The Court of Appeal erred in law when it ordered the Government and police to pay RM300,000 of exemplary damages to the family of A. Kugan, who died while in police custody in 2009, the Federal Court heard today.
Senior federal counsel Alice Loke submitted that Section 8(2) of the Civil Law Act 1956, bars the awarding of exemplary damages in an estate claim and that the Court of Appeal had created an exception to Section 8(2).
She argued that the words employed in Section 8 (2) were plain and admit of only one meaning that exemplary damages were not recoverable in an estate claim, with no exceptions.
Loke also sought the court to reduce the award for misfeasance (abuse of power by public official) in public office given to Kugan's family from RM100,000 to RM50,000, as the acts occurring post-death.
"Therefore, acts which occurred after the death of the deceased and which constitute misfeasance in public office cannot form the basis of a claim in Section 8. Damages are not recoverable for such acts," she said.
Loke further said that the Court of Appeal was wrong to affirm the High Court's award for exemplary damages and sought the damages to be set aside.
The government and police had appealed against the award of exemplary damages and misfeasance in public office.
Lawyer R.Sivarasa representing Kugan's family, however, countered that the exemplary damages should be awarded to the family because the case involved oppressive and arbitrary.
On Aug 3, 2015, the Federal Court granted the police and government leave to appeal against the award given to Kugan's mother, N. Indra, 49.
On Aug 8, 2014, the Court of Appeal upheld a High Court decision which found the police force, former police constable V. Navindran and the government liable for the death of Kugan, 22, while under police custody in January 2009.
However, in a unanimous decision, a three-member panel headed by Justice Datuk Mohamad Ariff Md Yusof reduced the amount of damages from RM801,700 to RM701,700 after setting aside RM100,000 in damages for false imprisonment awarded by the High Court in 2013.
On Jan 13, 2012, Indra, filed a RM100 million suit seeking damages over alleged negligence, assault, false imprisonment and misfeasance of public office as well as breach of statutory duties.
Navindran will serve three years in prison after his final appeal against conviction for causing hurt to Kugan was dismissed by the Court of Appeals on May 22, 2015.
In today's proceedings, similar submission was also argued in another case involving the family of Abdul Jaffar Abdul Mutalib, a car repossessor, who was allegedly shot dead by police in 2008.
The Government and police had appealed against a Court of Appeal ruling which awarded three daughters of Abdul Jaffar, a sum of RM351,000 in damages after the court allowed their claim for loss of dependency due to wrongful death of their father.
Federal Court Judge Tan Sri Suriyadi Halim Omar chairing a five-man bench reserved both judgments to a date to be fixed.
Bernama
Tue Jun 28 2016
![Kugan's family not entitled to receive RM300,000 in damages, court heard Kugan's family not entitled to receive RM300,000 in damages, court heard](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/http://img.astroawani.com/2016-06/41467105654_AKugan.jpg)
Kugan, 22, died in police custody in January 2009.
![Saya tidak fitnah Lim Guan Eng, cuma jelas tentang siasatan SPRM - Muhyiddin Saya tidak fitnah Lim Guan Eng, cuma jelas tentang siasatan SPRM - Muhyiddin](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/51721121786_MuhyiddinYassin.jpg)
Saya tidak fitnah Lim Guan Eng, cuma jelas tentang siasatan SPRM - Muhyiddin
Muhyiddin memberitahu bahawa beliau tidak memfitnah Lim Guan Eng berhubung isu pengecualian cukai terhadap Yayasan Albukhary.
![Saintis kesan gen bantu rawat kanser pankreas Saintis kesan gen bantu rawat kanser pankreas](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-04/81712376317_TujuanForensik.jpg)
Saintis kesan gen bantu rawat kanser pankreas
Gen HNF4A (Hepatocyte Nuclear Factor 4 Alpha) didapati akan berhenti berfungsi pada tubuh pesakit kanser pankreas.
Pantau Agenda Reformasi: Potensi dan cabaran percambahan e-Sukan di Malaysia
Pengerusi Gabungan Pelajar Melayu Semenanjung (GPMS) Negeri Selangor
merangkap Timbalan Presiden Majlis Belia Negeri Selangor
E-Sukan mampu mencetak nama Malaysia di pentas dunia. Memahami potensi, kekangan dan peranan yang perlu dimainkan semua pihak dalam melahirkan lebih ramai pemain E-Sukan yang berjaya, seterusnya menyokong pembangunan industri E-Sukan negara.
SRG cipta sejarah pasukan Malaysia pertama juarai MSC MLBB 2024
merangkap Timbalan Presiden Majlis Belia Negeri Selangor
E-Sukan mampu mencetak nama Malaysia di pentas dunia. Memahami potensi, kekangan dan peranan yang perlu dimainkan semua pihak dalam melahirkan lebih ramai pemain E-Sukan yang berjaya, seterusnya menyokong pembangunan industri E-Sukan negara.
SRG cipta sejarah pasukan Malaysia pertama juarai MSC MLBB 2024
Jualan kereta di Malaysia diunjur cecah 765,000 unit
Persatuan Automotif Malaysia (MAA) melakukan semakan semula berkaitan sasaran jumlah keseluruhan industri (TIV) kepada 765,000 unit berbanding unjuran awal 740,000 unit untuk 2024. Semakan dibuat disokong oleh persekitaran ekonomi yang positif dan jumlah tempatan tertunggak yang masih berada pada tahap yang baik
Kementerian Digital cari kaedah kurangkan kos pelaksanaan sistem e-invois
Kerajaan sedang mencari kaedah mengurangkan kos pelaksanaan sistem e-invois untuk Perusahaan Kecil dan Sederhana (PKS) selepas sistem itu diwajibkan untuk semua perniagaan pada 1 Julai 2025
Perbelanjaan pengguna dijangka meningkat tahun ini
Perbelanjaan Pengguna Malaysia dijangka meningkat sepanjang tahun ini
dengan unjuran sebanyak RM904.6 bilion, ketika proses pemulihan ekonomi menunjukkan kemajuan pada ketika ini.
dengan unjuran sebanyak RM904.6 bilion, ketika proses pemulihan ekonomi menunjukkan kemajuan pada ketika ini.
![Suspek bunuh Nur Farah Kartini dibawa ke lokasi kejadian Suspek bunuh Nur Farah Kartini dibawa ke lokasi kejadian](https://resizer-awani.eco.astro.com.my/tr:w-177,h-100,q-100,f-auto/https://img.astroawani.com/2024-07/71721123609_lokasi.jpg)
Suspek bunuh Nur Farah Kartini dibawa ke lokasi kejadian
Suspek kes pembunuhan Nur Farah Kartini Abdullah dibawa ke lokasi kejadian di ladang kelapa sawit di Kampung Sri Keledang, Hulu Bernam, Selangor.
Beberapa kementerian bincang perketat undang-undang - Fahmi
Penambahbaikan aspek perundangan akan diteliti kerajaan, termasuk mengadakan perbincangan dengan beberapa kementerian berkaitan dalam masa terdekat, bagi memperketatkan undang-undang berkaitan buli siber.
Denda terhadap syarikat ADSSB lewat bekal Black Hawk
Adly berkata, pihak ADSSB juga turut telah memohon tuntutan lanjutan masa kedua kepada pihak kementerian.
Faisal Halim berduka pemergian Kim Pan-gon
Pemain kebangsaan, Faisal Halim, meluahkan rasa kekecewaan menerusi laman Instagramnya ekoran pengumuman mengejut Kim Pan-gon meletakkan jawatan sebagai Ketua Jurulatih Skuad Kebangsaan serta-merta.
Sebelum ini, jurulatih berusia 55 tahun itu meluangkan masa melawat tonggak Selangor itu ketika dimasukkan ke hospital akibat terkena simbahan asid di sebuah pusat beli belah di Lembah Klang.
Sebelum ini, jurulatih berusia 55 tahun itu meluangkan masa melawat tonggak Selangor itu ketika dimasukkan ke hospital akibat terkena simbahan asid di sebuah pusat beli belah di Lembah Klang.