The Federal Court seven-member bench has deferred its decision to Aug 26 to decide appeals in drug trafficking cases involving three Iranians and a construction worker.
Chief Justice Tan Sri Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat who chaired the bench set the decision date after hearing submissions from parties in the appeals.
Presiding with her on the bench were Court of Appeal President Datuk Rohana Yusuf, Chief Judge of Malaya Tan Sri Azahar Mohamed and Federal Court judges Datuk Vernon Ong Lam Kiat, Datuk Abdul Rahman Sebli, Datuk Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Datuk Mary Lim Thiam Suan.
The appeals were brought by Abdullah Atan, and Iranians Mohammad Reza Ghaem Panah Nezamali, Hasan Javadipirouz Avazali against their conviction and death sentence for drug trafficking while the prosecution is appealing against the acquittal of Mahmood Yary Mohammad.
Lawyer Hisyam Teh Poh Teik appearing for Abdullah argued that the conviction of his client must be quashed and he should be acquitted and discharged as the High Court judge did not comply with Section 180 (4) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC).
He said the section stated that a prima facie case is made out against the accused where the prosecution had adduced credible evidence proving each ingredient of the offence which if unrebutted or unexplained would warrant a conviction.
The lawyer said the trial judge found there was prima facie case of trafficking based on the finding of actual possession and invoking the presumption of trafficking under Section 37 (da) of the Dangerous Drug Act 1952 (DDA).
“The judge's reliance on the presumption under section 37 (da) of the Act is in breach of section 180 (4) of the CPC as statutory presumption cannot amount to ‘evidence’,” he said.
Hisyam said a prima facie case can only be found based on credible evidence, and statutory presumptions, in law, cannot be regarded as evidence.
He said the trial judge erred when he relied on the statutory presumption to find that the ingredient of trafficking had been proven at the close of the prosecution's case.
Hisyam said presumption is only a special mode of proving facts which must be proved by evidence.
Section 37 (da) of the DDA states that any person who is found in possession of 200gm of ganja shall be presumed to be trafficking in the drugs.
Deputy public prosecutor Datuk Mohd Dusuki Mokhtar said presumption under Section 37 (da) can be invoked by the prosecution to prove prima facie in drug trafficking cases.
He said the High Court invoked the presumption based on credible evidence by the chemist, adding that the chemist's evidence was credible to support the presumption under section 37 (da) of the DDA.
Mohd Dusuki said section 37 (da) of the DDA is a specific legal provision that the prosecution can invoke while the procedure under section 180 (4) of the CPC concerns with the burden of proof which is used as a general guide to prove a case.
Hasan Javadipirouz's counsel Kitson Foong adopted the submissions made by Hisyam on section 180 (4) CPC. However, he further argued the High Court and Court of Appeal were wrong in finding his client for possession of the drug.
Abdullah was found guilty by the High Court and sentenced to death for trafficking in 4,213gm of ganja on May 15, 2016, in a rented room in Bandar Baru Permas Jaya in Johor and his appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal.
For the Iranians, they were convicted and sentenced to death by the High Court for trafficking 15,821gm of methamphetamine in a house in Jalan Dutamas Melor, Sentul, Kuala Lumpur, on Feb 11, 2012.
Mohammad Reza, Hasan Javadipirouz lost their appeal in the Court of Appeal.
The Court of Appeal had however set aside Mahmood Yary's conviction and acquitted him.
Hisyam also represented Mohammad Reza while Mahmood Yary was represented by lawyer Datuk Kamarul Hisham Kamaruddin.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Jul 15 2020
Chief Justice Tan Sri Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat who chaired the bench set the decision date after hearing submissions from parties in the appeals - file pic
Bekas gabenor New York, anak tiri diserang empat individu
Kedua-dua mangsa mengalami kecederaan di bahagian muka serta badan dan dikejarkan ke hospital untuk menerima rawatan.
Tentera AS lancar serangan di bandar Yaman
AS menyerang 15 sasaran Houthi di kawasan yang dikawal oleh kumpulan yang disokong Iran itu.
Korea Selatan pindahkan 97 rakyatnya dari Lubnan
Kementerian Luar Korea Selatan maklumkan, kesemua mereka tiba di Korea Selatan pada petang Sabtu.
Pelarian tiba di Syria selepas serangan Israel ke atas Lubnan - UNHCR
Lebih 200,000 warga Syria dan Lubnan telah tiba di Syria dari Lubnan sejak serangan Israel bermula 23 September lalu.
[LAPOR LANGSUNG] Lebih 2,000 terkorban di Lubnan akibat serangan Israel
Jumlah mangsa yang maut itu termasuk 261 wanita dan 127 kanak-kanak.
Lebih 2,000 terkorban di Lubnan akibat serangan Israel
Laporan Al Jazeera menyebut, jumlah mangsa yang maut itu termasuk 261 wanita dan 127 kanak-kanak.
AWANI Pagi: Pendayaupayaan Pembangunan Sosio Ekonomi Bagi Memacu Wilayah Persekutuan
Ikuti temu bual bersama Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Wilayah Persekutuan), Dr Zaliha Mustafa di #AWANIPagi jam 7.30 pagi di saluran 501 Astro AWANI.
Pentagon, Jabatan Negara AS beri amaran jenayah perang Israel
Pegawai-pegawai tersebut telah memberi amaran peningkatan jumlah kematian di Gaza mungkin melanggar undang-undang antarabangsa.
200,000 pelarian tiba di Syria selepas serangan Israel ke atas Lubnan - UNHCR
Lebih 200,000 warga Syria dan Lubnan telah tiba di Syria dari Lubnan sejak serangan Israel bermula pada 23 Sept.
Belanjawan 2025: Kesalinghubungan internet di sekolah, kampus jadi keutamaan - Fahmi
Kementerian Komunikasi akan memberikan keutamaan dengan meneruskan usaha untuk meningkatkan dan memantapkan lagi prasarana kesalinghubungan melibatkan isu Internet, dalam Belanjawan 2025 yang akan dibentangkan pada 18 Okt ini.