Since mid-August, the Islamic State has released three execution videos of three Western hostages. We're all sadly familiar with these brutal productions, but what strikes many is how collected and articulate the victims are while giving their final speeches denouncing their home governments. Why weren't they terrified? Why didn't they fight back? I admit I have no idea how I would have composed myself facing imminent death.
But after watching many of these types of videos, here are three points that might explain why James Foley, Steven Sotloff and David Haines gave the propaganda speeches they did.
The hostages may not have known they were to be murdered. There's something odd about all of the Islamic State's productions: They never show the hostage actually being killed. Rather, the video always cuts away right before the deed is done. This suggests that the hostages didn't realize they were about to be killed.
This might have been on purpose. In the past, the Islamic State's predecessors had no compunction about telling many of their captives of their impending end. In these videos from the Iraq war, some hostages seem to be in a catatonic trance, meekly awaiting their fate. But the few that gave speeches before their beheading were at their wit's end. I recall one hostage in particular who begged at length for his life on his video; his killers showed him no mercy. It was awful to watch, though I had to for my job as a CIA analyst.
Yet others remain defiant even up to the end. In 2004, an Italian security contractor in Iraq named Fabrizio Quattrocchi, captured by the Army of Islam, yelled, "I'll show you how an Italian dies!" and tried to remove his hood right before being shot.
But those individuals unambiguously knew the end was coming. For the Islamic State's more recent Western victims — the composed interviewees we see on tape — they simply may not have known what was going to occur, which allowed them to remain articulate and compliant in their final hours.
Even if they suspected they'd die at some point, they were under enormous pressure to comply with their captors. Remember that these hostages had been in captivity for many months, suffering both physically and psychologically. Of the Islamic State's three Western victims, Foley had been a hostage since November 2012, Haines since March 2013 and Sotloff since August 2013.
These men were undoubtedly treated with great cruelty and threatened with death numerous times. We know this because one French journalist held with James Foley said he had to endure several mock executions. Further, John Cantlie — who has recently resurfaced in another Islamic State video — had been a hostage in Syria beforehand, being held by a group of jihadists who blindfolded, hooded and frequently told him they wanted to kill him. Chances are the three beheading victims were held in similar circumstances.
These extreme conditions can take a terrible toll on a person's emotional well-being. As such, the hostages might have thought making pro-ISIS speeches were yet another indignity they had to endure. They might have also taken heart knowing that viewers would see the messages as clearly coerced. The most famous Vietnam War era prisoner message, for instance, featured Cmdr. Jeremiah Denton, who had to submit to a propaganda film on behalf of North Vietnamese captors in 1966. He showed great tenacity by blinking the word "T-O-R-T-U-R-E" with his eyelids in Morse code.
The hostages might have known the end was coming, and accepted it. But this is the least convincing of all the explanations. Both Foley and Sotloff speak of their own deaths in an abstract way, and the last hostage, David Haines, explicitly discusses his impending execution. Given the rehearsed, calm nature of their speeches, however, this does not seem especially likely.
Hostages rarely, if ever, speak their true thoughts in propaganda films and videos. (Denton, who defended U.S. policy and paid for it with years of beatings, was a rare exception.) Otherwise, it undermines the purpose of turning out propaganda in the first place, which is to disseminate a message and advance a political cause. If the three men were calm in their speeches, it's not because they were actually at peace.
- By Aki Peritz
Peritz is a former CIA counterterrorism analyst and coauthor of "Find, Fix, Finish: Inside the Counterterrorism Campaigns that Killed bin Laden and Devastated Al Qaeda."
The Washington Post
Wed Sep 24 2014
These men were undoubtedly treated with great cruelty and threatened with death numerous times.
Penyanyi Sean Diddy ditangakp di New York
Penerbit muzik terkenal, Puff Daddy atau lebih dikenali sebagai Sean Diddy Combs yang berdepan dengan beberapa tuduhan serangan seksual telah diberkas di Manhatann, New York oleh ejen persekutuan pada Isnin waktu tempatan.
10 maut, puluhan cedera bas Iran terbalik
Menurut angka awal, kemalangan itu mengakibatkan 10 maut dan 41 cedera.
Malaysia perlu melabur dalam infrastruktur
Pengarah Eksekutif Ukrainian Prism, Hennadiy Maksak berpandangan, Malaysia juga tidak boleh bergantung kepada satu laluan, selain menjalin hubungan yang baik dengan negara-negara jiran.
Lebih 1,000 rakyat termasuk pejuang Hezbollah cedera parah
Lebih seribu rakyat Lubnan termasuk anggota pejuang Hezbollah dan petugas perubatan cedera parah dalam satu letupan pada Selasa.
Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional memudahkan operasi perdagangan antara Malaysia dan China
Menteri Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI), Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz berpendapat inisiatif Tetingkap Tunggal Nasional (National single window) yang bakal diharmonikan Bersama system kastam China akan memudahkan operasi perniagaan dan perdagangan (ease of doing business) antara Malaysia dan China.
Medan selera perlu ditambah baik, kemudahan asas tidak lengkap
Air bergenang di lantai dan tempias sehingga meja makan mengakibatkan pengunjung basah. Itu situasi apabila keadaan hujan lebat di Medan Selera Taman Makmur di dalam Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Mahkota yang menempatkan deretan 12 kedai makan.
Calon manfaat platform media sosial dekati pengundi luar
Kempen Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Mahkota turut memberi tumpuan kepada penggunaan media sosial bagi menambat hati pengundi luar selain kempen secara bersemuka.
Seorang wanita maut jatuh lubang saluran air
Seorang wanita maut selepas terjatuh ke dalam lubang saluran air sedalam dua meter ketika menyertai aktiviti mendaki di Bukit Cherok Tok Kun pada Selasa.
Kerja pembersihan sisa kimia dijalankan pada Selasa
Kerja-kerja pembersihan sisa bahan kimia yang dibuang secara haram di Kawasan Perindustrian Tiong Nam dan Kawasan Perindustrian Tropika, Johor bermula pada Selasa.
Suara Rakyat: Ibu bapa gesa UPSR, PT3 dikembalikan semula
Ibu bapa menggesa supaya Ujian Pencapaian Sekolah Rendah (UPSR) dan Pentaksiran Tingkatan Tiga (PT3) dikembalikan secepat mungkin bagi membolehkan penilaian kecenderungan kanak-kanak dibuat dari peringkat awal.
Thirteen siblings rescued from California house, parents charged
Thirteen siblings aged between 2 and 29, were rescued by police in California from a house where some of them had been chained by their parents.