PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today ruled that the coroner who heard the inquest into fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim's death has the jurisdiction to issue leave to commence committal proceedings against former Attorney-General (AG) Tan Sri Tommy Thomas.
In a unanimous decision, a three-member bench chaired by Justice Datuk Suraya Othman said a coroner has the jurisdiction and power to hear and punish for any kind of contempt, albeit in the face of a court or out of court.
She said, the court also found that there was no merit in the argument by counsel Datuk S. Ambiga, who represented Thomas, that a Magistrate's power to punish was limited to contempt in the face of the court alone, due to the words used in the provision.
"In Paragraph 26 of the Third Schedule of the Subordinate Courts Act 1948, the words "power to take cognisance of any contempt of court" are used to outline the sentencing for matters of contempt at the Sessions Court and the Magistrate's Court.
"Ambiga had submitted to the court that the words meant the Magistrate's Court only has the power to deal with contempt of court in the face of the court and not outside of the court. The cases cited by Ambiga were not applicable in Malaysia under Section 3 (1) of the Civil Law Act 1956.
"Therefore, we find no merit in this appeal. Hence, we dismiss the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) appeal on whether the Coroner's Court has the jurisdiction to hear and decide on committal proceedings," said the judge who sat with Justices Datuk Abu Bakar Jais and Datuk Hashim Hamzah.
The decision was delivered during a virtual proceeding today. Present were Thomas' counsel, Ambiga and Zainur Zakaria, while lawyer Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdulla acted for Muhammad Adib's father, Mohd Kassim Abdul Hamid.
After the ruling was delivered, Zainur said they had been instructed to appeal to the Federal Court and then applied for the appellate court to stay the other appeal proceedings by Mohd Kassim, pending disposal of the appeal at the Federal Court.
Mohamed Haniff Khatri informed the panel that they reserve the right to raise an objection before the Federal Court, on whether Thomas could even appeal to the apex court.
He said this was because Thomas' appeal actually was against the Coroner's Court decision, which sits at a level below the High Court.
Justice Suraya allowed the application to stay Mohd Kassim's appeal, adding that this was because an appeal to the Federal Court involved the important point of the lower court's jurisdiction to hear contempt proceedings.
The other two appeals that were brought by Mohd Kassim included the appeal against a High Court's decision in setting aside the coroner's decision to give him leave to initiate committal proceedings against Thomas.
In his application, Mohd Kassim claimed that Thomas had insulted the court through an affidavit filed by the AGC on April 3, 2019, regarding the cause of his son's death.
Muhammad Adib, 24, who was a member of the emergency medical rescue services (EMRS) at the Subang Jaya Fire and Rescue station, was seriously injured in a riot at the Sri Maha Mariamman Temple, USJ 25, on Nov 27, 2018.
He died on Dec 17 2018 after 21 days at the National Heart Institute (IJN).
On Sept 27, 2019, the Coroner's Court ruled that Muhammad Adib's death was a result of a criminal act by more than two people.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Feb 08 2022
After the ruling was delivered, Zainur said they had been instructed to appeal to the Federal Court. - Astro AWANI
Suruhanjaya Eropah saman Hungary atas dakwaan pelanggaran hak asasi
Budapest gagal hilangkan kebimbangan mengenai undang-undang baharu Hungary yang bertujuan mengehadkan pembiayaan asing bagi kempen politik.
PM Pakistan gembira atas perbincangan produktif dengan PM Malaysia
Bidang-bidang utama itu termasuk perdagangan, IT, tenaga, pertanian, eksport daging halal, pelancongan, pendidikan dan pertahanan.
Rwanda catat 7 lagi kes virus Marburg dan satu lagi kematian
Rwanda mencatatkan tujuh kes baharu penyakit virus Marburg dan satu lagi kematian.
Menurut angka terkini yang dikeluarkan lewat Rabu Kementerian Kesihatan Rwanda,
jumlah keseluruhan jangkitan virus Marburg sejak wabak bermula kini sebanyak 36 kes, dengan 11 kematian dilaporkan setakat ini.
Menurut angka terkini yang dikeluarkan lewat Rabu Kementerian Kesihatan Rwanda,
jumlah keseluruhan jangkitan virus Marburg sejak wabak bermula kini sebanyak 36 kes, dengan 11 kematian dilaporkan setakat ini.
Lebih 140 sekolah UNRWA diserang sejak 7 Oktober
Lebih 140 sekolah UNRWA diserang sejak 7 Oktober dalam keadaan dimana penduduk Gaza berlindung di bawah naungan PBB.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Pesuruhjaya Agung Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) Philippe Lazzarini dalam satu hantaran di X.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Pesuruhjaya Agung Agensi Bantuan dan Kerja Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu untuk Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) Philippe Lazzarini dalam satu hantaran di X.
28 petugas dilapor maut dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu di Lubnan
28 petugas kesihatan dilaporkan terbunuh dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu di Lubnan.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Ketua Pengarah Pertubuhan Kesihatan Sedunia (WHO) Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus pada Khamis.
Perkara itu dimaklumkan Ketua Pengarah Pertubuhan Kesihatan Sedunia (WHO) Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus pada Khamis.
UNIFIL kekal pada posisi walaupun didesak berundur
Pasukan pengaman PBB di selatan Lubnan terus bertahan pada kedudukan mereka, di bawah mandat UNSC, walaupun diarah Israel untuk berundur.
G7 desak pemain serantau di Asia Barat bertindak cermat dalam krisis
Pemimpin Kumpulan Tujuh (G7) mengulangi kebimbangan mereka terhadap krisis di Asia Barat dan menyeru pemain serantau supaya bertindak dengan bertanggungjawab serta berhemah.
Mereka turut menegaskan sokongan penuh terhadap keselamatan Israel.
Mereka turut menegaskan sokongan penuh terhadap keselamatan Israel.
AS sokong operasi Israel di Lubnan meski risiko meluaskan konflik
Pentadbiran Joe Biden menyatakan bahawa adalah wajar untuk Israel meneruskan serangan darat dan udara terhadap Hezbollah buat masa ini, menurut jurucakap Jabatan Negara Amerika Syarikat, Matthew Miller.
Namun, beliau mengakui risiko operasi di Lubnan mungkin melangkaui matlamat semasa Israel.
Namun, beliau mengakui risiko operasi di Lubnan mungkin melangkaui matlamat semasa Israel.
Shamsul Iskandar dakwa kesepakatan parti dalam PN kian longgar
Shamsul Iskandar berkata, perpecahan dalaman PN itu dapat diukur melalui prestasi mereka pada PRK DUN Nenggiri dan DUN Mahkota.
Politik stabil, dasar kerajaan tarik minat syarikat global melabur di Malaysia - Gobind
Menurut Menteri Digital Gobind Singh Deo, pada masa ini terdapat banyak perbincangan, tidak hanya antara syarikat-syarikat di negara serantau malah dunia berhubung perkara itu.