PUTRAJAYA: An accused person ought to be given the opportunity to review the Attorney-General's prosecutorial discretion if the law had been misunderstood or misapplied as the decision to prosecute can have enormous consequences on the person.
Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, in her 55-page judgment said the consequences of being charged include the irretrievable loss of reputation, distress and disruption of work and family relations.
"The Attorney-General's decision to prosecute could have enormous consequences on the accused persons, the injured party and society at large," she said.
She said in an appropriate, rare and exceptional case, the Attorney-General's prosecutorial discretion is amenable to judicial review.
She said an accused person ought to be given the opportunity to have the Attorney-General's prosecutorial discretion reviewed by way of judicial review if the law has been misunderstood or misapplied by the Attorney-General, who is also a public prosecutor.
Justice Tengku Maimun said this in the court's judgment which ruled that the former director of the Asian International Arbitration Centre (AIAC) Datuk Prof Dr N. Sundra Rajoo, was entitled to immunity from prosecution for acts committed while in office.
In the court's judgment, Justice Tengku Maimun said the court has the responsibility to prevent the criminal justice system from being arbitrarily used against an individual and to prevent an innocent person from going through criminal proceedings if the Attorney-General had failed to exercise his discretion in accordance with the law to prosecute.
"To allow a matter without merit to be pursued through criminal court would have huge impact on the accused's life and career and would cause unnecessary expenditure of time and effort and would place extra costs on the public purse," she said.
She said in appropriate and exceptional cases, it would be better to quash the decision to prosecute before the criminal proceedings commence so that unnecessary suffering of the accused caused by improper prosecution can be minimised.
On April 30, this year, the seven-member Federal Court bench led by Justice Tengku Maimun had allowed Sundra Rajoo's appeal and granted him a declaration that he was immune from prosecution for acts done within his official capacity.
Sundra Rajoo, 65, who was the head of AIAC from 2010 until late 2018, won his case in the High Court but the Court of Appeal overturned the decision after allowing the appeal by the Foreign Ministry, the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC), the government and the Attorney General.
He subsequently obtained leave to appeal to the Federal Court.
On Jan 22, last year, Sessions Court judge Azura Alwi struck out the three criminal breach of trust charges involving AIAC funds amounting to more than RM1 million against Sundra Rajoo after ruling that she was bound by the High Court decision that he (Sundra Rajoo) was entitled to immunity from prosecution for acts done in his official capacity.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Thu Jun 10 2021
Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, in her 55-page judgment said the consequences of being charged include the irretrievable loss of reputation, distress and disruption of work and family relations. - BERNAMA filepic
Lelaki maut kereta terbabas langgar pokok di Manjung
Mangsa disahkan maut di lokasi oleh pihak Kementerian Kesihatan Malaysia.
Durian segar Malaysia di China habis dijual tidak sampai 24 jam
Tidak sampai 24 jam, hampir 40 tan durian segar pertama Malaysia ke China yang dipasarkan pada 26 Ogos lepas di outlet peruncitan terpilih di enam wilayah negara Tembok Besar itu habis terjual.
Keldai akaun ditahan sebabkan kerugian hampir RM60,000
Polis menahan lelaki berumur 58 tahun dipercayai keldai akaun kepada sindiket penipuan yang menawarkan kerja sambilan tidak wujud secara dalam talian sehingga menyebabkan mangsa kerugian RM59,569 baru-baru ini.
Lebih 200 maut akibat taufan Helene di AS
Seramai 200 orang disahkan maut sehingga Jumaat selepas Taufan Helene melanda beberapa negeri di tenggara Amerika Syarikat (AS), menjadikannya ribut paling membahayakan kedua yang melanda AS dalam lebih setengah abad.
Taiwan laksana operasi pembersihan selepas taufan Krathon
Taiwan sedang giat membersihkan kerosakan akibat banjir dan angin kencang selepas Taufan Krathon melanda bandar pelabuhan utama, sementara penduduk di sebahagian besar kawasan lain di pulau itu kembali bekerja dan pasaran kewangan dibuka semula.
AS dakwa Rusia, Iran dan China guna AI sabotaj pilihan raya
Amerika Syarikat (AS) berdepan ancaman dari Rusia, Iran dan China, yang didakwa cuba mempengaruhi Pilihan Raya Presiden 2024 dengan menggunakan kecerdasan buatan (AI) untuk menyebarkan maklumat palsu serta mencetuskan perpecahan.
Taiwan laksana operasi pembersihan selepas taufan Krathon
Taiwan sedang giat membersihkan kerosakan akibat banjir dan angin kencang selepas Taufan Krathon melanda bandar pelabuhan utama.
Malaysia sokong Pakistan jadi rakan dialog penuh dengan ASEAN
Menurut Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysia berada dalam kedudukan untuk membuka peluang kepada hasrat Pakistan dalam menjadi rakan dialog.
Deklarasai Doha seru gencatan senjata di Gaza
Deklarasi Doha, yang dikeluarkan pada Sidang Kemuncak Dialog Kerjasama Asia Ketiga dengan tumpuan pada 'Diplomasi Sukan', menekankan keperluan mendesak untuk gencatan senjata segera dan menyeluruh di Gaza.
3 hospital di Lubnan henti operasi, rosak akibat serangan Israel
Tiga hospital di Lubnan, termasuk satu di pinggir kawasan selatan Beirut mengumumkan pemberhentian operasi pada Jumaat susulan pengeboman berterusan oleh Israel.
Ceroboh Lahad Datu: Hukuman mati terhadap tujuh warga Filipina kekal
Mahkamah Persekutuan mengekalkan hukuman mati terhadap tujuh lelaki warga Filipina, termasuk anak saudara Jamalul Kiram.
Bantuan guaman rapatkan jurang dalam keadilan - Tengku Maimun
Keadilan yang menjadi sebagai asas penting masyarakat perlu boleh diakses secara universal dan bukan keistimewaan yang dikhaskan.
Tembak mati pengawal keselamatan, dua terlepas hukuman gantung
Dua lelaki terlepas tali gantung apabila Mahkamah Persekutuan menggantikan hukuman mati yang dijatuhkan terhadap mereka dengan penjara.
Peniaga besi buruk terlepas hukuman mati, digantikan penjara 35 tahun
Panel tiga hakim diketuai Ketua Hakim Negara Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat membenarkan permohonan semakan V Raja.
Litigasi ESG dijangka terus meningkat - Tun Maimun
Litigasi berkaitan prinsip alam sekitar, sosial dan tadbir urus (ESG) dijangka akan terus meningkat pada tahun mendatang.
Muhyiddin perlu tunjuk tauladan yang baik - MUDA Kelantan
MUDA Kelantan menggesa bekas Perdana Menteri, Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin menunjukkan tauladan dengan tidak menimbulkan sangkaan tidak baik susulan pembatalan 16 Enakmen Syariah Kelantan pada Jumaat lalu
Nik Elin terima banyak ugutan bunuh
Nik Elin Zurina Nik Abdul Rashid membuat tiga laporan polis berhubung ugutan bunuh yang diterimanya baru-baru ini.
Muhyiddin sebar berita palsu - Fahmi
Fahmi berkata kenyataan Muhyiddin berhubung keputusan Mahkamah Persekutuan yang membatalkan 16 peruntukan kesalahan di bawah Enakmen Kanun Jenayah Syariah (1) Kelantan 2019 adalah tidak benar.
Mahkamah Syariah, undang-undang Islam tidak akan terkubur - Ketua Hakim Negara
Beliau berkata isu yang perlu diputuskan ialah sama ada Badan Perundangan Negeri Kelantan membuat peruntukan terbabit mengikut batasan ditentukan oleh Perlembagaan Persekutuan atau sebaliknya.
Hakim bebas buat keputusan berdasarkan fakta, undang-undang - Ketua Hakim Negara
Beliau berkata berbeza dengan ahli politik, hakim tidak perlu menjawab kepada sesiapa, atau diperintah oleh desakan politik atau populariti.