INTRODUCTION
There are approximately 9 institutions of higher learning that offer Bachelor of Laws program in Malaysia as of 2022. The law school of Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia (USIM) was the latest to receive full recognition from the Legal Profession Qualifying Board (LPQB) in 2021.
It took USIM more than 10 years to get its law program fully recognised, indicating the high level of standards imposed by the LPQB in evaluating the quality of law schools. Taylor’s University is the only remaining institution that have yet to obtain full accreditation by the LPQB. Unlike other universities, law graduates from Taylor’s are required to seat for Certificate of Legal Practice (CLP) prior to becoming ‘qualified persons’ under the Legal Profession Act 1976.
Despite these stringent requirements, there have been a number of legal practitioners who were complaining that law graduates in Malaysia are not prepared for pupillage. Among the complaints include that law graduates are not knowledgeable in law and lack legal skills.
In order to improve the situation, a moratorium on the introduction of new law schools was imposed by the Ministry of Higher Education to ensure that Malaysia does not face excessive production of law graduates. The MinistER of Higher Education Malaysia, Datuk Seri Dr. Noraini Ahmad contended that the ratio of lawyers to the population is ideal in Malaysia as of 2021.
Should the 15-year-old moratorium remain or be removed?
FUTURE OF LEGAL EDUCATION IN MALAYSIA
A senior lawyer in Malaysia in his article entitled ‘On the Bench and the Bar’ published in the Star back in 2020 reiterated the incompetence of local graduates, in exception of those from three universities namely University of Malaya, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia and Multimedia University. These findings were made according to his own observation, unsupported by any data or credible facts. He may have arrived into this conclusion as he could have only dealt with graduates from these universities, and not with graduates from six other institutions in Malaysia.
The writer, who is also a senior lawyer, glorified Singapore and the United Kingdom as role model for legal education, as if legal education in Malaysia is of substandard quality. He repeatedly contended that local graduates have poor command of the English language, but then again, this claim was uncorroborated by any credible sources.
Local law graduates are also said not having ‘practice-ready’ qualities. Nevertheless, the term ‘practice-ready’ itself has not been defined in any circulars issued by the BAR. If one approaches practitioners to unearth the mystery behind the definition of ‘practice-ready’, this effort would be in vain as different practitioners define the term differently.
THE MYTH OF UNEMPLOYED LAW GRADUATES
According to the website of the Malaysian BAR, there are about 20,000 practicing lawyers in Malaysia, roughly 0.06 % of the entire population. On the other hand, according to the Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysian law schools produce about 1, 700 graduates each year. This means only a small percentage of these graduates chose to become practitioners while most of them opted not to practice law.
As such, legal practitioners who made unwarranted remarks against law schools must stop living in small little world of theirs and must realise that law schools do not only produce future practicing lawyers, but provide workforce for other job markets as well. In fact, tracer studies conducted by the Ministry of Higher Education on local law graduates indicated that just a small percentage of them are unemployed subsequent to graduation. Therefore, why is there a need for a moratorium?
Should these graduates choose to practice law, only then they should undergo pupillage. If law graduates are expected to know everything and to be practice-ready from day one, what is then the purpose of the 9-months pupillage?
This applies mutatis mutandis to other professions as well. Budding medical doctors are required to go for 2 years housemanship and even academics are obliged to undergo 3 years (or even longer) period of PhD studies before they are certified as competent researchers.
SCRUTINISE CHAMBERING
Pupils are placed under a master when they undergo chambering for nine-months. According to the website of the Malaysian BAR, the primary duty of a pupil master is to help, guide and advise his pupil in the traditions of the legal profession and to supervise the training of the pupil in the practice of an advocate and solicitor so that the pupil may obtain the maximum benefit from his period of pupillage.
While there are masters who take good care of their pupils, there are cases where the master totally neglected his or her pupils during the nine-month of chambering and learnt almost nothing.
Has the LPQB or even the BAR Council establish a committee to supervise and overseer how law firms conduct pupillage? It is not wise to blame universities as courses in universities are audited and accredited not just by the Malaysian Qualification Agency (MQA), but the LPQB itself. The accreditation process in itself is lengthy (could take up to a decade) and arduous.
It is to be reminded that universities provide legal education in 4 (or 5) years of the LLB program, both in substantive and procedural laws. Within this period of time, law students are required to study various subjects as law schools do not only produce lawyers or legal practitioners, but provide human resources for other professions as well.
CONCLUSION
Legal practitioners have to stop blaming law schools as law academics in universities in Malaysia are qualified educators, as majority of them hold PhD degrees in various fields of law from universities all around the world. In addition, some of them are ex-practitioners too.
It is a fact that these practitioners were educated in law schools prior to recognition as qualified persons and later admitted as members of the BAR. Malaysian universities have also produced not just successful lawyers, but successful individuals possessing law degree engaging in employment opportunities outside the scope of legal practice.
Maybe the time has come for legal practitioners who are expecting too much from law graduates to reflect on themselves – were they ‘practice-ready’ when they first began their pupillage ten, twenty, thirty or forty years ago? In addition, not all legally related professions require candidates to entirely be ‘practice-ready’.
It is not the sole duty of law schools to achieve this end. Both law schools and the legal fraternity must work hand in hand to build a better legal profession in Malaysia.
Its time for the LPQB or any related bodies to begin scrutinising and conducting regular audits on how legal firms conduct pupillage, the same way universities are being audited yearly.
As law degree in Malaysia provides human resource for various job markets, it would be a viable move should the Ministry lifts the moratorium imposed on law schools.
Dr Mohd Hazmi Mohd Rusli, Dr Syahirah Syukor and Dr Amalina Binti Ahmad Tajudin are lecturers at the Faculty of Syariah and Law, Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
AWANI Columnist
Sun Feb 06 2022
![To moratorium or not: The future of legal education in Malaysia To moratorium or not: The future of legal education in Malaysia](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2022-02/71644110017_peraturan.jpg)
As law degree in Malaysia provides human resource for various job markets, it would be a viable move should the Ministry lifts the moratorium imposed on law schools. - geotimes
![Istiadat Pertabalan Agong: Orang ramai dinasihat tidak cemas dengar tembakan meriam Istiadat Pertabalan Agong: Orang ramai dinasihat tidak cemas dengar tembakan meriam](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/51721193528_tbIstiadatPertabala.jpg)
Istiadat Pertabalan Agong: Orang ramai dinasihat tidak cemas dengar tembakan meriam
Orang ramai dinasihat tidak cemas jika terdengar bunyi tembakan meriam semasa memandu di Jalan Sultan Abdul Halim pada Jumaat dan Sabtu ini.
![Buang tulis 'PN' kepada bekas MP, Speaker minta hantar surat Buang tulis 'PN' kepada bekas MP, Speaker minta hantar surat](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/51721192211_SyedHussinDewanR.jpg)
Buang tulis 'PN' kepada bekas MP, Speaker minta hantar surat
Jelas Johari, sehingga kini, PN belum menghantar sebarang notis kepadanya bagi menarik paparan di skrin Dewan Rakyat mengenai status Syed Abu Hussin.
Istiadat Pertabalan Agong: Orang ramai dinasihat tidak cemas dengar tembakan meriam
Orang ramai khususnya warga kota dinasihatkan agar tidak cemas jika terdengar bunyi tembakan meriam semasa memandu di sepanjang Jalan Sultan Abdul Halim pada pagi Jumaat dan Sabtu ini.
Jangan 'shoot down' idea P-turn - Menteri Kerja Raya
Menteri Kerja Raya, Datuk Seri Alexander Nanta Linggi minta YB Stampin, Chong Chieng Jen tidak 'shoot down' idea P-turn di Lebuhraya Pan Borneo yang beri kemudahan kepada pengguna.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
![Tragedi MH17: Sedekad berlalu, keadilan akan terus dituntut Tragedi MH17: Sedekad berlalu, keadilan akan terus dituntut](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/41720776307_UkraineCrisis.jpg)
Tragedi MH17: Sedekad berlalu, keadilan akan terus dituntut
Mahkamah itu dalam penghakiman memutuskan bahawa mahkamah tidak meragui sama sekali bahawa MH17 telah terkena sebutir peluru berpandu BUK yang ditembak dari padang di ladang di timur Ukraine.
Teroka peluang baharu ekonomi, kurangkan kebergantungan hutang
Menurut, Pensyarah Kanan, Fakulti Perniagaan dan Ekonomi, Universiti Malaya, Dr. Safiah Omar hutang boleh menjadi alat untuk memperoleh dana yang diperlukan tetapi pergantungan yang berlebihan boleh membawa kepada masalah kewangan jangka panjang, termasuk beban hutang yang tinggi serta mendorong kepada ketidakstabilan ekonomi
![Maybank perkenal tempoh bertenang 12 jam untuk peningkatan had pemindahan wang Maybank perkenal tempoh bertenang 12 jam untuk peningkatan had pemindahan wang](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-01/51704603925_TBMAYBANK.jpg)
Maybank perkenal tempoh bertenang 12 jam untuk peningkatan had pemindahan wang
Langkah ini dilakukan dalam usaha mengekang penipuan perbankan dalam talian, serta mencegah penipuan yang cuba meningkatkan had pemindahan transaksi.
![Teroka peluang baharu ekonomi, kurangkan kebergantungan hutang - Pakar Teroka peluang baharu ekonomi, kurangkan kebergantungan hutang - Pakar](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/51721188868_HBREAKHUTANG.jpg)
Teroka peluang baharu ekonomi, kurangkan kebergantungan hutang - Pakar
Negara-negara yang mempunyai hutang yang tinggi sering menghadapi kesukaran untuk membayar semula hutang.
Prabayar Siswa: KPT sambut baik pengumuman pakej rahmah
Kementerian Pendidikan Tinggi (KPT) menyambut baik pengumuman Kementerian Komunikasi yang menawarkan Pakej Rahmah Prabayar Siswa pada harga tidak melebihi RM30 dengan permulaan data minimum sebanyak 30GB untuk tempoh sah laku selama 180 hari.
![George Town dikenali semua, tiada keperluan tukar nama - Wong George Town dikenali semua, tiada keperluan tukar nama - Wong](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-04/41712139037_Beca.jpg)
George Town dikenali semua, tiada keperluan tukar nama - Wong
George Town telah dikenali seluruh rakyat Malaysia dan dunia sekian lama, justeru tiada keperluan untuk menukar nama ibu negeri Pulau Pinang itu.
![Kerajaan perlu berhati-hati guna ruang fiskal yang ada - Pakar ekonomi Kerajaan perlu berhati-hati guna ruang fiskal yang ada - Pakar ekonomi](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-07/51626243436_RinggitMalaysia.jpg)
Kerajaan perlu berhati-hati guna ruang fiskal yang ada - Pakar ekonomi
Sehingga akhir Jun tahun ini, paras hutang statutori mencecah 56.8 peratus, namun ia masih di bawah had statutori 60 peratus KDNK yang dibenarkan.
![Permohonan moratorium mulai hari ini! Ini pautan untuk anda memohon Permohonan moratorium mulai hari ini! Ini pautan untuk anda memohon](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2020-10/71603960879_moratorium.jpg)
Permohonan moratorium mulai hari ini! Ini pautan untuk anda memohon
Jurucakap BNM menjelaskan faedah keuntungan hanya akan terakru (diambil kira) ke atas bayaran balik pinjaman yang tertangguh.
![MEF mahu moratorium diperluaskan kepada kumpulan M40, lebih banyak perniagaan MEF mahu moratorium diperluaskan kepada kumpulan M40, lebih banyak perniagaan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-06/71623249938_Pavilion.jpg)
MEF mahu moratorium diperluaskan kepada kumpulan M40, lebih banyak perniagaan
Persekutuan Majikan-Majikan Malaysia (MEF) mencadangkan agar skop moratorium di bawah Pemerkasa PLUS diperluaskan kepada kumpulan M40 dan semua jenis perniagaan.
![Gabungan NGO gesa lanjut moratorium automatik enam bulan lagi Gabungan NGO gesa lanjut moratorium automatik enam bulan lagi](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2020-10/41602918735_moratorium.jpg)
Gabungan NGO gesa lanjut moratorium automatik enam bulan lagi
Dalam perkembangan sama, satu petisyen turut digerakkan di laman www.change.org yang mensasarkan tandangan sebanyak 15,000.
![Total lockdown: Ramai di ambang muflis, pengusaha bas harapkan moratorium, bantuan kewangan Total lockdown: Ramai di ambang muflis, pengusaha bas harapkan moratorium, bantuan kewangan](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-06/81622619486_bas.jpg)
Total lockdown: Ramai di ambang muflis, pengusaha bas harapkan moratorium, bantuan kewangan
Ketika ini ramai yang sedang menanti untuk diisytiharkan muflis disebabkan tidak mampu lagi membayar ansuran bas yang dibeli.
![Moratorium: Kelulusan automatik bagi permohonan peminjam terjejas semua peringkat termasuk B40 Moratorium: Kelulusan automatik bagi permohonan peminjam terjejas semua peringkat termasuk B40](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-06/61622539284_felokorporat.jpg)
Moratorium: Kelulusan automatik bagi permohonan peminjam terjejas semua peringkat termasuk B40
Kelulusan secara automatik bagi permohonan moratorium serta pengurangan pembayaran balik ansuran pinjaman sebanyak 50 peratus akan diberi oleh bank kepada golongan yang terjejas.
![Pemerkasa PLUS: Isi rumah terima tambahan BPR RM500, bujang RM100 Pemerkasa PLUS: Isi rumah terima tambahan BPR RM500, bujang RM100](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-05/41622466950_PerutusanKhasPerda.jpg)
Pemerkasa PLUS: Isi rumah terima tambahan BPR RM500, bujang RM100
Perdana Menteri berkata, bayaran BPR tambahan itu akan mula dimasukkan ke akaun penerima pada hujung bulan Jun nanti.
![Hubungi BNM jika bank enggan memendekkan tempoh pinjaman Hubungi BNM jika bank enggan memendekkan tempoh pinjaman](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-02/41613025376_Gabenor.jpg)
Hubungi BNM jika bank enggan memendekkan tempoh pinjaman
Pengguna berhak meminta pihak bank memendekkan tempoh bayaran balik hutang mereka apabila mereka berkemampuan meningkatkan bayaran.
![Moratorium menyeluruh tidak baik untuk ekonomi, rakyat - Gabenor Moratorium menyeluruh tidak baik untuk ekonomi, rakyat - Gabenor](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2021-02/61613018019_NorShamsiahMohdYu.jpg)
Moratorium menyeluruh tidak baik untuk ekonomi, rakyat - Gabenor
moratorium bersasar adalah lebih baik berbanding moratorium menyeluruh kerana ia memberi pilihan kepada peminjam untuk membuat keputusan kewangan sendiri
![PKP 2.0: Laksana semula moratorium secara menyeluruh - DPDM PKP 2.0: Laksana semula moratorium secara menyeluruh - DPDM](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2020-05/61589348463_ChrisDanielWongP.jpg)
PKP 2.0: Laksana semula moratorium secara menyeluruh - DPDM
Daniel Wong berkata, kerajaan juga tidak perlu memikirkan tentang kemampuan institusi perbankan kerana perkara itu boleh dilaksanakan.