NEW YORK: Ed Sheeran's 2014 hit "Thinking Out Loud" did not unlawfully copy from Marvin Gaye's classic 1973 song "Let's Get It On," a jury decided on Thursday in a closely watched copyright lawsuit - a verdict that the British pop star said would help protect the creative process for song writers in the U.S. and globally.
The jury in Manhattan federal court determined that heirs of "Let's Get It On" songwriter Ed Townsend had not proven that Sheeran, his label Warner Music Group and his music publisher Sony Music Publishing had infringed their copyright interest in the Gaye song. Sheeran hugged his attorneys in the courtroom after the verdict was read.
"It's devastating to be accused of stealing someone else's song when we've put so much work into our livelihoods," Sheeran said outside the courthouse following the verdict.
"I want to thank the jury for making the decision that will help protect the creative process for song writers here in the United States and all around the world," Sheeran added.
The verdict came after six days of trial and less than three hours of jury deliberations.
Townsend's heirs sued Sheeran for copyright infringement in 2017, contending that "Thinking Out Loud" copied the "heart" of Gaye's song including its melody, harmony and rhythm. Sheeran's attorneys argued that any similarities between the songs involve basic musical "building blocks" that cannot be copyrighted.
The plaintiffs asked for a share of the profits from "Thinking Out Loud." The heirs said in a court filing that they received 22% of the writer's share of Gaye's song from Townsend.
"I'm just a guy with a guitar who loves writing music for people to enjoy. I am not and will never allow myself to be a piggy bank for anyone to shake," Sheeran said after the verdict.
PLAYING A CHORD PROGRESSION
Testifying during the trial, Sheeran denied the copyright infringement claims, telling the jury, "I find it really insulting to devote my whole life to being a performer and a songwriter and have someone diminish it."
Sheeran on the witness stand played the chord progression to "Thinking Out Loud" and sang the opening words: "When your legs don't work like they used to." Sheeran testified that his friend and collaborator Amy Wadge first started strumming the chords for the song during a visit to his home in England, and that they collaborated on the lyrics.
Ben Crump, a lawyer representing the heirs, told jurors that Sheeran effectively confessed to ripping off Gaye's song when he performed it live in concert as a medley with "Thinking Out Loud."
Sheeran testified that singers frequently perform such "mash ups," and that he had on other occasions combined his song with Van Morrison's "Crazy Love" and Dolly Parton's "I Will Always Love You."
Juror Sophia Neis, 23, told reporters afterward that there had been "a lot of back and forth" in the jury room before the panel made its decision.
Lawyers for Townsend's heirs did not immediately respond to a request for comment after the verdict.
Gaye, who died in 1984, collaborated with Townsend, who died in 2003, to write "Let's Get It On," which topped the Billboard charts. Sheeran's "Thinking Out Loud" peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 2015.
Two similar lawsuits are pending against Sheeran in Manhattan, brought by investment banker and "Bowie Bonds" creator David Pullman's Structured Asset Sales LLC, which also owns copyright interests in the Gaye song.
Pullman said after the verdict that he and his lawyers had learned from the trial.
"We'll know what to expect," Pullman said.
Pullman said one of his lawsuits in particular would be different because it involved a copyright on the recording of "Let's Get It On," rather than just the sheet music. Jurors in that case would be able to hear Gaye's original hit, rather than the computerized rendition played in the now-completed trial, Pullman said.
Sheeran won a trial in London last year in a separate copyright case over his hit "Shape of You." Gaye's heirs won an important verdict in 2015 when a jury in Los Angeles agreed with the claims that the Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams song "Blurred Lines" copied Gaye's "Got to Give It Up."
Reuters
Fri May 05 2023
Singer Ed Sheeran departs the Manhattan federal court following after winning his copyright lawsuit in New York City, U.S., May 4, 2023. - REUTERS
Sheikh Al-Azhar tamatkan lawatan khas di Malaysia
Sheikh Al-Azhar hari ini menamatkan lawatan khas empat hari ke Malaysia atas undangan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Prof Said Bani individu pertama dari Malaysia raih anugerah ‘Communicator of The Year’ IABC Asia Pasifik
Bani catat sejarah pengamal komunikasi pertama Malaysia terima anugerah 'Communicator of The Year' IABC Asia Pasifik dalam kategori Senior Communication Professional.
Analisis pasaran saham separuh tahun kedua 2024
Apakah rumusan prestasi pasaran saham pada separuh tahun pertama 2024 dan apakah faktor-faktor yang akan menjadi perhatian pelabur dalam pasaran saham separuh tahun kedua 2024? Kupasan lanjut bersama Ketua, MIDF Research, Imran Yassin Md Yusof.
63 PATI pelbagai warganegara di Perak dihantar pulang ke negara asal
Kesemua PATI itu terdiri daripada warganegara Indonesia, Pakistan, Vietnam, Bangladesh, India dan Indonesia.
Malaysia Digital (MD): Advancing Malaysia’s Digital Future
Explore the impact of the recent MD Open Day event and its key insights. Discover how it aligns with Malaysia’s growth strategy and benefits both businesses and the public. Join us for an exclusive live interview with Ts Mahadhir Aziz, CEO of MDEC, on Niaga AWANI.
Akta Audit: Tingkat ketelusan & kecekapan tadbir urus
Dewan Rakyat pada Rabu meluluskan RUU Audit (Pindaan) 2024 yang bertujuan meluaskan kuasa Ketua Audit Negara bagi memeriksa, menyiasat dan mengaudit akaun mana-mana badan lain. Adakah ini memadai? Apa lagi tambah baik yang perlu dilakukan?
Laporan PAC: Levi majikan hanya digunakan untuk latihan kemahiran - PSMB
PSMB menegaskan bahawa levi majikan sememangnya hanya digunakan untuk tujuan latihan pekerja mereka sahaja selama ini.
Lebih 20 subkontraktor Lebuhraya DASH lantik peguam tuntut bayaran tertunggak RM100 juta dari Prolintas
Menurut Tetuan Thomas Philip, walaupun lebuh raya itu telah dibuka kepada orang ramai, banyak subkontraktor masih tidak dibayar atas kerja mereka.
AWANI Pagi: Berhadapan individu narsistik? Apa perlu saya buat
EPL: Erik ten Hag gembira lanjut kontrak di Manchester United
Manchester United mengesahkan Erik ten Hag telah menandatangani lanjutan kontrak yang akan bertahan hingga penghujung musim 2025-26.
"Badminton amat besar di Malaysia" - Ed Sheeran
Ed Sheeran bermain badminton dengan legenda beregu campuran negara, Chan Peng Soon.
Sidang Kemuncak ASEAN 2025: Pastikan semua negeri dapat limpahan ekonomi - Fahmi
Katanya, Anwar juga menggesa agar semua cenderahati sempena penganjuran sidang kemuncak itu berkonsepkan kraf tangan Malaysia.
Mahkamah AS putuskan Ed Sheeran tidak ciplak lagu
Ed Sheeran sifatkan keputusan itu akan membantu melindungi proses kreatif untuk penulis lagu di AS dan seluruh dunia.
Ed Sheeran dituduh cetak rompak lagu Marvin Gaye
Sheeran menafikan dia telah meniru lirik lagu Gaye yang diterbitkan pada tahun 1973.
Album baharu 'ubat kemurungan', Ed Sheeran dedah isteri hidap tumor
Berkongsi detik sukar itu, Ed Sheeran berkata keadaan bertambah sukar apabila sahabatnya, Jamal Edwards meninggal dunia secara mengejut.
Ed Sheeran sekali lagi naik mahkamah, didakwa plagiat lagu
Ed Sheeran akan dibicarakan berhubung dakwaan memplagiat lagu hitnya, Thinking Out Loud daripada lagu Let's Get It On nyanyian Marvin Gaye.
Dapat anak perempuan lagi, Ed Sheeran umum kelahiran bayi keduanya
Ed Sheran berkongsi berita gembira itu di akaun Instagram miliknya baru-baru ini.
Ed Sheeran menang kes pertikaian hak cipta lagu 'Shape of You'
Mahkamah Tinggi London memutuskan Ed Sheeran tidak menciplak lagu 'Oh Why' dendangan Sami Chokri.
Ed Sheeran temui peminat menerusi konsert dalam talian pada 13 November ini
Konsert ini membolehkan peminat merasai sendiri kekuatan unik muzik pop Sheeran selepas dia kembali dari berehat di musim pandemik COVID-19.
Ed Sheeran umum positif COVID-19
Walaupun sedang menjalani isolasi, beliau berkata akan terus memberikan wawancara dan persembahan yang dirancang dari rumah.