A US judge Monday expressed doubt towards the government's e-book antitrust case against Apple, saying the tech giant was challenging "predatory" pricing from rival Amazon.
The comments came as a federal appeals court panel heard arguments in the case, in which Apple was found to have colluded with publishers to raise e-book prices.
Apple argues that its entry into the e-book market fostered competition because it challenged Amazon, which had a dominant share in e-books.
Apple claims its entry spurred additional publishers to produce e-books, and that prices of e-books generally fell even though it concedes that some prices rose in the short-term.
In July 2013, US District Court Judge Denise Cote sided with the government, concluding that Apple was liable for "facilitating and encouraging" a collective effort by the publishers to end price competition for e-books.
Theodore Boutrous, an attorney with Gibson Dunn representing Apple, told the appeals court that Cote's ruling was "a roadblock that chills innovation and competition." The decision discourages new entrants into a market, "which the court has said is the essence of competition," he said.
Apple's arguments resonated with at least one member of the three-judge panel, who appeared openly hostile to the government's case.
Judge Dennis Jacobs questioned a Department of Justice attorney on the agency's hostility to Apple's challenge to Amazon, which had more than estimated 90 percent market share at the time.
"What we're talking about is a new entrant who is breaking the hold of a market by a monopolist who is maintaining its hold by what is arguably predatory pricing," Jacobs said.
Jacobs also took a swipe at the government's characterization of the conspiracy among the publishers, suggesting that prosecutors should have shown more leniency in light of Amazon's dominance, which has pushed conventional booksellers like Barnes & Noble close to bankruptcy.
"All those people who got together, it's like the mice saying they want to put a bell on the cat," the judge said.
Malcolm Stewart, the deputy Solicitor General for the US Justice Department, defended the government's case on the grounds that Apple's entry raised e-book prices for many consumers.
Stewart said the department did not believe Amazon's policies qualified as "predatory pricing," but that its standard $9.99 price on many best-sellers was "good for consumers."
Cote barred Apple and the publishers from signing the types of contracts targeted in the case. She also required Apple to accept a monitor to oversee its antitrust policies.
Finally, Cote on November 21 signed off on Apple's $450 million legal deal to compensate consumers harmed by its e-books policies. However, the settlement is contingent on the appeals court's ruling.
AFP
Mon Dec 15 2014
Apple argues that its entry into the e-book market fostered competition because it challenged Amazon, which had a dominant share in e-books.
IShowSpeed tiba di KL, terima baju batik daripada peminat
Speed menerima hadiah daripada beberapa orang peminat Malaysia ketika kenderaannya berhenti di lampu isyarat di ibu negara pada Selasa,
Penyanyi Sean Diddy ditangakp di New York
Penerbit muzik terkenal, Puff Daddy atau lebih dikenali sebagai Sean Diddy Combs yang berdepan dengan beberapa tuduhan serangan seksual telah diberkas di Manhatann, New York oleh ejen persekutuan pada Isnin waktu tempatan.
10 maut, puluhan cedera bas Iran terbalik
Menurut angka awal, kemalangan itu mengakibatkan 10 maut dan 41 cedera.
Malaysia perlu melabur dalam infrastruktur
Pengarah Eksekutif Ukrainian Prism, Hennadiy Maksak berpandangan, Malaysia juga tidak boleh bergantung kepada satu laluan, selain menjalin hubungan yang baik dengan negara-negara jiran.
Lebih 1,000 rakyat termasuk pejuang Hezbollah cedera parah
Lebih seribu rakyat Lubnan termasuk anggota pejuang Hezbollah dan petugas perubatan cedera parah dalam satu letupan pada Selasa.
Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional memudahkan operasi perdagangan antara Malaysia dan China
Menteri Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI), Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz berpendapat inisiatif Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional (National single window) yang bakal diharmonikan Bersama system kastam China akan memudahkan operasi perniagaan dan perdagangan (ease of doing business) antara Malaysia dan China.
Medan selera perlu ditambah baik, kemudahan asas tidak lengkap
Air bergenang di lantai dan tempias sehingga meja makan mengakibatkan pengunjung basah. Itu situasi apabila keadaan hujan lebat di Medan Selera Taman Makmur di dalam Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Mahkota yang menempatkan deretan 12 kedai makan.
Calon manfaat platform media sosial dekati pengundi luar
Kempen Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Mahkota turut memberi tumpuan kepada penggunaan media sosial bagi menambat hati pengundi luar selain kempen secara bersemuka.
Seorang wanita maut jatuh lubang saluran air
Seorang wanita maut selepas terjatuh ke dalam lubang saluran air sedalam dua meter ketika menyertai aktiviti mendaki di Bukit Cherok Tok Kun pada Selasa.
Kerja pembersihan sisa kimia dijalankan pada Selasa
Kerja-kerja pembersihan sisa bahan kimia yang dibuang secara haram di Kawasan Perindustrian Tiong Nam dan Kawasan Perindustrian Tropika, Johor bermula pada Selasa.
Amazon arahkan pekerja kembali bekerja di pejabat lima hari seminggu
Pekerja Amazon diarah kembali bekerja sepenuh masa di pejabat, dengan menekankan kepentingan bekerja secara bersemuka.
Amazon dilapor akan guna Claude AI untuk kuasakan Alexa generasi baharu
Amazon mungkin bekerjasama dengan Anthropic dan menggunakan Claude AI untuk menguasakan Alexa generasi baharu.
Langganan bulanan Alexa dengan AI akan tiba pertengahan Oktober ini
Alexa serba baharu ini turut akan lebih memahami konteks arahan pengguna secara mendalam termasuk dengan bertanya mengenai perkara yang disukai serta menyampaikan promosi jualan di Amazon.
Pelaburan AWS: Cerminan keyakinan pelabur terhadap Ekonomi Madani - PM
Anwar berkata ia bukan sahaja membawa limpahan besar kepada negara, malah kemakmuran berpanjangan buat rakyat.
AWS Region dilancarkan di Malaysia hari ini
Ia akan membuat pelaburan AS$6.2 bilion di Malaysia menjelang 2038, meningkatkan pertumbuhan ekonomi dan membantu perniagaan tempatan.
Amazon dilapor pertimbang kenakan caj bulanan untuk Alexa
Caj bulanan ini bakal menawarkan sejumlah akses tambahan dan kebolehan yang lebih baik melalui Alexa. Mengikut
NVIDIA pintas Amazon sebagai syarikat kelima paling bernilai di dunia
Nilai pasaran NVIDIA mencecah $1.78 trilion (RM 8.52 trilion) selepas pasaran saham ditutup berbanding Amazon dengan nilai $1.75 trilion (RM 8.37 trilion).
Amazon perkenal chatbot beli-belah AI 'Rufus'
Rufus masih di peringkat ujian beta dalam kelompok pengguna kecil di AS, sebelum dilancarkan lebih meluas pada minggu akan datang.
Amazon lancar cip Trainium2, Graviton4 untuk latihan AI serta pelayar data
Trainium2 direka untuk mempercepatkan proses latihan model sehingga empat kali lebih pantas berbanding cip generasi pertama.
Amazon bakal aktifkan AWS Region di Malaysia pada 2024
AWS Region membolehkan pelbagai data berkaitan disimpan di Malaysia, dan pada masa sama menawarkan kadar pendam rendah (low-latency rate) untuk perkhidmatan yang digunakan dalam negara.