The PAS-led Kelantan government's decision to hold a special state assembly sitting on Dec 29 to table an amendment to the Syariah Criminal Code Enactment II 1993 (Amended 2014), is an extremely irresponsible act of political grandstanding.
Lawyers for Liberty executive director Eric Paulsen opined that the move as a blind faith that failed to take into account the context and best interest of Malaysia and its people as well as the serious repercussion such an act could entail.
"Harsh punishments like stoning to death (with stones of medium size), crucifixion and amputation of limbs are out of place in this day and age, or in any modern and democratic society as they constitute torture, cruel and unusual punishment and would violate the right to life and the prohibition against torture.
"Let us be clear; our Federal Constitution is secular in nature and does not allow for hudud to be implemented. Any attempt to introduce hudud will be unconstitutional as hudud derives its ultimate authority from the Qur'an and therefore only possible under a theocracy.
"The Constitution on the other hand is founded upon parliamentary democracy, fundamental liberties, equality and the rule of law – all concepts antithetic to hudud and its implementation.
"In order for hudud to be implemented, the Constitution and its legislature, executive and judiciary, all other structures and institutions that make up Malaysia would need to be destroyed and reconstituted as being based on Islam and the Qur'an," Paulsen said in a statement today.
However, he said it is not possible unless there is an Islamic revolution like in Iran, Afghanistan or as presently occurring in some parts of Iraq and Syria controlled by ISIL.
"Hudud does not have any divine or magical property to cure all the wrongs in society; see for example the implementation of hudud in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Somalia, Sudan, northern Nigeria and by ISIL that has caused so much injustice, cruelty and suffering.
"Various Islamic scholars have also questioned whether implementing hudud in modern times is not only unrealistic but is most likely to produce the opposite result of Islamic justice and fair play," he said.
As such, Paulsen said PAS needs to reassess its position on hudud as according to various Islamic scholars, there are realities that must be taken into account before hudud can be considered in modern times.
On Sunday, Kelantan Mentri Besar Datuk Ahmad Yakob announced that the amendment would be debated by assemblymen from both sides of the political divide and when passed, introduced in two Private Members' Bills at the next parliament sitting.
He had also said the Private Members’ Bills would be forwarded by a PAS MP in the Dewan Rakyat under Article 76 of the Federal Constitution for PAS' hudud to be implemented and enforced in Kelantan.
T K Letchumy Tamboo
Tue Dec 16 2014
PAULSEN: PAS has failed to take into account the context and best interest of Malaysia and its people, and the serious repercussion if hudud is implemented.
Langkah menoktahkan kemiskinan tegar di Sabah antara tumpuan Dewan Rakyat
Ahli Parlimen Kinabatangan, Datuk Seri Bung Moktar Radin meminta Menteri Ekonomi menyatakan langkah tersebut pada sesi jawab lisan.
Kerajaan cadang perkenal pembiayaan swasta pastikan kemampanan sektor air
Kerajaan menyasarkan untuk memperkenalkan pembiayaan swasta alternatif bagi memastikan kemampanan kewangan program sektor air.
[INFOGRAFIK] Tarikh-tarikh penting Istiadat Pertabalan Yang Di-Pertuan Agong ke-17
Berikut adalah info berkenaan dengan tarikh-tarikh penting Istiadat Pertabalan Yang Di-Pertuan Agong ke-17
Menendez didapati bersalah ke atas 16 pertuduhan rasuah
Juri di Mahkamah Persekutuan Manhattan membacakan keputusannya pada Selasa selepas berbincang selama lebih 12 jam selama tiga hari.
Tindakan keras terhadap penjualan racun makhluk perosak haram - CAP
CAP menggesa Lembaga Racun Makhluk Perosak segera mengambil tindakan keras terhadap penjualan racun makhluk perosak haram di negara ini dan menguatkuasakan dengan tegas Akta Racun Perosak 1974.
SDG: UTP lahir pelajar berkemahiran, tinggi tanggungjawab sosial
UTP berhasrat mendidik pelajar bukan sahaja untuk mahir dalam aspek teknikal tetapi juga untuk menjadi warganegara yang bertanggungjawab dari segi kemahiran dan keupayaan sosial.
RUU 355: Pindaan perlu untuk praktikaliti, keadilan
Apa sahaja pindaan terhadap akta itu perlu berjalan selari dengan persediaan mereka yang bertanggungjawab melaksanakannya, seperti mahkamah syariah, pegawai penguatkuasa agama dan peguam syarie.
Kerajaan teliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap
Kerajaan sedang meneliti kaedah baharu lantikan tetap bagi memastikan pengurusan kewangan negara yang lebih mampan.
Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Wilayah Persekutuan), Dr Zaliha Mustafa berkata hasil kajian tersebut akan dibentangkan kepada Jemaah Menteri untuk pertimbangan dan kelulusan.
Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Wilayah Persekutuan), Dr Zaliha Mustafa berkata hasil kajian tersebut akan dibentangkan kepada Jemaah Menteri untuk pertimbangan dan kelulusan.
PDRM gerak unit skuba forensik, K9 cari bukti hari ini
Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM) akan menggerakkan unit skuba (Unit Forensik) serta Unit Anjing Pengesan (K9) ke lokasi penemuan mayat Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah, 25, di Kampung Sri Kledang, Hulu Selangor, pagi esok.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Timbalan Ketua Polis Daerah Hulu Selangor DSP Mohd Asri Mohd Yunus ketika dihubungi Bernama berkata proses mencari bahan bukti akan dimulakan sekitar jam 9 pagi di kawasan parit berhampiran ladang kelapa sawit berkenaan.
Dewan Rakyat: Langkah meknoktahkan kemisikan tegar di Sabah antara tumpuan hari ini
Langkah-langkah untuk meknoktahkan kemiskinan tegar di Sabah terutamanya di lapan daerah yang dikategorikan termiskin di Malaysia antara tumpuan persidangan Dewan Rakyat hari ini.
Eric Paulsen ditangkap polis kerana tuit hasutan
Peguam Melissa Sasidaran memberitahu, Paulsen ditahan petang tadi sewaktu menghadiri acara Arts For Grab di Dataran Merdeka.
Dua aktivis #KitaLawan dan Ketua Pemuda DAP direman polis
Bagaimanapaun, majistret membuat keputusan untuk hanya mereman Teo Kok Seong selama sehari sementara Adam dan Mandeep selama tiga hari.
Nik Nazmi direman tiga hari
Ketua Pemuda PKR Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad telah ditahan reman selama tiga hari berikutan penglibatannya menganjur himpunan #KitaLawan.
"Jika Eric Paulsen boleh dikenakan Akta Hasutan, kenapa tidak Ibrahim Ali?" - Nur Jazlan
Ahli Parlimen Pulai (Umno-BN) Datuk Nur Jazlan Mohamed hari ini berpendapat bahawa Akta Hasutan harus dikekalkan namun ia perlu dilaksanakan dengan berhati-hati dan adil.
Jakim boleh saman Eric Paulsen kerana menfitnah
JAKIM boleh mempertimbang untuk menfailkan saman fitnah terhadap peguam Eric Paulsen yang mengeluarkan kenyataan menimbulkan kemarahan umat Islam berhubung Islam menerusi catatan Twitter miliknya.