A provision in the Penal Code that criminalises men for enticing married women is unconstitutional and should be abolished, a lawyer told the Federal Court five-member bench today.
Lawyer Jayarubbiny Jayaraj, whose client is charged with enticing a married woman, argued that Section 498 of the Penal Code violated women's right to equality before the law as the section only accorded husbands the right to initiate criminal proceedings against a person who interfered in their marriage.
She said the provision ought to be declared unconstitutional and repealed.
Jayarubbiny, also submitted that the provision was discriminatory against women in marriages because it treated women as their husband's property and was open to abuse by the husbands.
She said the amendment made to Article 8 (2) of the Federal Constitution by including the word "gender" proved that the Parliament, as the lawmaker in Malaysia, signified that women and men are to be seen as equals and to have equal rights.
Jayarubbiny, together with lawyers Jay Moi Wei Jiun and Puteri Batrisyia Abdul Latif, are representing a businessman who is referring a constitutional question to the Federal Court on whether section 498 of the Penal Code is unconstitutional as it contradicted Article 8(1)(2) of the Federal Constitution relating to equality before the law and gender discrimination.
The matter came up before the Federal Court bench comprising Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, Chief Judge of Malaya Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah and Federal Court judges Datuk Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal, Datuk Abu Bakar Jais and Datuk Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil today.
The 53-year-old businessman man was charged in the Petaling Jaya Magistrate's Court in 2020 for enticing a married woman in an apartment in Selangor in 2018 after a police report was lodged by the woman's husband.
Under Section 498 of the Penal Code, the man can be sentenced to two years in jail or fined or both if convicted.
The Shah Alam High Court in March this year had allowed the man's application to refer to the constitutional question to the Federal Court for the court to determine.
Meanwhile, deputy public prosecutor (DPP) Datuk Yusaini Amer Abdul Karim, assisted by DPP Eyu Ghim Siang, submitted that Section 498 is constitutional and does not violate Article 8(1) (2) of the Federal Constitution.
He said the provision was not a discriminatory law, adding that a woman in a marriage cannot be classified in the same category as a man, particularly from the aspect of protection from violence and crime as it has different criteria.
The objective of Section 498 is to protect the husband's right to maintain a marriage, he added.
After the court completed hearing the submissions, Justice Tengku Maimun told the parties involved that the court reserved its decision.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Jul 18 2023
Lawyer Jayarubbiny Jayaraj, also submitted that the provision was discriminatory against women in marriages because it treated women as their husband's property and was open to abuse by the husbands. - Filepic
Lelaki maut kereta terbabas langgar pokok di Manjung
Mangsa disahkan maut di lokasi oleh pihak Kementerian Kesihatan Malaysia.
Durian segar Malaysia di China habis dijual tidak sampai 24 jam
Tidak sampai 24 jam, hampir 40 tan durian segar pertama Malaysia ke China yang dipasarkan pada 26 Ogos lepas di outlet peruncitan terpilih di enam wilayah negara Tembok Besar itu habis terjual.
Keldai akaun ditahan sebabkan kerugian hampir RM60,000
Polis menahan lelaki berumur 58 tahun dipercayai keldai akaun kepada sindiket penipuan yang menawarkan kerja sambilan tidak wujud secara dalam talian sehingga menyebabkan mangsa kerugian RM59,569 baru-baru ini.
Lebih 200 maut akibat taufan Helene di AS
Seramai 200 orang disahkan maut sehingga Jumaat selepas Taufan Helene melanda beberapa negeri di tenggara Amerika Syarikat (AS), menjadikannya ribut paling membahayakan kedua yang melanda AS dalam lebih setengah abad.
Taiwan laksana operasi pembersihan selepas taufan Krathon
Taiwan sedang giat membersihkan kerosakan akibat banjir dan angin kencang selepas Taufan Krathon melanda bandar pelabuhan utama, sementara penduduk di sebahagian besar kawasan lain di pulau itu kembali bekerja dan pasaran kewangan dibuka semula.
AS dakwa Rusia, Iran dan China guna AI sabotaj pilihan raya
Amerika Syarikat (AS) berdepan ancaman dari Rusia, Iran dan China, yang didakwa cuba mempengaruhi Pilihan Raya Presiden 2024 dengan menggunakan kecerdasan buatan (AI) untuk menyebarkan maklumat palsu serta mencetuskan perpecahan.
Taiwan laksana operasi pembersihan selepas taufan Krathon
Taiwan sedang giat membersihkan kerosakan akibat banjir dan angin kencang selepas Taufan Krathon melanda bandar pelabuhan utama.
Malaysia sokong Pakistan jadi rakan dialog penuh dengan ASEAN
Menurut Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysia berada dalam kedudukan untuk membuka peluang kepada hasrat Pakistan dalam menjadi rakan dialog.
Deklarasai Doha seru gencatan senjata di Gaza
Deklarasi Doha, yang dikeluarkan pada Sidang Kemuncak Dialog Kerjasama Asia Ketiga dengan tumpuan pada 'Diplomasi Sukan', menekankan keperluan mendesak untuk gencatan senjata segera dan menyeluruh di Gaza.
3 hospital di Lubnan henti operasi, rosak akibat serangan Israel
Tiga hospital di Lubnan, termasuk satu di pinggir kawasan selatan Beirut mengumumkan pemberhentian operasi pada Jumaat susulan pengeboman berterusan oleh Israel.