PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal here today dismissed the appeals brought by four organisations which sought a declaration that the existence and establishment of vernacular schools and the use of Chinese and Tamil languages in those schools are unconstitutional.
The four organisations are Islamic Education Development Council (Mappim) and the Confederation of Malaysian Writers Association (Gapena), Ikatan Muslimin Malaysia (Isma) and Ikatan Guru-Guru Muslim Malaysia (I-Guru).
The decision was delivered by a three-man panel comprising Justices Datuk Supang Lian, Datuk M. Gunalan and Datuk Azizul Azmi Adnan today.
Justice Azizul, who delivered the court's unanimous decision, said national-type schools or vernacular schools are not public authorities and as such the use of Tamil or Chinese languages as the medium of instruction for teaching in these schools are not prohibited.
He said the Kuala Lumpur High Court had correctly decided that the use of Tamil or Chinese in national-type schools or vernacular schools as a medium of instruction is protected by the proviso of Article 152(1)(b) of the Federal Constitution.
"We are of the view that a school is neither a statutory authority nor a public authority, and the use of a language other than Malay in national-type schools as a medium of instruction would not be for official purposes," said Justice Azizul.
He said a contextual construction of the relevant provisions of the Federal Constitution did not support the appellants' contention that the provisions of the Education Act 1996 which provided for the establishment and maintenance of schools that uses Tamil or Chinese as a medium of instruction were inconsistent with Article 152 (1) (a) of the Federal Constitution.
"Article 152 (1) (b) of the Federal Constitution has the effect of 'grandfathering' the use of other languages at the time of the proclamation of Merdeka," he said, adding that nothing in that provision limiting the right of the government to preserve the use of other languages in those schools and to take steps to sustain its continued use.
He said the government's right to preserve and sustain the use of other languages in national-type schools or vernacular schools overrides the proviso in Article 152 (1) (a) which states that the Malay language shall be the language used for official purposes.
"It cannot seriously be argued that the framers of the Constitution had intended for schools employing a language other than Malay or English as a medium of instruction to be unlawful and contrary to the terms of the Constitution, for if this were the case, such schools would have been shut down, abolished or converted upon the adoption of the Federal Constitution," he said.
Meanwhile, the panel allowed a cross-appeal brought by representatives Chinese educationist groups Dong Zong and Jiao Zong to set aside the Kota Bharu High Court's determination that vernacular schools were "public authorities".
On Dec 29, 2021, High Court judge Datuk Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali (now Court of Appeal judge) dismissed the lawsuits brought by GPMS, Mappim, Gapena and Isma. GPMS did not file the appeal to the Court of Appeal.
On May 29, last year, the Kota Bahru High Court judicial commissioner Abazafree Mohd Abbas (now High Court judge) also ruled that the existence of vernacular schools is constitutional and he dismissed the suit filed by I-Guru.
In their suits, the four organisations wanted the court to declare three sections in the Education Act 1996 which allows Chinese and Tamil schools to teach in these languages were inconsistent with Article 152 of the Federal Constitution.
They also sought a declaration that the establishment and existence of vernacular schools infringed Articles 5 (right to a dignified life), 8 (equality), 10 (freedom of speech, assembly and association), 11 (freedom in religion) and 12 (rights in respect of education) of the Federal Constitution.
In the suit filed in Dec 2019, GPMS, Mappim and Gapena and Isma sued several parties including the government and 13 other defendants. Among them were Dong Zong and Jiao Zong, Persatuan Thamizhar Malaysia, Persatuan Tamilar Thurunal (Perak) and four political parties - MIC, MCA, Gerakan and Parti Bumiputera Perkasa Malaysia.
As for I-Guru, the organisation sued the Education Minister, the government of Malaysia, seeking for a declaration that section 28 and section 17 of the Education Act 1996 are inconsistent with Article 152 of the Federal Constitution and it is void and of no effect.
The Chinese Language Council, the Tamil Language Association and the Confederation of Former Tamil School Pupils, MCA and the United Chinese School Committees Association of Malaysia (Dong Zong) were allowed to become interveners in the suit filed by I-Guru.
Lawyers Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdullah represented Mappim and Gapena, while lawyer Mohd Khairul Azam Abdul Aziz appeared for Isma and lawyer Ramesh NP Chandran represented I-Guru while a team from the Attorney-General's Chambers led by senior federal counsel Liew Horng Bin appeared for the Education Minister and the Government of Malaysia.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Thu Nov 23 2023
In the court's decision, Justice Azizul Azmi Adnan said vernacular school is not a public authority and as such the use of Tamil and Mandarin languages as the medium of instruction for teaching in those schools are constitutional. - Filepic
Pelajar tahfiz perlu teroka bidang teknologi
Kira-kira 200,000 pelajar tahfiz di negara ini, perlu dipastikan untuk mempunyai kemampuan dan peluang menjadi tenaga penggerak kepada umat Islam Malaysia dalam meneroka bidang yang dahulu dilihat sebagai asing., tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Perpaduan rakyat prasyarat ekonomi mampan
Tidak semua negara Islam mempunyai ruang dan kesempatan untuk terus aman dan damai, dan mempunyai peluang untuk menikmati ekonomi yang kukuh dan berkembang seperti Malaysia, tegas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Beliau berkata, rakyat Malaysia perlu mempunyai tekad untuk memahami maksud dan keperluan perpaduan di kalangan mereka, serta kekuatan dalaman yang seterusnya dapat dijadikan tonggak untuk negara membuat langkah seterusnya.
Tidak perlu tergesa-gesa tukar ke lesen B - JPJ
Pemegang Lesen Memandu Malaysia (LMM) Kelas B2 dan B1 tidak perlu tergesa-gesa mendaftar Program Khas Peralihan LLM Kelas B2/B1 Kepada LMM Kelas B kerana tiada had masa ditetapkan untuk permohonan.
KPWKM teruskan lapan inisiatif bantu warga emas
Kementerian Pembangunan Wanita, Keluarga dan Masyarakat (KPWKM) akan terus menggerakkan lapan inisiatif utama dalam memenuhi keperluan jagaan dan sistem sokongan terhadap warga emas.
Warga emas maut ditikam anak kandung yang berhalusinasi
Seorang pesara guru maut ditikam anak kandungnya sendiri di sebuah rumah dekat Kampung Senaling, di sini, petang Sabtu.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Menurut Ketua Polis Daerah Kuala Pilah, Superintendan Amran Mohd Ghani, siasatan awal mendapati warga emas berusia 65 tahun itu cuba memujuk anak lelakinya yang juga pemegang kad orang kurang upaya (OKU) mental yang dikatakan mahu membunuh diri.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Sabtu, 5 Oktober 2024.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Hezbollah lancar serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kompleks industri ketenteraan di utara Israel
Pergerakan Hezbollah di Lubnan berkata mereka telah melancarkan serangan peluru berpandu ke atas kemudahan ATA Defence Industries.
Tiada kaitan dengan pelantikan CEO MDEC, Anuar Fariz bukan adik saya - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil menyangkal dakwaan Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif (CEO) baharu Perbadanan Ekonomi Digital Malaysia (MDEC) Anuar Fariz Fadzil merupakan adiknya.
Israel lakukan persiapan untuk serang Iran - Laporan
Tentera Israel sedang bersiap untuk "tindakan balas besar-besaran dan ekstrem" terhadap Iran.