Media Statement by Centre For A Better Tomorrow Co-President Gan Ping Sieu on The Controversy Surrounding the Malaysian Film Festival
The Malaysian Film Festival's (FFM) decision to deny renowned local film as nominees in its best picture award, for reason of inadequate Bahasa Melayu content, is a typical example of how public administrator's overzealousness can derail well-thought policies and be counterproductive.
The segregation policy runs counter to the two fundamental ideals CENBET promotes ie moderation and good governance. The non-inclusive and dogmatic thinking behind the segregation policy will only add to the fissure already tearing at the ideals of moderation that has been the cornerstone of this country. Further, Finas has abdicated its duties by allowing damaging discriminative practices to take place in a major event. This smacks of poor governance.
This segregation policy only makes us a laughing stock internationally. All over the world, crossborder multi-lingual films are becoming more popular, as cinema-goers become more global in their outlook. These days, many box-office hits have an international cast in productions that benefit from cross-fertlisation of ideas, languages and cultures.
It is time Finas relook at its current practices to keep up with international trends and benchmarks and review processes where it is a major stakeholder, like the FFM.
Restricting top honours in FFM to only producers who make films exclusively in the Malay language is grossly unfair. Winners of the FFM awards should be judged solely by its creative, artistic and technical strength. No productions should be denied of such honours on account of language or dialects they were made in. As the name of the awards suggest, FFM is held as a recognition of Malaysian films, not films of the Malay language.
Rightfully, artistic productions with multicultural themes should come as a natural choice, given Malaysia's social structure and demographics. In fact, it makes commercial sense to produce films for a larger market than a mono-lingual one with single-race appeal.
But beyond business considerations, movies with multi-cultural themes allow viewers to understand each other better and this can help rid prejudice that stems from years of ignorance and distrust. Such films help promote moderation and curb the rise of extremism.
CENBET understands and respect the need to uphold and promote Malay as the national language. Finas may want to consider holding a Malay language-only awards for this purpose, opened to include foreign participation, but the overall premiere award must be opened to all and be inclusive.
The Centre for A Better Tomorrow (CENBET) is part of Malaysia’s flourishing civil society landscape.
Gan Ping Sieu is a former Deputy Minister of Youth and Sports. He is a lawyer by training and holds a Diploma in Syariah from the International Islamic University.
Views expressed here are personally of the author's and do not necessarily reflect Astro AWANI's.
Media Statement
Mon Aug 08 2016
GAN: This segregation policy only makes us a laughing stock internationally.
PM Pakistan gembira atas perbincangan produktif dengan PM Malaysia
Bidang-bidang utama itu termasuk perdagangan, IT, tenaga, pertanian, eksport daging halal, pelancongan, pendidikan dan pertahanan.
Rwanda catat 7 lagi kes virus Marburg dan satu lagi kematian
Rwanda mencatatkan tujuh kes baharu penyakit virus Marburg dan satu lagi kematian.
Menurut angka terkini yang dikeluarkan lewat Rabu Kementerian Kesihatan Rwanda,
jumlah keseluruhan jangkitan virus Marburg sejak wabak bermula kini sebanyak 36 kes, dengan 11 kematian dilaporkan setakat ini.
Menurut angka terkini yang dikeluarkan lewat Rabu Kementerian Kesihatan Rwanda,
jumlah keseluruhan jangkitan virus Marburg sejak wabak bermula kini sebanyak 36 kes, dengan 11 kematian dilaporkan setakat ini.
Lebih 140 sekolah UNRWA diserang sejak 7 Oktober
Lebih 140 sekolah UNRWA diserang sejak 7 Oktober dalam keadaan dimana penduduk Gaza berlindung di bawah naungan PBB.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Pesuruhjaya Agung Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) Philippe Lazzarini dalam satu hantaran di X.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Pesuruhjaya Agung Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) Philippe Lazzarini dalam satu hantaran di X.
28 petugas dilapor maut dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu di Lubnan
28 petugas kesihatan dilaporkan terbunuh dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu di Lubnan.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Ketua Pengarah Pertubuhan Kesihatan Sedunia (WHO) Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus pada Khamis.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Ketua Pengarah Pertubuhan Kesihatan Sedunia (WHO) Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus pada Khamis.
UNIFIL kekal pada posisi walaupun didesak berundur
Pasukan pengaman PBB di selatan Lubnan terus bertahan pada kedudukan mereka, di bawah mandat UNSC, walaupun diarah Israel untuk berundur.
G7 desak pemain serantau di Asia Barat bertindak cermat dalam krisis
Pemimpin Kumpulan Tujuh (G7) mengulangi kebimbangan mereka terhadap krisis di Asia Barat dan menyeru pemain serantau supaya bertindak dengan bertanggungjawab serta berhemah.
Mereka turut menegaskan sokongan penuh terhadap keselamatan Israel.
Mereka turut menegaskan sokongan penuh terhadap keselamatan Israel.
AS sokong operasi Israel di Lubnan meski risiko meluaskan konflik
Pentadbiran Joe Biden menyatakan bahawa adalah wajar untuk Israel meneruskan serangan darat dan udara terhadap Hezbollah buat masa ini, menurut jurucakap Jabatan Negara Amerika Syarikat, Matthew Miller.
Namun, beliau mengakui risiko operasi di Lubnan mungkin melangkaui matlamat semasa Israel.
Namun, beliau mengakui risiko operasi di Lubnan mungkin melangkaui matlamat semasa Israel.
Shamsul Iskandar dakwa kesepakatan parti dalam PN kian longgar
Shamsul Iskandar berkata, perpecahan dalaman PN itu dapat diukur melalui prestasi mereka pada PRK DUN Nenggiri dan DUN Mahkota.
Politik stabil, dasar kerajaan tarik minat syarikat global melabur di Malaysia - Gobind
Menurut Menteri Digital Gobind Singh Deo, pada masa ini terdapat banyak perbincangan, tidak hanya antara syarikat-syarikat di negara serantau malah dunia berhubung perkara itu.
Lawatan negara Anwar ke Pakistan raih potensi perdagangan RM2.65 bilion - Tengku Zafrul
Pakistan turut beri komitmen untuk tingkat import minyak kelapa sawit dari Malaysia dan import produk berasaskan kayu, baja, petrokimia.
CENBET tegur kenyataan Zahid Hamidi berhubung The Edge
CENBET melahirkan rasa kurang senang dengan kenyataan Ahmad Zahid berhubung kemungkinan menarik balik lesen percetakan kepada akhbar The Edge.