The Court of Appeal has dismissed the government's appeal in a civil suit it filed against Bersih steering committee over damages to public property incurred in the Bersih 3 rally in 2012.
In a unanimous decision, a three-man bench chaired by Justice Datuk Rohana Yusuf upheld the High Court decision which had rejected the government's suit for claim of damages.
She said the court did not find any provision in the Peaceful Assembly Act 2012 that clearly stipulated the government's right to claim.
She said Section 6(2) of that Act did not create a statutory duty, which if violated, would necessary create a right of civil action by the government.
"We also find Section 3 of the Government Proceedings Act, read together with Section 39 of the same Act. does not entitle the government to sue for negligence or for a claim of damages under common law," she said.
Rohana said even if there was a right of claim in common law for negligence in that case, the court did not have reason to intervene in the High Court judge's finding that the government had failed to prove its case of negligence against the respondents based on evidence before him.
"The learned trial judge was in a better advantage than us, having had the benefit of hearing evidence in arriving at his conclusion," she added.
The government sued Bersih 2.0 steering committee, including its former Bersih co-chairman Datuk S. Ambiga and 14 other fellow committee members.
Justices Datuk Varghese George Varughese and Datuk Mary Lim Thiam Suan were the other judges presiding on the panel.
In its civil suit filed on May 15, 2012, the government claimed that the Bersih 3.0 rally on April 28, 2012 had caused damage to public property and sought special compensation of RM110,543.27 as costs to repair damaged police vehicles.
It also sought a declaration that the respondents as organisers of the rally had violated Section 6 (2)(g) of the PAA to ensure the gathering would not cause damage to public property.
The Court of Appeal panel today allowed the government's appeal partly in respect to the counter-claim brought by former steering committee member Wong Ching Huat.
The court (Court of Appeal) reduced the amount of damages from RM21,000 to RM15,000 awarded to Wong by the High Court.
It (the Court of Appeal) allowed damages for pain and suffering and aggravated damages but set aside the High Court decision to award RM6,000 to Wong for unlawful arrest and detention.
Outside the court, Ambiga said the Court of Appeal held that under the PAA, the government could not sue for the damages, adding that the decision was a landmark decision.
Bernama
Tue Aug 23 2016
A police car wrecked during the Bersih 3.0 rally on April 28, 2012. - BERNAMApic
Pelajar tahfiz perlu teroka bidang teknologi
Kira-kira 200,000 pelajar tahfiz di negara ini, perlu dipastikan untuk mempunyai kemampuan dan peluang menjadi tenaga penggerak kepada umat Islam Malaysia dalam meneroka bidang yang dahulu dilihat sebagai asing., tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Perpaduan rakyat prasyarat ekonomi mampan
Tidak semua negara Islam mempunyai ruang dan kesempatan untuk terus aman dan damai, dan mempunyai peluang untuk menikmati ekonomi yang kukuh dan berkembang seperti Malaysia, tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Tidak perlu tergesa-gesa tukar ke lesen B - JPJ
Pemegang Lesen Memandu Malaysia (LMM) Kelas B2 dan B1 tidak perlu tergesa-gesa mendaftar Program Khas Peralihan LLM Kelas B2/B1 Kepada LMM Kelas B kerana tiada had masa ditetapkan untuk permohonan.
KPWKM teruskan lapan inisiatif bantu warga emas
Kementerian Pembangunan Wanita, Keluarga dan Masyarakat (KPWKM) akan terus menggerakkan lapan inisiatif utama dalam memenuhi keperluan jagaan dan sistem sokongan terhadap warga emas.
Warga emas maut ditikam anak kandung yang berhalusinasi
Seorang pesara guru maut ditikam anak kandungnya sendiri di sebuah rumah dekat Kampung Senaling, di sini, petang Sabtu.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Sabtu, 5 Oktober 2024.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Hezbollah lancar serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kompleks industri ketenteraan di utara Israel
Pergerakan Hezbollah di Lubnan berkata mereka telah melancarkan serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kemudahan ATA Defence Industries.
Tiada kaitan dengan pelantikan CEO MDEC, Anuar Fariz bukan adik saya - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil menyangkal dakwaan Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif (CEO) baharu Perbadanan Ekonomi Digital Malaysia (MDEC) Anuar Fariz Fadzil merupakan adiknya.
Israel lakukan persiapan untuk serang Iran - Laporan
Tentera Israel sedang bersiap untuk "tindakan balas besar-besaran dan ekstrem" terhadap Iran.
Bersih 3: Rayuan kerajaan berhubung kerosakan harta benda ditolak
Mahkamah Rayuan menolak rayuan kerajaan dalam saman sivil difailkannya terhadap jawatankuasa pemandu Bersih berhubung kerosakan ke atas harta benda awam dalam perhimpunan Bersih 3 pada 2012.