjadi 'pembunuh upahan' selepas penampilan uniknya mendapat perhatian seluruh dunia.
MQSS medan lahirkan generasi celik al-Quran - KPM
Kemahiran yang ditonjolkan dalam MQSS bukan bersifat pertandingan atau persaingan mencari seorang juara.
Bursa Malaysia dibuka rendah
Bursa Malaysia dibuka rendah hari ini susut daripada kenaikan semalam berikutan aktiviti pengambilan untung dalam saham wajaran tinggi.
Liga Europa: Tottenham kekal rentak kemenangan
Tiga mata skuad bimbingan Ange Postecoglou dijana Pape Sarr dan Brennan Johnson pada setiap babak menundukkan anak buah Pascal Jansen.
Mangsa banjir di PPS Perak bertambah, beberapa tempat di Selangor, Kedah dinaiki air
Di Selangor, 1,968 individu daripada 480 keluarga terjejas akibat banjir dipindahkan ke enam PPS yang dibuka pagi ini.
AS sahkan kes baharu selesema burung H5 melibatkan manusia di California
Tiada kaitan ditemukan antara kedua-dua kes setakat ini, menandakan ia kejadian berasingan penularan virus dari haiwan kepada manusia.
Pegawai bank mengaku tidak bersalah dua tuduhan gangguan seksual
Rosman Jamaluddin, 52 tahun, mengaku tidak bersalah selepas pertuduhan terhadapnya dibacakan di hadapan Majistret S Punitha.
[LAPOR LANGSUNG] Pengganti Hassan Nasrallah, Hashem Safieddine sasaran terbaharu Israel
Angkatan Pertahanan Israel (IDF) menjadikan Hashem Safieddine iaitu pengganti pemimpin Hezbollah, Hassan Nasrallah sebagai sasaran baharu.
Penjaga rumah amal GISB mengaku tidak bersalah rotan kanak kanak
Mohd Syahid Hanapiah mengaku tidak bersalah di hadapan hakim Lailatul Zuraida Harron @ Harun di Mahkamah Sesyen Selayang pagi ini.
Wan Ji gagal rujuk isu perlembagaan berhubung tuduhan hasutan ke Mahkamah Persekutuan
Mahkamah Rayuan menolak permohonan penceramah bebas Wan Ji Wan Hussin untuk merujuk isu perlembagaan membabitkan pertuduhan di bawah Akta Hasutan 1948 yang dihadapinya ke Mahkamah Persekutuan.
Wan Ji disyaki sebar fitnah dakwa dipukul dalam penjara
Pendakwah kontroversi, Wan Ji Wan Hussin kini berhadapan siasatan polis kerana disyaki menyebarkan fitnah dengan mendakwa dirinya dipukul semasa berada dalam penjara.
Mohon tangguh bagi kes hukuman penjara setahun amalan biasa - Syahredzan
Tempoh rayuan akan didengar mungkin memakan masa beberapa bulan atau lebih setahunselepas hukuman dijatuhkan.
Kes Wan Ji: Kaji semula kes hasutan jika ada representasi - Peguam Negara
Jabatan hanya boleh bertindak berdasarkan representasi bertulis yang diterima daripada tertuduh atau peguam belanya.
PH tidak komited mansuh akta drakonian - Bersih 2.0
Pakatan Harapan dilihat tidak bersungguh-sungguh untuk menghapuskan Akta Hasutan ini dan menegakkan kebebasan bersuara sebagaimana termaktub dalam Perkara 10 Perlembagaan Persekutuan.
Rayuan ditolak, hukuman penjara 9 bulan Wan Ji dipinda kepada setahun
Hakim, Datuk Abdul Halim Aman turut meminda hukuman kepada setahun setelah memberi pertimbangan terhadap rayuan silang pihak pendakwaan.
Wan Ji dipenjara sembilan bulan kerana menghasut
Seorang penceramah bebas dijatuhi hukuman penjara sembilan bulan oleh Mahkamah Sesyen di sini, hari ini kerana menerbitkan penerbitan menghasut bagi menghina Sultan Selangor.
'Ada guru madrasah tempatan tiru budaya pembelajaran Pakistan' - Penceramah bebas
Seorang pendakwah Islam, Wan Ji Wan Hussin berkata, kaedah agak keras seperti merotan dan memukul semenangnya diamalkan di sesetengah madrasah luar negara.
Penceramah bebas Wan Ji ditahan Jais kerana didakwa beri ceramah tanpa tauliah
Penceramah bebas Wan Ji Wan Hussin, 33 ditahan Jabatan Agama Islam Selangor (Selangor) kira-kira jam 9.45 malam tadi atas kesalahan memberi ceramah tanpa tauliah.
Pendakwah Wan Ji Wan Hussin ditahan di bawah Akta Hasutan
Seorang pendakwah Islam, Wan Ji Wan Hussin dilaporkan ditahan awal pagi tadi di bawah Akta Hasutan.