SAN FRANCISCO: Tesla Inc Elon Musk "lied" when he said that funding was "secured" to take the company private, a lawyer for Tesla investors said on Wednesday, as an attorney for Musk argued that the billionaire merely used the "wrong words" when he tweeted about his plans in 2018.
Tesla investor Glen Littleton is seeking damages on behalf of shareholders who traded the company's stock in the days after Musk posted his plan to take the company private on Twitter in August 2018.
Musk's alleged lies caused "regular people" to lose millions, Nicholas Porritt, lead attorney for the investors, told a jury in San Francisco during opening statements.
"Millions of dollars were lost when his lies were exposed," he added.
Musk's lawyer disputed this characterization, saying that the billionaire was "serious" about taking the company private in 2018, but ultimately encountered shareholder opposition.
"You will come to learn very soon that this was not fraud, not even close," Alex Spiro said during opening statements.
Musk believed that financing was not an issue and was "taking steps" to make a deal happen, Spiro told the jury.
While the tweets contained "technical inaccuracies," Musk was concerned that some investors knew about his go-private plan and wanted to get the information out to the "everyday shareholder" that he "wanted to protect," Spiro said.
"In a rush, he used the wrong words," he said.
The case is a rare securities class action trial, and Musk and his company are bucking the norm of settling claims that clear high legal hurdles, making for a potentially dramatic trial at which Musk himself is expected to take the stand as early as this week.
A jury of nine will decide whether the tweets artificially inflated Tesla's share price by playing up the status of funding for the deal, and if so, by how much.
The defendants include current and former Tesla directors, whom Spiro said had "pure" motives in their response to Musk's plan.
Testimony concluded on Wednesday after nearly three hours from the first witness, Littleton. The trial will resume on Friday with an expert witness and might include Musk taking the stand.
Littleton said he began investing in Tesla in 2015 as Musk was "bringing new ideas to life" in the technology industry.
The self-employed investor said he viewed Musk's "funding secured" statement as "absolute."
Littleton said he scrambled to unwind his Tesla options positions, which the tweet made unprofitable.
On cross-examination, William Price, who represents the defendants, sought to show Littleton was motivated by Musk's bid to take Tesla private, and not on "funding secured," which is what the lawsuit challenges as fraudulent.
U.S. District Judge Edward Chen, who is overseeing the trial, has ruled that Musk's statements about the status of the deal were false and Musk made them recklessly. The deal did not happen.
While shareholders sue hundreds of companies and their executives for alleged securities fraud every year, very few of those cases make it to trial. The vast majority are either dismissed by courts or settle.
Not among the jurors selected on Tuesday were some critics of Musk, such as one potential juror who said the chief executive, who has gained a reputation for the unpredictable, was "a little off his rocker."
Reuters
Thu Jan 19 2023
Musk believed that financing was not an issue and was "taking steps" to make a deal happen, Spiro told the jury. - REUTERS/Filepic
24 orang terbunuh selepas Israel serang masjid, sekolah di Gaza
Sekurang-kurangnya 24 orang terbunuh manakala 93 lagi cedera akibat serangan udara Israel di sebuah masjid dan sebuah sekolah yang menempatkan penduduk Gaza pada Ahad.
Israel tingkat serangan udara di timur Lubnan
Hampir semua bangunan di bandar lama Baalbek di Timur Lubnan musnah selepas rejim zionis meningkatkan serangan udaranya pada Ahad.
Jokowi seru sentiasa berwaspada di tengah-tengah cabaran global
Presiden Joko Widodo menyeru Tentera Nasional Indonesia (TNI) untuk sentiasa berwaspada dan bersiap sedia ketika negara berdepan dengan cabaran global yang semakin meningkat.
Pesawat Frontier Airlines terbakar ketika mendarat
Pesawat penerbangan 1326 Frontier Airlines terbakar ketika mendarat di Lapangan Terbang Antarabangsa Harry Reid di Las Vegas, Nevada.
7 maut termasuk dua kanak-kanak di Maharashtra
Sekurang-kurangnya tujuh orang termasuk dua kanak-kanak maut dan beberapa lagi cedera selepas kebakaran besar berlaku di sebuah bangunan di Maharashtra, Mumbai.
Kejadian tembak di Selama, polis tahan pemilik kebun
Polis menahan seorang lelaki tempatan kerana disyaki terlibat kes tembakan sehingga menyebabkan seorang individu cedera di Kampung Sumpit Beras, Rantau Panjang dekat Selama Jumaat lepas.
Kedai runcit simpan, cuci sayuran dalam tandas sebelum dijual
Sebuah kedai runcit diusahakan seorang warga asing dikesan melakukan pelbagai kesalahan kepenggunaan termasuk menyimpan sayur-sayuran di dalam tandas premis itu.
8,500 premis diberi amaran susulan pelaksanaan Akta 852 - Dzulkefly
Sejumlah 8,500 premis di seluruh negara diberi amaran kerana melanggar Akta Kawalan Produk Merokok Demi Kesihatan Awam 2024 (Akta 852) yang berkuat kuasa pada 1 Okt lepas.
JDT raih kejuaraan berganda, julang Piala Futsal Malaysia 2024
Skuad futsal Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT) meraih kejuaraan berganda musim ini apabila muncul juara Piala Futsal Malaysia 2024 selepas menewaskan Selangor 3-2.
AWANI Ringkas: 21 warga Bangladesh ditahan cuba masuk Malaysia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.